Girl Guides Go Back To God After Dispute Over New Wording Of Traditional Pledge


The Girlguiding movement offered a concession tonight to Christian campaigners over its decision to adopt a secular promise as the Church of England called for Brownies and Guides to be allowed to continue to pledge to love God.

A spokeswoman said it remained committed to one promise for all and the wording of its new pledge of allegiance which drops the promise to "love my God" in favour of the phrase "to be true to myself and develop my beliefs."

But she said the organisation had taken on board the views of a "minority" of its members who "struggle" with the new wording and has suggested that they can provide the "context of their own belief" if they wish before making the promise.

"This wording has been in place since September last year and has been welcomed by many members both of faith and no faith who have embraced the inclusivity it enables.

Terry Sanderson, president of the National Secular Society, blasted the decision: "It really is very arrogant of these churches to put such pressure on an entirely independent organisation.

"The fact that some Guide groups meet in church halls and perhaps receive some other kind of 'sponsorship' does not mean that they are beholden to comply with every demand from the church.

"As in so many other areas, the churches seem to think that they have a right to impose their own rules on to other people, some of whom just don't want them."

The announcement was made after members of the General Synod congratulated the Girlguiding organisation on its work but said women and girls should be able to continue to promise to love God when enrolled.

Under proposals backed by the Church of England, Guides who chose to do so should be able to preface the new promise with the phrase "In the presence of God I make my Guide promise."

Alison Ruoff, from the London Diocese, called for the old promise to be reinstated as an alternative to the new pledge.

She said many Guide units meet on church premises and to be banned from saying I "love my God" "cannot be right."

Mrs Ruoff said units in Jesmond church in the Newcastle Diocese have said they want to only use the old promise. "I have to say the pressure on their leaders to change to the secular promise has been enormous," she said.

"Leaders and girls who are Christians and I am talking about the Christian faith in particular, are faced with choosing between their faith and Guiding," she said.

But Alison Wynne, from Leyland, in the Blackburn Diocese, said the expression to be "true to myself" could lead to chaos.

"We all know of course that human beings are all sinful and a promise to be true to yourself, to do what is right in my own mind will only lead to chaos," she said.

"I wonder where being true to myself leaves Guides or Brownies to disregard their leaders' instructions on camp and wander off into the woods late at night or refuse to wear their uniforms because the colour doesn't suit me or choose to bring alcohol along to group meetings?"

But the Rev Jeremy Fletcher, from Beverley, in the York Diocese, praised the "fabulous" "superb and sacrificial" work of Girlguiding.

"It does seem to me a bit rude sending Girlguiding's homework back and saying they could do better. I don't know whether it is our place to do that," he said.

Before You Go