Stella McCartney Apologises For 'Appalling Image' Of 'Very Ill' Model On Instagram

Stella McCartney Removes Image Of 'Very Ill' Model
|

Stella McCartney has apologised for posting an image of what some described as a "very ill" looking model on Instagram.

The picture in question showed model JiHye Park backstage at the brand's Paris Fashion Week show.

The image was captioned "Worn well!! X Stella," along with details of where fans could buy the outfit shown.

Open Image Modal

Hundreds of Instagram users criticised the image for promoting an unhealthy body type, with one person writing: "Disgusting. That is not worn well, it’s hanging over bones."

Another comment read: "Appalling image. This young lady is clearly very ill and the body image being used is all that is wrong with the fashion world."

The brand has since removed the image of JiHye Park and replaced it with a picture of model Malaika Firth.

A Stella McCartney representative told The Independent: "We are a house that celebrates all shapes, all sizes, all races and all ages.

"We should have been more mindful. It was a quick snap done backstage that was misleading. We listened to our followers and we took it down and replaced it. We can only apologise if we offended anyone."

The replacement image

The speed with which Stella McCartney replaced the image of JiHye Park has re-ignited the skinny shaming debate, with some Instagram users arguing the model should not be criticised for her weight.

"Just because you're thinner than normal does not mean you have a disorder. I think that what they did to the other model was incredibly disrespectful," wrote one user under the Malaika Firth image.

"Just because someone is thin, it doesn't mean they're unhealthy. People come in all different shapes and sizes lets please stop shaming other human beings," said another.

While most people will be aware of what fat shaming is, fewer are aware of criticising a person for being too thin can be just as damaging.

Previously speaking to HuffPost UK Lifestyle, eating disorders charity Beat said: "You can’t tell just by looking at a picture of someone’s body if they are healthy not, and making critical comments about someone’s size - whether that is large or small - is never helpful.

"It doesn’t help our friends, it doesn’t help ourselves and it doesn’t help those people who find themselves scrutinised in public.

"Beat encourages everyone to celebrate the wonderful diversity that our bodies represent, because that is what gives us the strength and emotional resilience we need to fight the size-shamers.”

This isn't the first time the fashion industry has received criticism for its choice of models in recent weeks.

In September, Emporio Armani came under fire for using what some described as "ultra thin" models in their Milan show.

There is a fine line between calling out the fashion industry for not including a diverse range of body types, and body shaming an individual.

We do not know the eating habits of the Stella McCartney or Armani models - they may be perfectly healthy women. But undeniably, the designers do need to consider how images of these models may make other women feel and behave.

If young or impressionable women only see images of thin women, they are likely to think this is the only body type that is beautiful.

We'd like to see more body types represented in the fashion industry to help inspire body confidence in all women, whatever their size.

Body Image Heroes
Jennie Runk(01 of21)
Open Image Modal
Runk is the star of a May 2013 H&M swimwear campaign that gained widespread media attention for not relegating the gorgeous size 12 model to the "plus-size" pages of their website. In an interview with activist group SPARK, Runk told a young blogger: "I remember often feeling like I should be unhappy with my body, but it was confusing, because I never thought there was anything wrong with it until people started talking about it."In a piece for the BBC, Runk wrote of her newfound media attention: "This is exactly the kind of thing I've always wanted to accomplish, showing women that it's OK to be confident even if you're not the popular notion of 'perfect.'... There's no need to glamorise one body type and slam another." (credit:H&M)
Jennifer Lawrence(02 of21)
Open Image Modal
The famously outspoken "Hunger Games" star has been extremely vocal about resisting diet culture and pressure to be unnaturally thin. "If anybody even tries to whisper the word 'diet,' I'm like, 'You can go f*ck yourself,'" Lawrence said in an interview for the November 2013 UK issue of Harper's Bazaar. She also hit the nail on the head during a Nov. 7 Q&A with Yahoo! employees. "The world has this idea that if you don't look like an airbrushed perfect model," she said to Yahoo! CEO Marissa Mayer. "You have to see past it. You look how you look, you have to be comfortable. What are you going to do? Be hungry every single day to make other people happy? That's just dumb." (credit:Getty)
Nickolay Lamm(03 of21)
Open Image Modal
Lamm, an artist who works for MyDeals.com, used CDC measurements of an average 19-year-old woman to create a 3-D model which he then Photoshopped to look like a Barbie doll. His images of "normal" Barbie next to the doll sold in stores is truly worrying."If we criticize skinny models, we should at least be open to the possibility that Barbie may negatively influence young girls as well," Lamm told the Huffington Post in an email. "Furthermore, a realistically proportioned Barbie actually looks pretty good."It's awesome to see a man take a stance on these issues, especially considering that many men experience their own body struggles -- often in silence. (credit:Nickolay Lamm)
Trina Hall(04 of21)
Open Image Modal
Hall, a Dallas-based yoga instructor, abandoned all dietary restrictions between March and July of this year in order to see how her body changed when she wasn't actively limiting her eating habits -- and how people in her life reacted to her changing shape. The results of her project were not what she expected:
The people who didn't know, who were just with me in my life -- there was no difference that I could tell in the way that they treated me. The difference came in my own perceptions of myself, and I began to treat myself differently. I was very judgmental, and I would look in the mirror and critique myself... I would pick apart my body. Instead of looking at the whole of my body, I would look at different parts and analyze what's wrong with them.
"My most shocking discovery through the process is that I’m afraid of not being loved," Hall wrote in a Jul. 30 blog post. "I noticed the self-talk was that my beauty is only on the surface."The experience moved Hall to better understand the dialogue happening inside her own head, and inspired her to help other people suffering from poor body image. "I want to empower people to love their bodies... if it's going to start somewhere, it has to start within," she wrote.
(credit:Trina Hall)
Shailene Woodley(05 of21)
Open Image Modal
Woodley, who was nominated for a Golden Globe for her role in "The Descendants," told Flavorwire in July:
I saw somebody -- what I thought was me -- in a magazine once, and I had big red lips that definitely did not belong on my face. I had boobs about three times the size they are in real life. My stomach was completely flat. My skin was also flawless. But the reality is that I do not have those lips and my skin is not flawless and I do have a little bit of a stomach. It was not a proper representation of who I am. I realized that, growing up and looking at magazines, I was comparing myself to images like that -- and most of it isn’t real.
Because of her discomfort with how women are constantly Photoshopped and edited on-screen, Woodley doesn't wear makeup to events. What a badass.
(credit:AP)
Elena Raouna (06 of21)
Open Image Modal
Raouna, who was crowned Miss British Beauty Curve 2013, told the Daily Mail: "you don't have to be size zero to be a model, and you can be pretty and plus size at the same time." The beauty queen hopes to use her platform to inspire young women to be comfortable in their own bodies, regardless of their weight. "My confidence has grown over the years and hopefully I can inspire other plus-size girls to be confident in their own skin," she said. (credit:Elena Raouna )
Kelsey Miller(07 of21)
Open Image Modal
The Refinery29 staff writer turned to intuitive eating, a practice where you learn to listen to your body's signals and eat accordingly, to help manage her body demons -- and is chronicling her journey on the Internet via the Anti-Diet Project. "The goal here is not fast weight loss," Miller told the Huffington Post in an email. "It's about creating a healthy, neutralized relationship with food and learning how to be fit and active every day -- but still have a life." (credit:Rockie Nolan)
Sheila Pree bright(08 of21)
Open Image Modal
Pree Bright's photo series "Plastic Bodies" examines how beauty ideals affect women, especially women of color. Her striking images combine doll parts with segments of human bodies, and the discord between the two is startling. She told HuffPost in an email:
American concepts of the “perfect female body” are clearly exemplified through commercialism, portraying “image as everything” and introducing trends that many spend hundreds of dollars to imitate. It is more common than ever that women are enlarging breasts with silicone, making short hair longer with synthetic hair weaves, covering natural nails with acrylic fill-ins, or perhaps replacing natural eyes with contacts.Even on magazine covers, graphic artists are airbrushing and manipulating photographs in software programs, making the image of a small waist and clear skin flawless. As a result, the female body becomes a replica of a doll, and the essence of natural beauty in popular American culture is replaced by fantasy.
(credit:Sheila Pree Bright)
Adele(09 of21)
Open Image Modal
Adele says she tries not to worry about her body image and doesn't want to be a "skinny minnie." "The first thing to do is be happy with yourself and appreciate your body -- only then should you try to change things about yourself." (credit:Getty)
Rebel Wilson(10 of21)
Open Image Modal
The actress took to Twitter to say, "I'm not trying to be hot. I'm just trying to be a good actress and entertain people." (credit:Facebook)
(11 of21)
Open Image Modal
Source: "Body Image." Rader Programs.
(12 of21)
Open Image Modal
Source: The Renfrew Center Foundation for Eating Disorders, “Eating Disorders 101 Guide: A Summary of Issues, Statistics and Resources,” 2003.
(13 of21)
Open Image Modal
Source: Prevention of Eating Problems with Elementary Children, Michael Levine, USA Today, July 1998.
(14 of21)
Open Image Modal
Source: Marketdata Enterprises, 2007
(15 of21)
Open Image Modal
(16 of21)
Open Image Modal
Source: Zucker NL, Womble LG, Williamson DA, et al. Protective factors for eating disorders in female college athletes. Eat Disorders 1999; 7: 207-218.Source: Sungot-Borgen, J. Torstveit, M.K. (2004) Prevalence of ED in Elite Athletes is Higher than in the General Population. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine, 14(1), 25-32.
(17 of21)
Open Image Modal
(18 of21)
Open Image Modal
Source: The Renfrew Center Foundation for Eating Disorders, “Eating Disorders 101 Guide: A Summary of Issues, Statistics and Resources,” 2003.
(19 of21)
Open Image Modal
Source: Shisslak, C.M., Crago, M., & Estes, L.S. (1995). The Spectrum of Eating Disturbances. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 18 (3): 209-219.
(20 of21)
Open Image Modal
Source: Collins, 1991.Source: Mellin et al., 1991.
(21 of21)
Open Image Modal