Woman With Dental Drill Bit Lodged In Her Mouth For Two Years Opens Up About Stressful Ordeal

Woman Lives With Drill Bit Lodged In Her Mouth For Two Years
|

A woman has revealed how a drill bit remained lodged in her mouth for more than two years after it snapped off during a routine visit to the dentist.

Medics have been unable to retrieve the metal from Alison Southwood’s jaw, despite several consultations with some of the best dentists in the country.

The drill piece is located so close to a nerve that they fear removing it could cause her to lose sensation in the side of her face.

Open Image Modal

Although it has made no admissions of liability, the dentistry firm reached a settlement with Southwood, paying her £5500 in an out-of-court settlement.

The 44-year-old, a sales and innovation manager, said she has faced a long ordeal since the drill slipped in March 2013.

"I went to the dentist for routine root canal surgery," she said. "I can’t believe how much stress and misery has been caused by what should have been a simple operation."

Southwood, of Leamington Spa, Warwickshire, went to Genix Healthcare in Cirencester for root canal surgery.

Her mouth was numbed, which meant she did not feel anything when the drill snapped just minutes into the procedure. But she said she knew "straight away" what had happened.

Open Image Modal

Red dot shows teeth during Root Canal procedure before the drill had broken off.

Open Image Modal

Dot shows broken drill embedded through the end of the root and skewering surrounding bone.

"A hush descended on the room and the dentist and dental nurse exchanged worried glances," she said. "They legged it out the room for a private discussion.

"I was just left to lie there and wonder how they were going to break the news to me."

Southwood was told the drill was lodged too far down into her jaw bone to retrieve it, and all they could do was fill the hole and send her home.

"I was in shock, just going through the motions so I could get out of there as soon as possible," she said.

"They said they weren’t sure what to do next and I told them they’d better figure it out. I was totally dumfounded that I was just sent on my way with the drill still lodged in my jaw."

The 44-year-old consulted a string of specialists, but none wanted to attempt to retrieve the drill as, being so near the nerve, it posed too great a risk of permanent loss of sensation down the side of her face.

Meanwhile, her tooth was left to rot beyond repair and she is now facing having it extracted.

It is hoped that, by removing the tooth, surgeons will be able to reach and remove the drill.

"It’s a race against time to get it out," she said. "If left for too long, the metal could cause a toxic reaction. It’s an absolutely terrifying thought."

Currently, she has a temporary filling while she waits for a replacement tooth to be fitted.

"The filling is slightly discoloured so it’s a permanent reminder of what happened," Southwood said.

"I’ve had to choose between either that or a gap in my smile. If it was just for a couple of weeks, I wouldn’t mind, I’d just avoid going out. But I’ve been told it could be a year before I have my replacement tooth.

"Even then, I’ll have to deal with having a false tooth years before anyone would reasonably expect me to."

Following the incident, Southwood approached the Dental Law Partnership, who took on her case in November 2013.

After a 16 month legal battle, damages of £5,500 were awarded to her in February 2015.

"I’m not a litigious person, but the settlement money was necessary to cover my treatment costs," she said.

Story continues below...

Common Fears At The Dentist
1. Fear Of The Unknown(01 of07)
Open Image Modal
When Siegelman receives a new patient, he often doesn't jump right into the cleaning or dental procedure in the first visit. Instead, he sits with the new patient in his office -- with the door open, so there's no feelings of claustrophobia -- just to talk, so the patient can get to know him first.Siegelman said that other people with milder dental phobia can also ask to meet with their dentist first to help quell fears. While not all dentists may not have the luxury of time to be able to do this, it's worth asking a dentist before scheduling an appointment if you think it will help you feel more at ease, he said. (credit:alamy)
2. Fear Of The Dental Equipment(02 of07)
Open Image Modal
Sometimes, the scariest part of the dental visit is having those strange, sharp, metal tools stuck into your mouth. "I think it's an instinctive thing not to like noisy, sharp, piercing metallic things," Siegelman said. What can help ease this fear is to ask to hold the tools first, just so they don't seem so foreign, he suggested. (credit:alamy)
3. Sensitive Gag Reflex(03 of07)
Open Image Modal
People with a sensitive gag reflex may loathe the part of the dentist's visit where those tabs are put in the mouth for the dental X-ray. These days, newer dentist offices offer panoramic X-rays, Siegelman said. (credit:alamy)
4. The Dentist Seems Ominous(04 of07)
Open Image Modal
Find a dentist with a sense of humor! A study published in the European Journal of Oral Science showed that empathy and humor are big factors in reducing dental fear."Psychological barriers can be broken down by humor, both as a result of the patient and the dentist coming together more as equals, and as a result of humor reducing stress, increasing well-being and creating a pleasant atmosphere," study researcher Jenny Bernson, of the Sahlgrenska Academy at the University of Gothenburg, said in a statement. While humor is a great tactic to help a patient feel more at ease, Siegelman said that it's important that a dentist have a good grasp of the patient's sense of humor, or else it could backfire. "Absolutely, humor is great for anxiety, without question," Siegelman said."I just think that it's a tough play -- not every patient has a great sense of humor, and not every dentist has a great sense of humor." (credit:alamy)
5. Fear Of Loud Noises(05 of07)
Open Image Modal
Those dental tools can be really loud, and the noise can stir up fear in some people, Siegelman said. So, he recommends that these people wear earplugs or noice-canceling headphones to block out the sound. (credit:alamy)
6. Feeling Uncomfortable Lying Back In A Dentist's Chair(06 of07)
Open Image Modal
Some people may be uncomfortable with something as simple as lying back in the dentist's chair, due to a bad back or some control issues, Siegelman said. A simple remedy may be for the dentist to only put the patient half-back so that it's more comfortable. Or, a dentist could provide positioning pillows for people who feel aches and pains for being in a laid-back position. (credit:alamy)
7. Unable To Breathe Through The Nose(07 of07)
Open Image Modal
Are you a mouth-breather, who feels like you're being stifled if you can only breathe through your nose? That could be an issue at a dentist visit, where the dentist must work in the mouth, which can make mouth-breathing hard. Siegelman recommends nasal strips for patients to help them breathe through their nose. Or, nitrous oxide could help people relax and breathe better -- it all depends on the situation, he said. (credit:alamy)

Reflecting on her ordeal, Southwood said: "I’m gearing myself up to have the implant tooth fitted. I know it’ll be painful but hopefully it’ll help put this nightmare behind me.

"I’m still appalled that I was told they usually just hope patients don’t notice when this kind of thing happens.

"I wonder how many people are walking round with no idea they have metal lodged in their mouths.

"Whatever happens, I know I’ll never be able to get back in the dentist’s chair for another root canal treatment."

A spokesperson for Genix Healthcare commented: "We are totally committed to ensuring the safety of our patients and the high quality of dental treatment and care provided.

"We strive to make sure all patients know and understand the potential risk of any dental procedure they undertake and we enforce vigorous quality assurance protocols to minimise this risk as much as possible.

"We take any patient concerns very seriously – we strive to resolve any issues in a timely and amicable manner on the rare occasions that they arise."