Breast Cancer Symptoms May Not Include Lump And Women Must Learn Other Signs, Researchers Warn

One in six women have 'non-lump' symptoms.

In order to detect breast cancer early, women need to be aware that symptoms may not include a lump.

That’s the message from a team of researchers, who found one in six women (17%) diagnosed with breast cancer go to their doctor with a symptom other than a lump. 

Researchers from UCL examined the data of more than 2,300 women diagnosed with breast cancer in England between 2009 and 2010.

They found that, although most women with breast cancer sought help quickly, those with “non-lump” symptoms were more likely to delay going to their doctor compared with women with a breast lump alone.

Open Image Modal
Maskot via Getty Images

Symptoms other than a breast lump that may be a sign of cancer (termed “non-lump” in the study) include nipple abnormalities, breast pain, skin abnormalities, ulceration, shape abnormalities and an infected or inflamed breast.

Women with both a breast lump and “non-lump” symptoms were also more likely to delay seeking help.

Women presenting with breast ulceration, nipple abnormalities, breast infection or inflammation, swollen arm or armpit, and pain in the armpit were more likely to wait longer than three months to seek help.

The research used data from the 2009/10 National Audit of Cancer Diagnosis in Primary Care.

There are more than 53,600 breast cancers diagnosed in the UK every year and 11,400 deaths from the disease annually.

Monica Koo, presenting author based at UCL, said: “Our research shows around one in six women diagnosed with breast cancer have symptoms other than a breast lump. These women are more likely to delay going to the doctor compared to women with breast lump alone.

“It’s crucial that women are aware that a lump is not the only symptom of breast cancer. If they are worried about any breast symptoms, the best thing to do is to get it checked by a doctor as soon as possible.”

She added that diagnosing cancer earlier is key in order to increase the chances of survival.

“Symptom awareness campaigns such as the Be Clear on Cancer campaign should continue to emphasise breast symptoms other than breast lump,” she said.

Dr Karen Kennedy, director of the NCRI, added: “This research shows that, all too often, women are delaying going to their doctor with symptoms of breast cancer. This could be because people are simply unaware that breast cancer can present in many different ways, not just through the presence of a lump. 

“With a disease like breast cancer, it’s essential to be diagnosed as early as possible so that a treatment plan can be developed and started.

“Awareness campaigns need to raise awareness of all of the potential symptoms of breast cancer so that people know how to spot the signs and when to go to a doctor.”

The message that “breast cancer is more than a lump” is one that is echoed by Breast Cancer Care, who have created the below graphic to highlight other symptoms we often overlook.

Open Image Modal
Breast Cancer Care

The latest research was presented at the 2016 National Cancer Research Institute (NCRI) Cancer conference(link is external) in Liverpool. 

10 Famous Women Get Real About Breast Cancer
Dame Maggie Smith(01 of10)
Open Image Modal
Having cancer can knock your confidence and even film stars like Dame Maggie Smith aren't immune.

"It leaves you so flattened," the actress said following her cancer treatment.

"I’m not sure I could go back to theatre work, although film work is more tiring. I’m frightened to work in theatre now. I feel very uncertain. I haven’t done it for a while."
(credit:Kirsty Wigglesworth/AP)
Kylie Minogue(02 of10)
Open Image Modal
Kylie Minogue was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2005, but she refuses to let the disease define her.

"Having had cancer, one important thing to know is you're still the same person at the end. You're stripped down to near zero," she told Good Housekeeping back in 2014.

"But most people come out the other end feeling more like themselves than ever before."
(credit:Samir Hussein via Getty Images)
Jennifer Saunders(03 of10)
Open Image Modal
After her cancer diagnosis in 2009, Jennifer Saunders penned a humorous piece on the realities of treatment.

"The first time you have chemo is a bit scary, because you have no idea how you’re going to feel," she said.

"But let me tell you this: it’s basically like the most enormous hangover you’ve ever had in your whole life; it’s like a night on mixed spirits, wine and grappa. It’s a real cracker. It’s a humdinger."
(credit:Empics Entertainment)
Shannen Doherty(04 of10)
Open Image Modal
Shannen Doherty said "the unknown" is the worst part of living with breast cancer.

"The unknown is always the scariest part," she told ET Online.

"Is the chemo going to work? Is the radiation going to work? You know, am I going to have to go through this again, or am I going to get secondary cancer? Everything else is manageable. Pain is manageable, you know living without a breast is manageable, it's the worry of your future and how your future is going to affect the people that you love."
(credit:Jason LaVeris via Getty Images)
Olivia Newton-John(05 of10)
Open Image Modal
When Olivia Newton-John was diagnosed with breast cancer in 1992, she learned that sometimes it's important to put yourself first.

"I learned very quickly how important it was for me to think positively," she said on her website.

"When the second friend I called with the news burst into tears, I thought - this is too stressful. I had to find someone else to handle the day to day discussions of my health so I could concentrate on healing."
(credit:Ross Gilmore via Getty Images)
Wanda Sykes(06 of10)
Open Image Modal
In 2011, Wanda Sykes said her twins, who were just two years old at the time, were one of the reasons she opted to have a double mastectomy.

"We never hid anything from the kids. They were a huge part of my decision because I wanted to be around for them," she told People magazine.

"I feel whole again, I really do. I've told them, 'Mommy's boo-boo is much better now.'"
(credit:Dennis Van Tine/ABACA USA)
Sharon Osbourne(07 of10)
Open Image Modal
Sharon Osbourne decided to have a double mastectomy in 2012 after discovering she has a faulty breast cancer gene, having already had treatment for the disease once.

"For me, it wasn’t a big decision, it was a no-brainer. I didn’t want to live the rest of my life with that shadow hanging over me," she said at the time.

"I didn’t even think of my breasts in a nostalgic way, I just wanted to be able to live my life without that fear all the time."

"It’s not 'pity me', it’s a decision I made that’s got rid of this weight that I was carrying around."
(credit:Matt Crossick/PA Archive)
Janice Dickinson(08 of10)
Open Image Modal
In an interview shortly after her diagnosis, Janice Dickinson admitted she became scared for herself, but also for her family, when she was given a prognosis.

'It's still quite shocking. Today I got very scared... I just get very scared and it hit me [sic]. But I am not gonna let that define me, the fear," she said.

"I became fearful for my two children, my loving fiancé Rocky, we have a grandson, aged four, his name is baby Aby. I just thought they are gonna flip out."
(credit:Paul Archuleta via Getty Images)
Cynthia Nixon(09 of10)
Open Image Modal
Cynthia Nixon had a lumpectomy and radiation therapy when she was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2006.

In 2008, she said being the daughter of a cancer survivor helped her get through the difficult period.

"As the daughter of a breast cancer survivor, knowing my personal risk made me more aware and more empowered when I faced my own diagnosis," she said.

"I want to help Susan G. Komen for the Cure [breast cancer charity] educate the 1.1 million women around the globe who face a diagnosis each year."
(credit:Juan Naharro Gimenez via Getty Images)
Anastacia Lyn Newkirk(10 of10)
Open Image Modal
Anastacia Lyn Newkirk was first diagnosed with breast cancer in 2003 then again in 2013, and decided to have a double mastectomy to stop the cancer from spreading.

She's now raising money for Cancer Research UK by appearing on 'Strictly Come Dancing'.

"After beating breast cancer twice, I'm really passionate about trying to do something to help change the odds for others who are affected by this terrible disease," she says on her fundraising page.

"It's so important for everyone to know what's normal for them and see their doctor with any changes, as spotting cancer at an early stage can make a huge difference."
(credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)