Oscars 2018: Emma Stone Divides Viewers As She Takes A Swipe At Best Director Category

She referred to the nominees as 'four men and Greta Gerwig'.
LOADINGERROR LOADING

Emma Stone took the opportunity to call out the underrepresentation of female filmmakers at this year’s Oscars, as she took to the stage to present the award for Best Director.

A year on from bagging her first Academy Award for her performance in ‘La La Land’, Emma was invited back to present the award for Best Director, and couldn’t resist the opportunity to take a swipe at the male-dominated category.

Prior to reading out this year’s five nominees, Emma remarked: “These four men and Greta Gerwig created their own masterpieces this year.”

Emma Stone
Emma Stone
MARK RALSTON via Getty Images

Her remark did not go unnoticed by Oscars viewers, with many praising the actress for speaking her mind about the lack of women nominated in the category:

"These men AND Greta Gerwig" EMMA STONE DID THAT #Oscars90

— B. Dailey (@B_Dailey13) March 5, 2018

Hah love Emma Stone’s not so subtle dig on...#OscarsSoPenis-y?

Not against @RealGDT winning (LOVED #TheShapeOfWater so much), but YEAH. #Oscars

— Heather R (@heather_reindl) March 5, 2018

I have never been more here for anything than for Emma Stone calling out the Academy's sexism in a pantsuit. #Oscars

— ZakeNBake (@bzakenbake) March 5, 2018

These four men and @Greta gerwig... Lol Emma Stone slays it #Oscars90 #Oscars #Oscars2018

— Foolforyou (@kurian_anu) March 5, 2018

“These four men and #GretaGerwig...”

Best. Line. Ever. #Oscars#EmmaStone

— Daniel Persing (@danielpersing) March 5, 2018

I’m still laughing at “Four men and Greta Gerwig” I love Emma Stone lmao pic.twitter.com/kCJET5VZI6

— Brooke Sikes (@BrookeTaylor94) March 5, 2018

Emma Stone: These four men and Greta Gerwig...
Me: pic.twitter.com/2ecrUbI6GP

— Camille (@cferraz20) March 5, 2018

However, others have pointed out that Emma’s comments were disrespectful to nominees Guillermo del Toro, who spoke about his own experiences as a Mexican immigrant during the show, and Jordan Peele, the first black writer to win Best Original Screenplay at the Oscars for ‘Get Out’.

ok emma stone being like “four male directors and greta gerwig” or whatever tf she said is exactly what we mean by white feminism. Jordan Peele and Guillermo Del Toro are not white men that had everything easily handed to them and they don’t deserve to be classified as such.

— thea (@detectiveamys) March 5, 2018

TBH I wasn't a fan of Emma Stone presenting Best Director at the #Oscars by saying "The men nominated and Greta Gerwig". Gerwig is only the 5th white woman to be nominated but Jordan Peele is only the 5th black man. How many Mexican directors are nominated?

— Women Film Directors (@women_direct) March 5, 2018

Why am I not surprised that white women are celebrating noted white feminist Emma Stone for doing the absolute least while excluding the fact that two minorities were nominated for Best Director in a sea of white. Also y'all can't count. https://t.co/TYzSegu9k2

— donnia (@fincherism) March 5, 2018

“These four men and Greta Gerwig” is a cute thought Emma Stone, but feels extremely white feminist in that Jordan Peele is also nominated and is 1 of 5 black directors ever nominated for the category !! Also I’m still mad at u for Aloha binch we haven’t forgotten!!!

— T I N G R O L L (@TingRoll) March 5, 2018

“These four men and Greta Gerwig.”
Nevermind that one of those men is Black and one of those men is Latino but ok...you go right on ahead, Emma Stone. I say ALL of OUR names. #Oscars

— Terésa Dowell-Vest, M.F.A. (@dowellvest) March 5, 2018

A kind reminder to Emma Stone that Jordan Peele and Guillermo Del Toro's nominations are just as important and momentous as Greta Gerwig's for us people of color. #Oscars

— Eve (@missmorningeve) March 5, 2018

Emma stone saying “these 4 men and Greta gerwig” was peak white feminism

— honey boy (@msantc3) March 5, 2018

Am I the only one bothered by Emma Stone's " four men and Greta Gerwig" line for best director nominees? I don't consider Jordan Peele , and Guillermo del Toro to be a-typical nominees for #Oscars(cont)

— Connie Allen 🥞 (@conallen) March 5, 2018

(cont) Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't year mark the 5th time in the #Oscars a female director, and a black director have been nominated? So, why the shade on the male directors when they include POC? pic.twitter.com/u5jyBg48iS

— Connie Allen 🥞 (@conallen) March 5, 2018

During the ceremony, Sandra Bullock made similar comments, when presenting the award for Best Cinematographer, singling out “trail-blazing woman” Greta Gerwig, who was the first female nominee in the category in 90 years of Academy Awards.

Earlier this year, Natalie Portman won praise from Golden Globes viewers, when she highlighted the fact that no woman had been nominated in the Best Director category that year, despite great efforts from Greta Gerwig and Patty Jenkins, among many others.

Check out the full list of this year’s Oscars winners here.

Close

What's Hot