YOUNG VOICES

Higher Education White Paper Reveals Proposal To Link University Tuition Fees To Teaching Quality

'Students will understandably be outraged'.

16/05/2016 00:01 | Updated 16 May 2016
Chris Ison/PA Wire
The government says its proposed reforms will ensure students can be assured of quality 

Universities could soon increase tuition fees above the current £9,000 limit, student groups have warned.

The suggestion came as government proposals aiming to increase standards in higher education were published on Monday.

A new White Paper, titled Success as a Knowledge Economy, revealed: 

  • a new Office for Students watchdog to police quality in the sector
  • confirmation of an excellence framework to provide students with information on quality before they apply to begin courses
  • new universities will find it easier to gain degree-giving powers, though stringent quality assurances will need to be given
  • new providers will be encouraged to be "innovative and flexible" in their approach to teaching
  • and a "transparency revolution" requiring all universities to publish data on how well students from ethnic and minority backgrounds fair in the offer, application and acceptance stages
David Cheskin/PA Wire
Student groups have criticised a proposal which leaves open the possibility of increased tuition fees

The paper reveals a proposed link between the quality of teaching and university income as part of a teaching excellence framework.

The framework, part of the Conservative manifesto, aims to increase quality by linking teaching standards to university finances for the first time.

The move has led to fears that better universities may be able to charge students more than the current fees cap - an idea advocated before by leading vice-chancellors.

The new proposal would allow better universities to increase fees at least in line with inflation and perhaps even higher after two years.

But campaigners and student groups have criticised the plans, arguing that doing so will act as an incentive to remove a fees cap altogether.

Yui Mok/PA Archive
Tuition fees have prompted well-attended protests in London over the past four years

Sorana Vieru, National Union of Students vice president for higher education, said: "Students will understandably be outraged at any suggestion universities could be allowed to put fees up even higher in order to improve teaching quality.

"It was only four years ago tuition fees were trebled and students now face debts up to £53,000 when they graduate. 

"Universities, students and staff have all been very clear the proposed teaching excellence framework should not be linked to any rise in fees and the influential BIS Select Committee urged the government to do some serious rethinking before taking this forward.

"The government should urgently reflect on this and drop this muddled proposal.”

The government should urgently reflect on this and drop this muddled proposal Sorana Vieru, National Union of Students

The government believes reforms are needed to reflect the fact over half of job vacancies between now and 2022 are expected to be in occupations that require high-level graduate skills and knowledge.

It said the changes will ensure there are university places available to meet the demand for a more highly skilled workforce into the next decade.

Universities and Science Minister Jo Johnson said: "Our universities are engines of economic growth and social mobility, but if we are to remain competitive and ensure that a high-quality education remains open to all, we cannot stand still."

On the proposal to increase fees, Johnson told Times Higher Education: "Institutions do need to be able to address the real-terms erosion in their fee income... [but] in years one and two, we want the emphasis to be on getting the system right before we hang financial consequences from it."

READ MORE: Oxford chief believes diversity quotas will 'lower standards'

The suggestion that tuition fees could rise comes after research revealed graduates of English universities face a higher debt burden than US students.

Statista for HuffPost UK
Statista for HuffPost UK

English grads will owe an average of £44,000, more than average student debt in Canada, Australia and New Zealand.

Proposals which may increase tuition fees are likely to be met with fierce opposition from student groups and activists.

Tens of thousands of students have protested fees across the UK since their increase to £9,000 from £3,000 was passed into policy in 2011. 

Yui Mok/PA Archive
Students have protested fee increases before, seen here outside the Business department in 2014

The new White Paper also enhances students' rights as consumers in the higher education market.

The creation of a new Office for Students has been welcomed by consumer rights group Which? as a sign of progress in enabling students to make informed choices.

Alex Neill, Director of Policy and Campaigns at Which?, said: "These proposals could not only drive up standards, but could also empower students ahead of one of the biggest financial decisions of their lives."

Plans for an independent director in charge of ensuring fair access to universities come at a time of increased scrutiny on the prospects of ethnic and minority students.

Les Ebdon, current chief of Fair Access to Higher Education, said: "I am pleased that Ministers recognise the importance of this independent role within the new Office for Students."

Suggest a correction
Comments

CONVERSATIONS