20/09/2012 09:52 BST

Bright Children Fail To Get Top Grades As Entering Exams Too Early, Warns Ofsted's Michael Wilshaw

Thousands of the brightest children in England are failing to achieve top grades at GCSE because of a growing trend towards entering pupils early for the examination, according to figures released by the education watchdog.

Sir Michael Wilshaw, Ofsted chief inspector, has warned that the watchdog will be "critical" of schools which use early entry for GCSE where they are not "absolutely confident" that pupils will achieve their full potential.

His message comes after Ofsted statistics showed an "explosion" in early entries for maths and English at GCSE over the past six years with around a third of all pupils - more than 200,000 in each subject - now entered early for these exams.

But figures released by Ofsted have shown that for pupils who were the highest achievers at primary school - reaching level 5 in Sats exams - 12% fewer were awarded A grades in English and 11% fewer got A grades in maths in 2011 where they took the GCSE exam early, compared to those who were not entered early.

"We think early entry hurts the chances of the most able children getting the top grades of A*, A and B which they need to progress to A level and certainly to university," Sir Michael said.

"We will be critical of schools using early entry except where they are absolutely confident that youngsters are reaching their full potential.

"By full potential we mean A* and A actually if they are bright youngsters."

Wilshaw added that even when pupils achieved those top grades early Ofsted expected them to continue studying the core subjects of English, maths and science into Year 11 rather than being diverted to other subjects.

He said around one in five, or 20% of children, who leave primary school with level 5 do not achieve the top grades at GCSE of A*, A and B as a result of a "combination" of factors including early entry at GCSE.

Other factors included low expectations in schools of pupils, a failure to track the progress of pupils sufficiently and what Sir Michael termed "the curse of mixed ability classes without mixed ability teaching.

"This is not a judgment on mixed ability as opposed to setting or streaming, it is saying where there are mixed ability classes unless there is differentiated teaching to groups of school children in the class, unless there are individual programmes of work, it doesn't work," he said,

He added: "It is absolutely critical that if you have a youngster with low grades at school who struggles with literacy and numeracy sitting alongside a youngster with Oxbridge potential then it is really important that is taken into account and they are taught by people who are experienced in good teaching of mixed ability classes."

Wilshaw's remarks were made as Ofsted unveiled the report "Getting to Good" examining the steps taken by headteachers in schools that have improved from satisfactory to good or better. A second report on the impact of early entry for GCSE is due to be published at a later date by Ofsted.

Ofsted has warned schools that from start of this academic year, "good" is the minimum standard that will be expected of them, with the "satisfactory" rating used by inspectors scrapped in favour of "requires improvement."

Wilshaw said leadership was the "key issue" in improving schools.

"If we are going to be a country which is competitive economically and competitive with the rest of the world and a country which is socially cohesive we have got to have more schools getting to good and particularly those schools in poorer areas," he said.

A Department for Education spokesman said: "Candidates entered early often perform worse overall than those who do not, even after re-sits are taken into account.

"Some pupils are being entered before they are ready, and 'banking' a C grade, but their performance at Key Stage 2 suggests that if they had continued to study the subject and taken the GCSE at the end of Year 11, they could have achieved a top grade."


Six-Year-Old Reignites Hothousing Debate After Taking Maths A-level

Spend Pupil Premium On Poor Students Not Teachers, Says Wilshaw