09/07/2013 12:47 BST | Updated 09/07/2013 12:57 BST

Dove Releases New 'Camera Shy' Video But How Does It Compare To Controversial 'Real Beauty Sketches'?

Following in the well-heeled -- if slightly controversial -- footsteps of Dove's 'Real Beauty Sketches' campaign comes the beauty brand's follow-up video 'Camera Shy'.

Inspired by Dove's own global survey that highlights how 90% of women feel self-conscious in front of the camera, it hopes to shake insecurities and get women enjoying life instead of fretting over appearance.

So far, so noble.

While HuffPost UK Lifestyle aren't denying the intentions of the beauty brand, it is worth taking a stroll down memory lane to remind ourselves about the limitations of the last video.


A woman doesn't want to have her photograph taken

'Real Beauty Sketches', which attracted more than 150 million views on YouTube making it one of the most watched videos of 2013, implied that women are their own harshest critics and see themselves as much less attractive than a stranger does.

It divided the internet. While many hailed the campaign for inspiring positive body image, others criticised it for reinforcing dominant beauty stereotypes.

HuffPost blogger Jazz Brice said: "As I clicked the link and started watching the video, I started to feel a slight sense of discomfort. The message that we constantly receive is that girls are not valuable without beauty."

So how does 'Camera Shy' measure up?

The one-minute video shows more diversity than its predecessor, which lasted more than six minutes. It includes not only women of different ages, but different ethnicities.

But ultimately, the women in the video are all undeniably beautiful. Beautiful, slim and able-bodied.

Perhaps Dove should take a leaf out of Debenhams' book. Their High Summer Look Book championed diversity by using a Paralympian, plus-sized model and a 69-year-old.

Photo gallery See Gallery

Here are a selection of reactions to Dove's Real Beauty Sketches:

Photo galleryMixed Reactions To Dove 'Real Beauty Sketches' See Gallery

Here are some of the key findings from Dove's global research, which surveyed 4075 women.

Beauty anxiety is the main reason why women are camera shy

  • More than half of women (57%) admitted that worrying how they will look is likely to have a negative impact on how they feel in front of the camera
  • 36% of women admit they started to become more camera shy between the ages of 11 – 20 years of age
  • 55% of women are more camera shy now compared to 10 years ago

Women are missing out on capturing memories

  • 63% of women have destroyed photos of themselves
  • Digital photos are even more likely to be destroyed than printed copies (55% vs 25%)
  • 19% of women do not have photos of a once-in-a-lifetime holiday, 14% of their wedding day and 17% of the
  • birth of a child
  • Nearly 1 out of 3 have stopped photos being taken or later destroyed photos of a beach holiday, a significant party with friends/family and even their own graduations

Digital photos are increasing women's sense of camera shyness.

  • Being tagged in a photo on a social network causes more than half of women to feel more anxious about the way they look
  • Almost half (46%) have de-tagged, deleted or removed a photo of themselves
  • 41% have done something to a photo of themselves to enhance their looks before posting it online