ENTERTAINMENT
16/03/2015 23:39 GMT | Updated 17/03/2015 04:59 GMT

Jeremy Clarkson Top Gear Row: Two Stigs Give Verdicts On Whether Show Can Continue Without Him

As Jeremy Clarkson’s future at Top Gear continues to hang in the balance, two former Stigs have weighed in over whether the show can survive without the controversial presenter.

Clarkson has been suspended after a “fracas” with Oisin Tymon, which allegedly saw the producer punched in the face in a row over catering.

Perry McCarthy, who played The Stig from 2002 – 2003 is less than hopeful the show can continue without Clarkson – and has some words of warning for anyone who might be hoping to fill his shoes.

jeremy clarkson

Jeremy Clarkson's future at Top Gear hangs in the balance...

He told the Radio Times: “You would be taking the fire out of it.

“And God help any soul who takes his place, because that’s like signing up for your own firing squad."

the stig perry mccarthy

The original Stig Perry McCarthy

McCarthy mused as to whether the show could continue with a “neutered” Clarkson, but insisted: “It won’t work. The charm and the brilliance of Jeremy are that he is a slightly loose cannon."

Top Gear without Clarkson, he warned, would be: "Like having a Ferrari in your garage, but with a Ford engine.”

the stig ben collins

Ben Collins took over as the Stig after McCarthy

It’s praise indeed for Clarkson, but less so from Ben Collins, who performed as The Stig from 2003 – 2011.

Collins left the show on bad terms following his decision to reveal his identity in a book, something he says Clarkson was “not supportive” of.

17 Times Jeremy Clarkson Did Something Outrageous

Collins, who has not spoken to Clarkson since his departure admits the front man is an “unstoppable force” but was keen to praise the creativity of the show's production team.

He added: "It's become harder for Top Gear to reinvent itself, so it’s possibly starting to strain under the weight of its own success. But things will evolve. I don’t think it can be only anchored in one person."

READ MORE:

Though the 54-year-old presenter is being investigated over the incident, he is the subject of an online campaign to “Bring Back Clarkson” and has found himself a number of celebrity supporters.

In his weekly column for The Sun he expressed gratitude for the support of his fans but then discussed extinction, noting: “The day must come when you have to wave goodbye to the big monsters and move on.”

jeremy clarkson

17 Times Jeremy Clarkson Did Something Outrageous

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK | FOLLOW US ON TWITTER