The writer, who himself attended a college at the university where the notorious drinking society was spawned, rubbished an article that claimed such groups "cement the misogyny and privilege of a narrow elite".
Young scorned the piece, penned by feminist barrister Charlotte Proudman, who herself came under the media spotlight for posting a "sexist" message she had received on professional networking website 'LinkedIn' last month.
Proudman's latest article, published on Monday, claimed that "nasty segregated clubs" were designed to "educate the next generation of leaders that misogyny is not only no big deal, but something to be applauded".
The assertion was mocked, though, by Young, who commented on Twitter: "Finger on the pulse. Surprised no one else has pointed this out in the past 919 years #cuttingedgejournalism"
— Toby Young (@toadmeister) October 26, 2015
One indignant social media user hit back at Young, pointing out: "And yet nothing has changed... so it should continue to be pointed out!"
But the columnist rebutted, claiming that David Cameron, George Osborne and Boris Johnson - all former members of the Bullingdon Club during their time at university - had been hindered in their political pursuits by having been associated with the group.
But being a member of the Bullingdon has been a hindrance, not a help, to DC, GO and BJ. https://t.co/kwaKfyZZyf— Toby Young (@toadmeister) October 26, 2015
His comment sparked a backlash, with Twitter users piling in to rebuke Young.
Poor darlings, reduced to being Prime Minister, Chancellor & Mayor of London. Such prospects, so unfairly blighted: https://t.co/77No43FN0M— Anna H. (@drlangtry_girl) October 26, 2015
He resisted calls to expand on the remark, falling silent on the matter after his final post.