Dispatches Momentum Documentary Prompts Torrent Of Criticism Led By Owen Jones

'Well #Dispatches was an absolute embarrassment.'
LOADINGERROR LOADING

The much-anticipated Channel 4 Dispatches documentary ‘The Battle For The Labour Party’ aired on Monday night, claiming to expose the inner workings of the Jeremy Corbyn-supporting network Momentum.

Whether or not it succeeded is a matter of debate.

The show claimed the left-wing, grassroots movement was harvesting data, misusing campaign funds and trying to “take over” the Labour party.

Only, some people thought it was just a bit boring.

Watched #dispatches.
They should have called it The Battle To Stay Awake.

— John Prescott (@johnprescott) September 19, 2016

People finding out Channel4 spent 6months of their time & money on #Dispatches documentary about Momentum that everybody just found boring pic.twitter.com/zFQS0lzH8u

— Shlomo Anker (@Hapoel4) September 19, 2016

Owen Jones led the criticism, claiming the documentary was nothing more than a “hatchet job”.

Well #Dispatches was an absolute embarrassment. If you're going to do a hatchet job and find nothing, why bother broadcasting it

— Owen Jones (@OwenJones84) September 19, 2016

A sentiment with which many agreed.

So I watched #Dispatches and #Panorama and all I have to say is: err, was that it?! yeah great "smear" attempt there, no really 😆🙄 pic.twitter.com/374FJAuQoP

— Kathleen Anne 🇨🇦 (@says_it_now) September 19, 2016

Five minutes in and you can already get from the tone it will be a hatchet Job #Dispatches

— howling wolf (@houndog222) September 19, 2016

For pities sake. I don't like Momentum, so if you're going to do a hatchet job on them, at least make it effective @Channel4 #Dispatches

— Karen B (@Karen_Broady) September 19, 2016

In fact, it may have even served as a recruiting tool for Momentum.

This hatchet job by channel 4 is pathetic. If anything it has made decide I need to join momentum.... #Dispatches

— Moe (@moethemyth) September 19, 2016

Thx to the #Dispatches hatchet job I've done my own research on Momentum & can't wait to go to my first meeting. Cheers #C4 👍

— Angela (@AngelaLyttle) September 19, 2016

Whatever this trash #Dispatches hatchet job says, it's done its job for me. I'm going to #JoinMomentum & I'll be proud. #votecorbyn #Labour

— Urban Fox Defender (@ladyurbanfox) September 19, 2016

Even the Tories were knocking it.

#Dispatches was weak. It will only reinforce the view that the establishment wants to trash Corbyn. Suspect it'ill have the opposite effect

— Zac Goldsmith (@ZacGoldsmith) September 19, 2016

A number of claims were made in the documentary including:

  1. Momentum is trying to “take over” Labour by urging members to “flood” the Party.

  2. Momentum activists tried to conceal their level of involvement with the Labour Party.

  3. Funds meant for Corbyn’s campaign have been misused.

  4. Momentum used a Unite venue meant to be used by the wider Labour campaign.

  5. Momentum is harvesting personal data from Labour members.

On the opposite end of the scale to Jones, some viewers did think the documentary had performed a valuable service in shedding light on Momentum.

#Dispatches has done a public service in shedding light on the murky world of Momentum

— Malcolm Kennedy (@CllrKennedy) September 19, 2016

The Momentum defence that there are only "small numbers" of Trotskyists is odd - haven't they heard of vanguardism? #Dispatches

— Jonathan Derbyshire (@Jderbyshire) September 19, 2016

While others thought the Dispatches team would do well to concentrate on other topics...

People die after declared fit for work, made homeless by benefit sanctions, children in abject poverty. #Dispatches investigates Momentum.

— Rachel (@racybearhold) September 19, 2016

#Dispatches should expose the large number of tory MPs & peers with financial stakes in private healthcare firms being awarded NHS contracts

— will thorpe (@withorpe) September 19, 2016

Even though they have covered a whole host of programmes in the past...

Next week on #Dispatches, we follow some old ladies about in Nuneaton until they say sumat vaguely racist after 100 leading questions.

— Newsfox (@theNewsfox) September 19, 2016

Momentum released a video - before the show had even aired - showing the effect the documentary had had on its activists.

Activists explain how @C4Dispatches's rather pointless deceit has impacted on them personally #dispatches pic.twitter.com/DLsp4hCui5

— Momentum (@PeoplesMomentum) September 19, 2016

A Momentum spokesman told the Huffington Post UK that Channel 4’s investigation had exploited its “enthusiastic and young activists”, and that some allegations are “slurs or matters of opinion”.

He said: “Lawyers are looking at it and we’re minded to take this to Ofcom.”

They also insisted the group is not campaigning for deselections or mandatory reselection of MPs and “Labour members are free to organise as they see fit for candidate selections”.

It said any suggestions Momentum has been funded by Corbyn’s leadership campaign were false and claimed that in fact, Momentum has provided loans to Jeremy for Labour.

Momentum also complained that the Dispatches programme focuses on the actions of the left-wing Alliance of Workers’ Liberty, which it claims has around 100 members.

Young and enthusiastic? Get involved in politics and be secretly filmed and smeared in the national media. Very disappointed in #Dispatches

— Liam O'Hare (@Liam_O_Hare) September 19, 2016

A Channel 4 spokesperson said: “Channel 4 has a remit to deliver high quality news and current affairs, and a track record for investigative journalism and holding those in power to account.

“This is a vital piece of investigative journalism, on an issue of critical national importance to everyone in the UK particularly in a period of political flux.”

So what did @C4Dispatches find out? That Momentum are a group of folks routing for Jez. No anti-semitism, misogyny or violence #Dispatches

— Sam Speakman (@Sam_SoundFix) September 19, 2016
Close

What's Hot