Kay Burley Asked 'What's Wrong With You?' After Asking Labour MP Dawn Butler The Same Question Multiple Times

23/07/2015 09:50 | Updated 29 July 2015

As if the Labour leadership contest, in which parliamentarians voted for a contender they didn't actually want to win, wasn't confusing enough already. Now we have this interview between Sky News journalist Kay Burley and Brent Central MP Dawn Butler.

Butler was repeatedly questioned by Burley over her decision to put Jeremy Corbyn on the leadership ballot, despite actually wanting Andy Burnham to win.

Left-wing Corbyn was considered a rank outsider but could now be set to win the vote according to the latest poll.

The tense interview, in which neither one of the pair seemed to get their message across, eventually ended with the Labour MP asking Burley "What's wrong with you?".

kay burley

Tory MP and government whip Gavin Barwell has come out in support of Butler, tweeting:

And Butler herself was pleased and surprised to have started her own hashtag: #WhatsWrongWithYou:

It was a rare hiccup for Burley, who on the same day brilliantly refereed what was later described as 'the media bitch-fight of the week' between Guardian commentator Owen Jones and The Huffington Post UK's Owen Bennett, also over the Labour leadership.

In the interview, Butler explained that she didn't regret her decision to nominate Corbyn for the ballot: "I accept that responsibility. I'm glad I nominated Jeremy. I think it was our duty as MPs to make sure that we had as many different people on the list as possible, so that we could have the widest possible debate in the party."

"You'd like him to win?" Burley asks. "I don't think he will win, I nominated Jeremy..." replies Butler.

"That wasn't my question, with respect," interrupts Burley. "Yes, but I'm answering," says Butler.

"No, you're not. No no, my question is, do you want him to win?" replies Burley.

Butler replies: "And I'm going to answer you Kay, just calm down. So what I'm saying is, I nominated Jeremy, I'm happy that I nominated him. I don't think he will win, the person that I'd like to win would be Andy."

After a pause, Burley asks again: "Do you want him to win?"

"I'd like Andy Burnham to win," Butler repeats, "because I think Andy is the leader that we need to take the party forward and to actually unite the party, so I'd like Andy Burnham to win."

"So what was the point of voting for Jeremy Corbyn to be on the ballot paper in the first place?" Burley responds.

"Because, as I said right at the beginning," said an apparently exasperated Butler, "it was our responsibility as MPs to make sure we had the widest possible debate."

kay burley

Burley's reaction to being asked "What's wrong with you?"

Burley continues to press her on the same point, asking: "What's the point of putting somebody on the ballot paper if you don't want them to win?"

Butler repeats her explanation again before saying "I don't know, you say that politicians don't answer the question, I've answered it three times, and then you're asking me the same question again."

Their exchanges continue to become tense, especially as they debate whether Burnham had said he would have Jeremy Corbyn in his shadow cabinet if elected.

"Don't tell me he didn't say it because he did, what's wrong with you?" says Butler, laughing.

Butler's microphone later appears to be muted, after she says that she doesn't understand Burley's question.

Speaking to the Huffington Post UK, Butler said she was "extremely frustrated" that Burley continued to ask the same question repeatedly, but added that at least the interview has evoked a discussion about politics.

Butler said: "Not listening, it's frustrating. The great thing is I should be thanking her because there are lots of people who now understand the process [selecting a new Labour leader].

"Really, I suppose I should thank her because, ultimately, it's nice to get people involved in the political discussion."

Butler said she "loves" the 'what's wrong with you' hashtag and said that, after answering the same question three times, at least there can be no doubt about where she stands in the Labour leadership race.



  • Asking The Partner Of A Serial Killer If It Was Her Fault
    Burley asked the partner of Ipswich serial killer Steve Wright: "Do you think if you'd had a better sex life he'd have done what he did?"
  • Breaking Bad News To The Public Live On Air
    When Welsh toddler April Jones went missing, a huge search was launched by the community in Powys. When an arrest for her murder was made, Burley broke the news to locals helping in the search live on air.
  • Making Peter Andre Cry
    The pop star ended his interview with Burley after she showed him comments by Dwight Yorke.
  • Joining A Media Scrum In Malaysia
    Grieving relatives were 'knocked to the floor' by a crowd of media after the disappearance of flight MH370
  • Holding Alton Towers' CEO To Account
    An interview with Nick Varney, the CEO of Alton Towers owner Merlin Entertainments went viral after Burley's interview style was criticised on social media.
  • Describing Joe Biden's Ash Wednesday Mark As A Bruise
    Youtube/Matt Wardman
    "It looks like he's walked into a door." Burley later corrected her statements to clarify the Vice President's observation of Ash Wednesday.
  • Being Embarrassed By James O'Brien
    "You can say that if you want Kay," the LBC radio host told Burley during the interview, prompting a defensive response from the Afternoon Live host.
  • Making Chris Bryant Very Angry
    The Labour MP Chris Bryant told Burley to tell the truth when she made a mistake during an interview around phone hacking.
  • ... then refusing to apologise
    Chris Bryant MP came back after his first appearance to demand an apologise from Burley over comments she made earlier.

Related on HuffPost:

Spectacular Fox News FAILS
Suggest a correction