George Osborne was forced into a dramatic climbdown over his flagship welfare reforms on Monday after the government's cuts to tax credits were upended in the House of Lords. The double defeat in the Lords could trigger a constitutional crisis, with David Cameron reacting to defeat by promising retribution, including a “rapid review” to prevent peers blocking fiscal policy in the future.
After the defeat the chancellor said he would delay the policy until he comes up with a way of “compensating” workers affected by the cuts for at least three years. "I said I would listen to the concerns being raised and that is precisely what I will do,” said Osborne. "We can achieve the same goal of reforming these tax credits, securing the money we need to ensure our economy is safe, and at the same time helping in the transition to these changes and I will set out how we achieve that at the Autumn Statement."
The vote represents the first time in 100 years that the House of Lords has voted down a financial bill already approved by the House of Commons. A Downing Street spokesman said on Monday: “The Prime Minister is determined we will address this constitutional issue. A convention exists and it has been broken. He has asked for a rapid review to see how it can be put back in place."
Earlier in the Lords, Labour peer Patricia Hollis' motion to have a three-year transition for low-paid workers won by 289 votes to 272. It followed another motion tabled by the cross-bench peer Molly Meacher to delay the cuts until ministers spelled out how they would help low-paid workers triumphing by 307 votes to 277. However, a fatal motion, tabled by the Liberal Democrat peer Zahida Manzoor, that would have killed the cuts outright, failed by 310 votes to 99.
Conservatives reacted with anger at the results. Tory backbencher Edward Leigh said: “Not for 100 years has the House of Lords defied this elected House. This is a serious matter and I ask for the speaker to give a statement to protect the rights of the elected representatives, not just for us but for the people of this country.” Theresa May’s Parliamentary Private Secretary, said: “It should and hopefully will have consequences for the House of Lords.”
Labour's John McDonnell said the government defeat should force Osborne to "think again." The shadow chancellor said Britons were "shocked" by the Chancellor's determination to institute the divisive welfare reforms, which would slash £4.4 billion from working tax credits and child tax credits, effecting some of Britain's poorest households.
Speaking to Sky News, he said: "George Osborne has got to think again. He has been defeated twice in the House of Lords tonight but there are a large number of Conservative MPs as well who have been telling him very, very clearly he has got to think again on this one. I think now he is going to have to come back with further proposals."
Many congratulations to the Lords for teaching Govt a bit of fairness & humanity - shame it takes an unelected body to do it #taxcredits— Caroline Lucas (@CarolineLucas) October 26, 2015
I welcome the delay in cuts to #taxcredits, but the campaign must continue to protect the incomes of working Londoners.— Sadiq Khan MP (@SadiqKhan) October 26, 2015
What a disgrace that the unelected House had to champion working people because too many MPs were brow-beaten by govt whips. #taxcredits— Wes Streeting MP (@wesstreeting) October 26, 2015