Bayern Munich 3-1 Manchester United: David Moyes' Season Ends Trophyless (PICTURES)

Bayern 3-1 United: Moyes' Maiden Season Ends Trophyless Despite Valiant Display In Munich
|

Manchester United's first season under David Moyes will end trophyless after they were defeated 3-1 by Bayern Munich in the return leg of their Champions League quarter-final.

Patrice Evra's sensational strike put the visitors ahead after the pause, but Mario Mandžukić extinguished the Frenchman's opener less than two minutes later before Thomas Müller pounced to put Bayern ahead in the tie. Arjen Robben eventually ended United's valiant effort.

Open Image Modal

United will not play Champions League football for at least 17 months

Here are five talking points...

WENGER RIGHT ABOUT BAYERN'S VULNERABILITY

Logically, the acquisitions of Mario Götze and Thiago Alcântara to a treble-winning squad that remained largely intact should make said squad better. Pep Guardiola is rightly regarded as one of the best coaches in the world but, like Sir Alex Ferguson, he is perhaps his club's biggest liability as well as its strongest asset. Bayern were ponderous, predictable and - startlingly - weak in numbers against the worst United squad in a decade, missing the ineligible Juan Mata and the injured Robin van Persie and Rafael da Silva. Four of Bayern's substitutes were unknowns, and although the absent Thiago, Bastian Schweinsteiger and Javier Martínez contributed to a shift in formation, little had changed from the first hour at Old Trafford last week. Again, it took a United goal to instigate a proper performance.

It was easy to dismiss Arsène Wenger's suggestion last month that Bayern were "vulnerable" as an embittered barb after Arsenal were eliminated, yet following a tighter tie it is difficult to disagree. United will rue their heavy touches in the final third and Wayne Rooney's profligate finishing; Moyes' side gave an inkling as to how this Bayern side can be bettered in a European tie.

Open Image Modal

The man for the big occasion: Thomas Müller scored another big goal

Bayern are not as entertaining as Jupp Heynckes' merciless marvels of a year ago, even though Guardiola could emulate his predecessor's feat. The restrictions imposed are solely the coach's doing.

EVRA THE LIABILITY

How appropriate Patrice Evra, whose blockbuster strike past Manuel Neuer put United ahead, was culpable for Mario Mandžukić's leveller 22 seconds after the re-start. The Frenchman was effectively still celebrating his cracking half-volley, but his lack of appetite for defending has been evident all season.

There was little effort to close down Arjen Robben for Thomas Müller's winner and he was easily dismissed by the lightweight and calculable Dutchman for the clincher. Ferguson's failure to leave Moyes with a quality alternative at left-back is almost as unfathomable as his midfield blind spot.

Open Image Modal

Evra struggled to cope with Robben, who made the difference

CARRICK FAILS TO TAKE RESPONSIBILITY AGAIN

At his United zenith, Michael Carrick had one Italian newspaper gushing "bellissimo Carrick" following his masterclass at San Siro five years ago. Those 90 minutes against Internazionale now represent a glimpse of the player he should have emerged into at United.

Ferguson's aversion to signing midfielders in his last six years as manager restricted Carrick, who papered over that area's cracks excellently over the last two seasons, but he has experienced arguably his worst season at Old Trafford and was wasteful in possession again at the Allianz Arena. In a team of pretenders aiming to register an upset, his maturity and knowledge of playing at Bayern four years ago ought to have provided a more composed display, as the artisan Darren Fletcher was tasked with the donkey work. Unfortunately for United, it was a tentatively recognisable effort from the 32-year-old.

United: who should stay and who should go?
David de Gea(01 of35)
Open Image Modal
United's player of the season and one of only two world-class players in the squad.Verdict: Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Rafael da Silva(02 of35)
Open Image Modal
Has regressed this season but has also lacked support from sceptical coaches.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Patrice Evra(03 of35)
Open Image Modal
A liability in defence coming up to four years now, United should have brought in a replacement in 2012.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Phil Jones(04 of35)
Open Image Modal
Needs to regain his confidence but has all the hallmarks of a defensive mainstay.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Rio Ferdinand(05 of35)
Open Image Modal
Going (credit:Getty Images)
Jonny Evans(06 of35)
Open Image Modal
The best distributor out of United's centre-backs likely to stay next season, Evans is an able reserve and strong enough to compete for a first-team berth.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Juan Mata(07 of35)
Open Image Modal
A quality addition - when used in the right position.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Wayne Rooney(08 of35)
Open Image Modal
Irrespective of who United's manager is next season, Rooney will be at the club, too. That doesn't mean they shouldn't try to offload a player who has successfully held the club to ransom and not justified either pay rise.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Ryan Giggs(09 of35)
Open Image Modal
Like Ferdinand, Giggs should have bowed out with Ferguson. An undeservingly unsuccessful end for one of the club's greats.Staying (as an assistant) (credit:Getty Images)
Chris Smalling(10 of35)
Open Image Modal
United's best centre-back this season, he now needs a world-class defender to start alongside him.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Anders Lindegaard(11 of35)
Open Image Modal
Has rarely played under Moyes after a torrid 2012-13, but showed at Newcastle he is an able deputy.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Javier Hernandez(12 of35)
Open Image Modal
His pace has not been exploited often enough by Moyes this season, and he is apparently keen on a move. A new coach might prompt a re-think and he remains a quality squad player.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Nemanja Vidić(13 of35)
Open Image Modal
Going (credit:Getty Images)
Michael Carrick(14 of35)
Open Image Modal
Fortunate to have received a new contract earlier this term, he has performed woefully but would be a handy reserve once United bolster their midfield.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Nani(15 of35)
Open Image Modal
Nani has somehow played worse this season than last. He turns 28 in November and plays like he is still 18, but remains the best winger at the club and received a five-year contract in September.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Ashley Young(16 of35)
Open Image Modal
A player who was never good enough, it remains unfathomable why Sir Alex Ferguson rushed out to sign Young, rather than midfielders, in 2011.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Danny Welbeck(17 of35)
Open Image Modal
Reliably unreliable, Welbeck's final third play is rusty and blunt but his pace and selflessness make him an essential squad member.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Robin van Persie(18 of35)
Open Image Modal
Sulky, injury prone and underwhelming, and yet Van Persie has arguably been United's best outfield player this season. Selling Rooney would solve a lot of problems.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Angelo Henriquez(19 of35)
Open Image Modal
Yet to make his debut nearly two years on, United perhaps should have focussed on local talent rather than plucking a Chilean from South America, only to farm him out on loan.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Tom Cleverley(20 of35)
Open Image Modal
The supporters' scapegoat, he played well for five games in 2011. That is all.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Darren Fletcher(21 of35)
Open Image Modal
Mercifully, he can extend his career, just not at United. His first-team opportunities are more owed to the paucity of midfield options.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Antonio Valencia(22 of35)
Open Image Modal
With the exception of four months in 2011-12, Valencia has been consistently bad since the 2011 Champions League final. Too bulky and not as pacy as when he arrived.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Shinji Kagawa(23 of35)
Open Image Modal
One of the most sophisticated and technical footballers at United who has not been handled well by either Ferguson or Moyes.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Federico Macheda(24 of35)
Open Image Modal
Should have been sold in 2012.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Alexander Büttner(25 of35)
Open Image Modal
Has exceeded expectations recently, but should still never have been signed.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Wilfried Zaha(26 of35)
Open Image Modal
Do United write off a £15 million waste or give a raw winger a fair crack of the whip? Zaha needs to address his discipline, mind.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Guillermo Varela(27 of35)
Open Image Modal
Signed after Sir Alex Ferguson retired and before David Moyes began work as United manager, it's shown. In a season when one right-back has underperformed and suffered injuries and another has been sold, he has not had a kick.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Marouane Fellaini(28 of35)
Open Image Modal
Potentially the heir to Cleverley's scapegoat mantle, he has performed terribly but a wrist injury and insufficient midfield support have not helped.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Nick Powell(29 of35)
Open Image Modal
An exciting young attacker ready for his first-team squad induction.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Bébé(30 of35)
Open Image Modal
The worst player in modern United history.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Michael Keane(31 of35)
Open Image Modal
Out of contract in the summer and unlikely to get any first-team chances.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Ben Amos(32 of35)
Open Image Modal
At 24, this goalkeeper should have left two years ago.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Adnan Januzaj(33 of35)
Open Image Modal
A star in the making and one of the few rays of light in an otherwise dark season.Stay (credit:Getty Images)
Anderson(34 of35)
Open Image Modal
At £25 million, he is one of Sir Alex Ferguson's worst signings. Anderson scored nine goals in six-and-a-half seasons, was overpriced and is overweight.Go (credit:Getty Images)
Sam Johnstone(35 of35)
Open Image Modal
The designated third-choice goalkeeper.Stay (credit:Getty Images)

ROBBEN PREDICTABLY BRILLIANT

He receives the ball, he cuts inside and he shoots. He will rarely pass and he will sometimes score. No, it is not Andros Townsend, but the player he aspires to be. Arjen Robben's avarice on the ball visibly infuriated some of his teammates in the first 45 minutes, although, as is his wont, he decided this tie. His cross for Thomas Müller's winner was deflected - as was his goal - yet there is much to admire about Robben's resilience, which he exhibited in last year's Champions League final.

Open Image Modal

Moyes' first season will end trophyless

MOYES REACTIVE, RATHER THAN PROACTIVE

David Moyes shares some unwanted traits with the man he succeeded, and on Wednesday evening it extended to his substitutions. Nicknamed "Dithering" by Evertonians, he was certainly that after Mandžukić's equaliser, which galvanised a hitherto moribund Bayern side, whose dominance inevitably increased. Danny Welbeck was reliably unreliable, Darren Fletcher nor Michael Carrick could retain possession and yet Moyes waited. By the time he reacted, it was too late and two minutes after Javier Hernández was belatedly introduced Robben scored Bayern's third.