Transgender Patients 'Not Treated Equally' By NHS, MPs Told

MPs Told Transgender Patients 'Not Treated Equally' By NHS
|
Open Image Modal
doctor briefing nursing students
sturti via Getty Images

Doctors are not being trained well enough to provide adequate medical care to transgender people, NHS officials have warned parliament.

MPs were also told on Tuesday that transgender patients were not being treated equally by the NHS.

Dr John Dean, the chair of NHS England's Clinical Reference Group for Specialised Gender Identity Services, told a Commons committee that doctors were "hampered by a lack of knowledge" when it came to trans issues.

"Overall people working in the service try to be empathic, they are certainly sympathetic, but they lack a great deal of background knowledge about gender incongruence and dysphoria. It is something which is not covered in any detail in medical training," he said.

He said that while medical students were interested in the needs of transgender people, they received "very little information" about it during training.

And he warned that many doctors and other NHS staff found it "very scary" when they did not even have a proper understanding about which pronoun to use when addressing a transgender patient. "That can cause deep offence to patients if that issue isn’t properly addressed," he said.

Dr Dean was giving evidence to the Commons women and equalities committee, which is conducting an inquiry into transgender equality.

He added that given the "dramatic" rise in the number of people seeking care, it was "no longer appropriate" for doctors to palm transgender patients off to specialists physicians. "Trans people are people and must be treated like people," he said.

Iconic Transgender Moments
Caitlyn Jenner Makes Her Debut On Vanity Fair(01 of10)
Open Image Modal
On June 1, 2015, Caitlyn Jenner (formerly known as Bruce Jenner) made her debut on the cover of Vanity Fair magazine. The issue followed her public interview with Diane Sawyer, in which she spoke openly about her transition and journey. (credit:Vanity Fair)
Chelsea Manning Comes Out(02 of10)
Open Image Modal
Following her trial for leaking classified government documents, Chelsea Manning sent shockwaves through the nation when she announced her transgender identity and asked for the public's support. "As I transition into this next phase of my life, I want everyone to know the real me," Manning said in a statement. "I am Chelsea Manning. I am a female. Given the way that I feel, and have felt since childhood, I want to begin hormone therapy as soon as possible." (credit:Alex Wong via Getty Images)
Carmen Carrera's Victoria Secret Petition(03 of10)
Open Image Modal
"RuPaul's Drag Race" season three contestant and transgender model Carmen Carrera unexpectedly became the subject of a viral Internet petition in early November. The petition called for Victoria's Secret to hire the showgirl as the company's first transgender model in its annual fashion show. Though Victoria's Secret did not respond to the Carrera petition, the model has claimed that she will campaign to be included in next year's show. (credit:Chelsea Lauren via Getty Images)
McDonald's Supports Transgender Rights With Bathroom Message(04 of10)
Open Image Modal
In light of recent controversy surrounding McDonald's treatment of the company's employees, one Washington franchise of the fast food chain impressively allowed transgender individuals to use the bathroom that corresponds with their gender identity. The letter read,
We respect the rights of all customers and employees. We believe all people must have access to safe and dignified bathroom facilities regardless of their gender identity or expression. Therefore, the following policy has been adopted for this restaurant at 1530 3rd Avenue ... Employees and customers may use any restroom that corresponds with and is based upon the gender identity they publicly and exclusively assert or express.
(credit:Tumblr)
First Openly Transgender Character In Mainstream Comics(05 of10)
Open Image Modal
DC Comic fans were introduced to Alysia in "Batgirl" #19 in early April, who went on to reveal that she is transgender during a conversation with Barbara Gordon (Batgirl). The move made Alysia not only the first DC Comics transgender character but the first transgender character in mainstream comics. (credit:DC Comics)
Transgender Teenage Couple Transitions Together(06 of10)
Open Image Modal
Arin Andrews and Katie Hill warmed hearts around the world last summer with their unique and touching love story. The pair met at a trans support group, after each had begun the transitioning process, and fell in love. (credit:Barcroft Media)
Ari South Becomes First Openly Transgender Project Runway Contestant(07 of10)
Open Image Modal
When Ari South first appeared on "Project Runway" season eight, the designer embodied a different name and different identity. When she returned to "Project Runway All Stars" in October, she was living as her authentic self and blazing through uncharted territory for transgender people both within -- and outside -- the fashion world. (credit:Courtesy of Lifetime)
Top Russian Lawyer Comes Out As Trans, Announces Presidential Campaign(08 of10)
Open Image Modal
In wake of the pervasive climate of fear and violence plaguing LGBT Russians, top Russian lawyer Masha Best came out as both transgender and bisexual in protest of the country's institutionalized homophobia. Best later went on to announce her campaign for the Russian presidency in 2018. Here, Best poses nude in honor of the 2013 Transgender Day of Remembrance. (credit:Masha Best)
Arizona's Rights For Transgender Minors(09 of10)
Open Image Modal
Other states also met these bills with resistance, with one Arizona lawmaker, John Kavanagh, attempting to push through legislation that would prosecute transgender people for using a public restroom if their appearance didn't match the listed gender on their identification. One local new station dubbed this the "Show Me Your Papers Before You Go Potty" bill. The backlash convinced the lawmaker to tone down the language of his bill, and put it on hold until next year. (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
University Expels Transgender Student For 'Fraud'(10 of10)
Open Image Modal
Domaine Javier, a nursing student at California Baptist University, revealed to the world that she was transgender in an MTV episode of "True Life." The university's response? Accusations of fraud followed by expulsion because Javier had given her gender as female on her admissions application. She went on to sue the institution. (credit:Courtesy of Domaine Javier)

Steve Shrubb, the chief executive of West London Mental Health NHS Trust, also told MPs that transgender people were not treated equally by the health service. "Transgender individuals really do suffer stigma," he said. "I don't believe there is equality."

Shrubb added: "Whether it's through lack of knowledge or people's own views I think service users tell me it can feel as if they are not being treated equally"."

Announcing the inquiry in July, committee chair and former cabinet minister Maria Miller said there needed to be "true equality for everyone".

"many trans people still face discrimination and unfair treatment in their work, schools, healthcare and other important services," she said.