George Osborne Set To Give Big Banks A Secret Tax Cut

Osborne Is Trying To Give The Banks A Secret Tax Cut
|
Open Image Modal
George Osborne leaves Downing Street before delivering his 2014 budget announcement at the House of Commons.
Matt Crossick/Matt Crossick

George Osborne slipped out a potential "secret tax cut" for Britain's biggest banks that could see them pay hundreds of millions less in tax, critics have warned.

Barclays and HSBC could be in line for a combined fall in their levy charges of more than £300 million under Treasury proposals to switch the bank levy to a band-based system which would see an individual bank's tax capped at an upper limit.

Labour’s shadow financial secretary Cathy Jamieson warned that the proposals would be a "secret tax cut" for major British banks.

“This looks like a secret tax cut for the big banks hidden in George Osborne’s Budget," she told the Telegraph.

"The bank levy has already raised billions less than was originally promised. George Osborne must come clean and explain what impact this banding will have on revenues from the bank levy in future years."

Osborne's proposed changes would come in after a consultation at the start of next year and put banks into five separate bands, with the levy rising from nothing to banks with balance sheets smaller than £20 billion to £375m for those with chargeable assets between £160bn and £320bn.

A Treasury spokesperson said: “The bank levy is forecast to raise £2.9bn a year from 2015-16 according to the independent OBR and the government has no plans to reduce the amount of money the levy raises.

“The consultation, announced at Budget last week, will look at ways to make the levy more predictable and sustainable moving forward.

“The suggested changes will not impact on the target yield from the levy, which is designed to ensure that the sector makes a fair contribution.”

The British Bankers' Association warned Osborne in a written submission: "The bank levy rate has been increased eight times since (it) was first announced at Budget 2010, and many of those increases have been implemented with minimal advance notice.

“The frequency of the rate change has not resulted in a stable tax environment for the banking industry and is inconsistent with the government’s desire for the UK to have a competitive, stable and predictable tax regime for business.”

Reasons Why The Banks Aren't Yet In Order
Barely Anyone Thinks Banks Are Well Run(01 of07)
Open Image Modal
They're Still Not Lending To Businesses (02 of07)
Open Image Modal
The big banks have been battling to get money out of the door to help British SMEs but are still struggling as business lending has fallen in most parts of Britain. An investigation by Lawrence Tomlinson, the business department's entrepreneurial adviser, found that government-owned banks were "crucifying" firms in the way they managed their financial support.
PPI Mis-selling Drags On(03 of07)
Open Image Modal
Banks are still paying out millions for mis-sold payment protection insurance.This has led to a peak in complaints too.
Credit Card Theft Insurance Mis-selling Surfaces(04 of07)
Open Image Modal
Over a dozen high street banks and credit card firms have agreed on a compensation fund of more than £1 billion for potentially for seven million people who had been mis-sold credit card and identity theft protection.It all stems from card insurance policies supplied by York-based CPP Group.
Was There Gilt-Rigging?(05 of07)
Open Image Modal
Did the Bank of England miss an attempt by traders to rig the gilt market too? Tory MP Andrea Leadsom thinks so.Financial regulators are investigating. Meanwhile one of the Bank officials said such an attempt at a dodgy trade would be "reprehensible" if proven.
Bank Bonuses Are On The Up (06 of07)
Open Image Modal
Banker bonuses effectively increased by 4% over last year to £38.6 billion, after banks deferred bonuses to take advantage of George Osborne's 50p income tax rate coming in.Osborne's introduction of the lower 45p income tax band, announced in his Budget last year means that the taxpayer lost out on an estimated £85 million as banks deferred £700 million of bonuses to April this year.Also, we have three times more millionaire bankers than the rest of the EU combined.
Oh Yes, And The Libor Rigging (07 of07)
Open Image Modal
Regulators are still looking into the Libor interbank fixing scandal, bringing charges against traders they have managed to single out.