Labour's Blairites Dominate Sunday Talk Shows In Battle Over How Party Should React To Election Loss

Blairites Gain Early Advantage In Labour Leadership Stakes
|

Blairites gained an early advantage in the battle to set how the Labour Party will respond to its defeat, as current and former grandees of the party have dominated the Sunday talk shows and newspapers talking up a less left-wing direction for the party.

Chuka Umunna, Tristram Hunt, Lord Mandelson, Pat McFadden and Liz Kendall all appeared on politics talk shows - a crucial public relations arena for setting the agenda of the week ahead.

All repeated variations of the theme that their party had to move rightwards to the centre and appeal to a broader range of voters, as Blair did when he led it to three consecutive wins in 1997, 2001 and 2005.

Mandelson, who appeared on the Andrew Marr Show and Five Live, was particularly scathing, saying Ed Miliband's campaign was "completely useless".

“The awful, shocking thing about this election is Labour could have won it,” he told Marr.

“The reason we lost it and lost it so badly is in 2010 we discarded New Labour, rather than revitalising it and reenergising it and making it relevant for the new times, the new policy challenges that we faced. That was a terrible mistake.”

Ed Miliband was deemed an heir to the more left-wing Gordon Brown when in 2010 he narrowly defeated his brother David - whose sympathies were more Blairite - for his party's leadership, thanks to support from the unions.

In another Blairite nod, Mandelson told Marr Labour should end the unions' "inappropriate" role in selecting the party leader.

Even Blair himself has given his thoughts today on the direction the party should take.

March Of The Blairites
Tony Blair(01 of05)
Open Image Modal
Writing in The Observer, the former prime minister said Miliband had shown "courage under savage attack," and put "his heart and soul into the fight".
He wrote: "The route to the summit lies through the centre ground. Labour has to be for ambition and aspiration as well as compassion and care.
"Hard-working families' don't just want us to celebrate their hard work; they want to know that by hard work and effort they can do well, rise up, achieve.
They want to be better off and they need to know we don't just tolerate that; we support it."
(credit:Owen Humphreys/PA Wire)
Chuka Umunna(02 of05)
Open Image Modal
The Shadow Business Secretary has still not said whether he will run to be leader.
But he told Marr: "We weren't with the wealth creators... For middle income voters there wasn't enough of an aspirational offer there.
"I was never told that there was specifically a 35% strategy but if you look at the offer that was a conclusion that people were entitled to reach.
He added: "We cannot have a message that anybody is too rich or too poor to be a part of our party. What the Labour Party does will is build a big tent of people of different backgrounds, creeds, colours, races,. religions, economic circumstances. And it is when we have an offer that is big tent and appeals to a lot of people, that's when we win."
(credit:Matt Dunham/AP)
Tristram Hunt(03 of05)
Open Image Modal
Elected in 2010, the Shadow Education Secretary entered parliament after the days of Blair and brown. But he was on radio and TV today giving a profoundly Blairite message.
He told BBC Radio 5 Live's Pienaar's Politics: "Sometimes we told too many stories about a downhearted Britain, and zero hours, and yes, Ed Miliband's great achievement was to address the inequality issue.
"But this is also a wonderful, optimistic country which I think we needed to say more about and be more, in a sense, confident about the achievements of the last Labour government in helping to build that and then optimistic about the future."
He added: "The reason why this debate [about Labour's future] needs to be long and deep and painful for the Labour Party is we are in a real hole. We are in a hole in Scotland and we are in a hole in England and we've got challenges in Wales as well.
"But the issue in England is this double bind of losing traditional Labour communities often under pressure from Ukip, and not speaking to an aspirational, John Lewis couple who we should be on their side."
(credit:Matt Dunham/AP)
Liz Kendall(04 of05)
Open Image Modal
The shadow health minister was first earmarked as a potential leader when she gave a quote saying she was amenable to privatising part of the NHS - going against the left of her party.
She tells today's Sunday Times that it was a "truly terrible result" for her party, adding: "We need to show people that we understand their aspirations and ambitions for the future, and if you look right across England, we did not do enough to appeal to Conservative supporters, and we must."
(credit:John Stillwell/PA Wire)
Pat McFadden(05 of05)
Open Image Modal
Shadow Europe Minister Pat McFadden said Miliband's break from New Labour was the cause for voters rejecting the party, saying: "their verdict on that strategy was very clear." (credit:David Jones/PA Archive)

Labour's defeat means it has not won an election without Tony Blair since 1974.

Shadow Health Secretary Andy Burnham and Shadow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, whom insiders expect to run for the leadership, did not make an appearance on the talk shows or in the papers.

Blair's former deputy prime minister John Prescott attacked Miliband in his Sunday Mirror column, saying the campaign was "bloody disastrous".

"We fought a presidential-type election based on computers, charts, focus groups and even the American language - Hell yes? Hell no!"

Chris Leslie, the Shadow Chief Secretary to The Treasury who is rumoured to be poised to be named shadow chancellor, said the party had to avoiding a re-run of old battles between the Blairite and more leftwing factions.

He said: “I understand the arguments that are being made, but this can’t be about going back and fighting those old battles of seven or 12 years ago. I was a minister in previous Labour governments and I’m very proud of being a minister in previous Labour governments, but I think now we need to face the future.

"The longer-term question is how we, of course, create that coalition for the longer term in 2020, but there’s an immediate task as well, and I’m very concerned about that. It is basically George Osborne and David Cameron, they will be rushing to get their agenda through."

He added: "The Conservative party, I suspect, is going to fragment in a number of different ways, particularly on Europe, but when it comes to the economy and it comes to public services, we’ve got to reform those public services but we’ve also got to make sure we pin them down on where those cuts are going to fall and who is going to pay the price for that – that is our immediate job.”