Recall Of MPs Bill A 'Cynical Stitch-Up' Warns Tory Zac Goldsmith

Recall Bill A 'Cynical Stitch-Up' Warns Tory MP
|
Open Image Modal
New Conservative MP Zac Goldsmith poses for a photograph in Westminster Hall, Palace of Westminster, London.
Anthony Devlin/PA Archive

New legislation that would allow voters to kick their MP out of parliament mid-term has been attacked as a "stitch up" by one of the staunchest supporters of so-called "recall" laws.

On Wednesday David Cameron and Nick Clegg used the Queen's Speech to announce a Recall of MPs Bill would be introduced before the 2015 general election, after years of delays and internal coalition wrangling.

Constituents will be able to sack their MP if they are sentenced to up to 12 months in jail. And voters could also trigger a by-election if the House of Commons resolves that an MP has engaged in "serious wrongdoing". Under the new law, a vote would be forced if more than 10% of constituents sign a petition over an eight-week period.

MPs are now only expelled from parliament if they are jailed for more than one year. Less serious wrongdoing is punished by temporary suspension from the House.

However Tory MP Zac Goldsmith said the Bill was a "breathtakingly cynical attempt to convey an impression of democratic reform" without actually empowering voters in any real sense.

Goldsmith, who has long campaigned for a power of recall, blamed the "stitch up" on Clegg. He said the legislation actually handed more power to the establishment, as the decision as to whether a MP was guilty of "serious wrongdoing" and would face being kicked out was in the hands of a committee of MPs, not voters themselves.

"It is surely revealing that not a single organisation interested in democratic reform, or a single reform-minded MP backed the Lib Dem plans," he said in a statement today.

"True recall is simple. If a percentage of constituents – usually 20 per cent – sign a petition in a given time frame, they earn the right to have a referendum in which voters are asked if they want to recall their MP. If more than half say yes, there is a subsequent by-election."

Goldsmith said the argument against allowing voters to recall their MP whenever they likes was the same as the argument used to prevent women being given the vote.

"It is theoretically possible of course that an MP might be unfairly removed from office under recall, but the same can be said of any election. And where recall happens, there are no known examples of successful vexatious recall attempts," he said.

State Opening of Parliament 2014
State Opening of Parliament 2014(01 of46)
Open Image Modal
The new carriage carrying Queen Elizabeth II and The Duke of Edinburgh leaves Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(02 of46)
Open Image Modal
The new carriage carrying Queen Elizabeth II and The Duke of Edinburgh leaves Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(03 of46)
Open Image Modal
A carriage carrying the Prince of Wales and Duchess of Cornwall leaves Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(04 of46)
Open Image Modal
The royal procession makes its way along The Mall, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(05 of46)
Open Image Modal
The Imperial State Crown leaves Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(06 of46)
Open Image Modal
The new carriage carrying Queen Elizabeth II and The Duke of Edinburgh leaves Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(07 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament, in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(08 of46)
Open Image Modal
The new carriage carrying Queen Elizabeth II and The Duke of Edinburgh leaves Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(09 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(10 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(11 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(12 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(13 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(14 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
Queen Elizabeth II Attends The State Opening Of Parliament(15 of46)
Open Image Modal
LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 04: British Prime Minister David Cameron (L) Deputy Prime Minister and leader of the Liberal Democrats Nick Clegg (C) Leader of the Labour Party Ed Miliband (R) walk through the Members' Lobby before the Queen's Speech at the State Opening of Parliament on June 4, 2014 in London, England. Queen Elizabeth II will unveil the coalition government's legislative programme in a speech delivered to Members of Parliament and Peers in The House of Lords. Proposed legislation is expected to be introduced on a 5p charge for plastic bags in England, funding of workplace pensions, new state-funded childcare subsidy and reforms to speed up infrastructure projects. (Photo by Dan Kitwood - WPA Pool/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Queen Elizabeth II Attends The State Opening Of Parliament(16 of46)
Open Image Modal
LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 04: British Prime Minister David Cameron and Leader of the Labour Party Ed Miliband talk as they walk through the Members' Lobby before the Queen's Speech at the State Opening of Parliament on June 4, 2014 in London, England. Queen Elizabeth II will unveil the coalition government's legislative programme in a speech delivered to Members of Parliament and Peers in The House of Lords. Proposed legislation is expected to be introduced on a 5p charge for plastic bags in England, funding of workplace pensions, new state-funded childcare subsidy and reforms to speed up infrastructure projects. (Photo by Dan Kitwood - WPA Pool/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(17 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(18 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh proceed through the Royal Gallery during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster in London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(19 of46)
Open Image Modal
Members of the Household Cavalry ride through a rain shower during the State Opening of Parliament outside the House of Lords, London. (credit:PA)
BRITAIN-ROYALS-POLITICS(20 of46)
Open Image Modal
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II (R) rides with Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh (L) in the Diamond Jubilee state coach from Buckingham Palace to Parliament to attend the State Opening of Parliament in London on June 4, 2014. The State Opening of Parliament marks the formal start of the parliamentary year and the Queen's Speech sets out the governments agenda for the coming session. AFP PHOTO / ADRIAN DENNIS (Photo credit should read ADRIAN DENNIS/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
BRITAIN-ROYALS-POLITICS(21 of46)
Open Image Modal
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh ride in the Diamond Jubilee state coach from Buckingham Palace to Parliament to attend the State Opening of Parliament in London on June 4, 2014. The State Opening of Parliament marks the formal start of the parliamentary year and the Queen's Speech sets out the governments agenda for the coming session. AFP PHOTO / JUSTIN TALLIS (Photo credit should read JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Queen Elizabeth II Attends The State Opening Of Parliament(22 of46)
Open Image Modal
LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 04: A Guard of Honour leaves Buckingham Palace prior to the depature of Queen Elizabeth II to attend the State Opening of Parliament on June 4, 2014 in London, England. Queen Elizabeth II will unveil the coalition government's legislative programme in a speech delivered to Members of Parliament and Peers in The House of Lords. Proposed legislation is expected to be introduced on a 5p charge for plastic bags in England, funding of workplace pensions, new state-funded childcare subsidy and reforms to speed up infrastructure projects. (Photo by Matthew Lloyd/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
BRITAIN-ROYALS-POLITICS(23 of46)
Open Image Modal
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II (C) rides with Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh (R) in the Diamond Jubilee state coach from Buckingham Palace to Parliament to attend the State Opening of Parliament in London on June 4, 2014. The State Opening of Parliament marks the formal start of the parliamentary year and the Queen's Speech sets out the governments agenda for the coming session. AFP PHOTO / ADRIAN DENNIS (Photo credit should read ADRIAN DENNIS/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
BRITAIN-ROYALS-POLITICS(24 of46)
Open Image Modal
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh ride in the Diamond Jubilee state coach from Buckingham Palace to Parliament to attend the State Opening of Parliament in London on June 4, 2014. The State Opening of Parliament marks the formal start of the parliamentary year and the Queen's Speech sets out the governments agenda for the coming session. AFP PHOTO / JUSTIN TALLIS (Photo credit should read JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(25 of46)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II arrives aboard the new Diamond Jubilee Coach to attend the State Opening of Parliament at the House of Lords, London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(26 of46)
Open Image Modal
Members of the Guard of Honour mass in front of Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(27 of46)
Open Image Modal
Members of the Guard of Honour process past Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(28 of46)
Open Image Modal
Members of the Scots Guards process past Buckingham Palace, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(29 of46)
Open Image Modal
Members of the Guard of Honour process down The Mall, London, ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(30 of46)
Open Image Modal
Members of the media photograph Yeoman of the Guard, wearing traditional uniform, during a rehearsal for the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords, London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(31 of46)
Open Image Modal
Yeoman of the Guard, wearing traditional uniform, walk through the Royal Gallery during a rehearsal for the State Opening of Parliament, in the House of Lords, London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(32 of46)
Open Image Modal
Yeoman of the Guard, wearing traditional uniform, walk through the Royal Gallery during a rehearsal for the State Opening of Parliament, in the House of Lords, London. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament 2014(33 of46)
Open Image Modal
An Order of Service booklet resting on a chair during the State Opening of Parliament in the House of Lords at the Palace of Westminster, London. (credit:PA)
Queen Elizabeth II Attends The State Opening Of Parliament(34 of46)
Open Image Modal
LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 04: HRH Queen Elizabeth II leaves Buckingham Palace to attend the State Opening of Parliament on June 4, 2014 in London, England. Queen Elizabeth II will unveil the coalition government's legislative programme in a speech delivered to Members of Parliament and Peers in The House of Lords. Proposed legislation is expected to be introduced on a 5p charge for plastic bags in England, funding of workplace pensions, new state-funded childcare subsidy and reforms to speed up infrastructure projects. (Photo by Matthew Lloyd/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Queen Elizabeth II Attends The State Opening Of Parliament(35 of46)
Open Image Modal
LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 04: A military procession escorts the carriage of Queen Elizabeth II as it processes down the Mall to attend the State Opening of Parliament on June 4, 2014 in London, England. Queen Elizabeth II will unveil the coalition government's legislative programme in a speech delivered to Members of Parliament and Peers in The House of Lords. Proposed legislation is expected to be introduced on a 5p charge for plastic bags in England, funding of workplace pensions, new state-funded childcare subsidy and reforms to speed up infrastructure projects. (Photo by Matthew Lloyd/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Queen Elizabeth II Attends The State Opening Of Parliament(36 of46)
Open Image Modal
LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 04: HRH Queen Elizabeth II leaves Buckingham Palace to attend the State Opening of Parliament on June 4, 2014 in London, England. Queen Elizabeth II will unveil the coalition government's legislative programme in a speech delivered to Members of Parliament and Peers in The House of Lords. Proposed legislation is expected to be introduced on a 5p charge for plastic bags in England, funding of workplace pensions, new state-funded childcare subsidy and reforms to speed up infrastructure projects. (Photo by Matthew Lloyd/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Queen Elizabeth II Attends The State Opening Of Parliament(37 of46)
Open Image Modal
LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 04: Prince Charles, Prince of Wales leaves Buckingham Palace to attend the State Opening of Parliament on June 4, 2014 in London, England. Queen Elizabeth II will unveil the coalition government's legislative programme in a speech delivered to Members of Parliament and Peers in The House of Lords. Proposed legislation is expected to be introduced on a 5p charge for plastic bags in England, funding of workplace pensions, new state-funded childcare subsidy and reforms to speed up infrastructure projects. (Photo by Matthew Lloyd/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(38 of46)
Open Image Modal
Security preparations take place at the Palace of Westminster in London, ready for tomorrow's State Opening of Parliament Queen Elizabeth II. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(39 of46)
Open Image Modal
Security preparations take place at the Palace of Westminster in London, ready for tomorrow's State Opening of Parliament Queen Elizabeth II. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(40 of46)
Open Image Modal
Woods from various celebrated buildings and vessels have been used to inlay of one of the doors of the new Diamond Jubilee state coach which will be used by Queen Elizabeth II during the State Opening of Parliament on June 4. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(41 of46)
Open Image Modal
A part of the Stone of Destiny has been placed under the seats in the new Diamond Jubilee state coach which will be used by Queen Elizabeth II during the State Opening of Parliament on June 4. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(42 of46)
Open Image Modal
Made from wood reclaimed from HMS Victory the reproduction of the crown sits atop the new Diamond Jubilee state coach which will be used by Queen Elizabeth II during the State Opening of Parliament on June 4. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(43 of46)
Open Image Modal
The new Diamond Jubilee state coach which will be used by Queen Elizabeth II during the State Opening of Parliament on June 4. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(44 of46)
Open Image Modal
The two lanterns on display to the fore of the new Diamond Jubilee state coach which will be used by Queen Elizabeth II during the State Opening of Parliament on June 4. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(45 of46)
Open Image Modal
The new Diamond Jubilee state coach which will be used by Queen Elizabeth II during the State Opening of Parliament on June 4. (credit:PA)
State Opening of Parliament - Preparations(46 of46)
Open Image Modal
A wheel hub of the new Diamond Jubilee state coach which will be used by Queen Elizabeth II during the State Opening of Parliament on June 4. (credit:PA)

MPs had previously warned that a recall mechanism could be abused for party political advantage and fears were raised about the process turning into a "kangaroo court".

The government said the measures announced today would be "transparent, robust and fair" but would not lead to MPs facing "frequent and unnecessary distractions". And it insisted move will give constituents a direct voice when MPs have behaved badly.

It comes after years of wrangling that sparked bitter recriminations and rows between the two governing parties.

Recall powers formed a key plank of the coalition agreement by Cameron and Clegg in 2010 following widespread voter discontent about the House of Commons expenses scandal. Under the deal, they pledged to bring forward "early legislation" to introduce the powers but the move was repeatedly kicked into the long grass.

The proposals appeared to have been killed off earlier this year when the Liberal Democrats accused the Conservatives of scuppering the measure. But the prime minister later declared his intention to revive the plans in the wake of fresh anger over the behaviour of MPs.