John McDonnell Calls For Tax Credits U-Turn And Promises He Won't Make 'Political Capital'

John McDonnell Brings Up His Own 'Embarrassing' U-Turn In Letter To George Osborne
|

Shadow chancellor John McDonnell has called on George Osborne to reverse his plans for controversial cuts to tax credits, while admitting he also "knows what a U-turn looks like".

Mr McDonnell said had written to Osborne to say he is well aware a U-turn could be damaging - after his own climbdown on Osborne's fiscal charter.

But he promised his Tory counterpart he wouldn't make "political capital" if the Chancellor changed his mind on the plans for £4.4 billion welfare cuts.

Open Image Modal

McDonnell jokes that he also knows what a U-turn feels like

Earlier this month, McDonnell described his own U-turn on supporting Osborne's fiscal charter as “embarrassing” earlier this month, as the measure was passed in the Commons.

He was jeered by Tory MPs and repeatedly quizzed on why he had implied he opposed the charter, despite backing it two weeks before.

Joking about the flak he endured, he said: "I have written to George Osborne today to say 'I know what a U-turn looks like and how it can damage you but we need a U-turn on this one.

"So I have said to him 'look, if you can change your mind on this we will not make any political capital out of this'.

Liberal Democrats are pushing a "fatal" motion in the House of Lords that would kick out the tax credits policy entirely, and a Cabinet minister has hinted Osborne could be willing to soften the impact of cuts.

McDonnell added that Labour could support cuts to tax credits under some circumstances, if "real protection" was given to low-income families.

"It is a real offer to the Government, to George Osborne, to see if we can actually make sure people are properly protected and that at the right time, if there is a way of reducing tax credits, of course we will cooperate with them in that respect," he told BBC1's Andrew Marr Show.

"If the Lords do throw this out tomorrow and put it back to the Government, I have said to him 'if you change your mind and bring back a policy in which people are protected - not a political stunt but a real protection, we will not in any way attack you for that, in fact we will support you."

He said: "These are people who go to work, look after their kids, do everything asked of them and they are going to lose, on average, about £1,300 a year. 200,000 people could be forced into poverty."

Open Image Modal

McDonnell spoke on the Marr show with Nicky Morgan

Education Secretary Nicky Morgan defended the policy, which she insisted was in line with the Conservative's general election pitch despite apparent pledges during the campaign to spare working tax credits.

She warned peers not to make a "constitutionally unprecedented" power grab by rejecting a financial measure that had already been approved by the Commons.

The "broad package" including a higher minimum wage and increases in income tax personal allowance would offset the losses, she said - expected to reach up to £1,300 a year for millions of households.

But amid a growing chorus of senior Tories demanding action to soften the impact, she suggested measures to mitigate the effect could be put in place - perhaps in Mr Osborne's Autumn Statement on November 25.

"The Chancellor's track record has very much been about supporting, in Budgets, working families," she told the Marr show.

"I was a Treasury minister in the last Parliament, George was my boss at that point. He very much is always in listening mode."

She added: "Not the main policy, the Prime Minister has been very clear that the policy is not going to change."

"People are of course going to be worried ... but I think it's a question of working through all the numbers. But what is the alternative? We have to get the economy straight."

[Story continues below slideshow]

Jeremy Corbyn's Shadow Chancellor In His Six Most Controversial Quotes
War over welfare(01 of06)
Open Image Modal
McDonnell - unsurprisingly - defied his party's acting leader Harriet Harman in a recent vote over the Conservative Party's proposed benefit cuts.

Despite Labour whips instructing MPs to abstain, the Hayes and Harlington representative declared in July he would "swim through vomit" to rally against welfare support being slashed.
(credit:Peter Byrne/PA Archive)
'Assassinate' Thatcher(02 of06)
Open Image Modal
Perhaps his most outlandish comment comes from a leadership hustings in 2010, when McDonnell tried himself to stand himself to replace Gordon Brown after Labour's 2010 election loss.

McDonnell later apologised for his remark, which was dubbed by some as "sickening" and "distasteful".
(credit:Wesley via Getty Images)
'Overthrow Of Capitalism'(03 of06)
Open Image Modal
While touted by some as a tongue-in-cheek remark, McDonnell's 'Who's Who' entry has sparked some contention too.

The new shadow chancellor included "generally fermenting the overthrow of capitalism" in his list of favourite pastimes.
(credit:Jonathan Brady/PA Archive)
'Bravery And Sacrifice' Of IRA Members(04 of06)
Open Image Modal
In 2003, McDonnell sparked controversy with an outburst over the Irish Republican Army. His rally to honour the “bravery and sacrifice” of the republican terrorists for taking part in their "armed struggle".

"It's about time we started honouring those people involved in the armed struggle," he announced at a gathering in London to commemorate the IRA hunger striker Bobby Sands.

"It was the bombs and bullets and sacrifice made by the likes of Bobby Sands that brought Britain to the negotiating table."

Clarifying his remarks, McDonnell added soon after: "Let me be clear, I abhor the killing of innocent human beings. My argument was that republicans had the right to honour those who had brought about this process of negotiation which had led to peace."
(credit:Andrew Matthews/PA Archive)
Suspension From The Commons(05 of06)
Open Image Modal
McDonnell's sparked uproar and earned himself a five-day suspension from Parliament for violating a sacred Commons tradition.

The MP, who's constituency includes Heathrow, picked up the ceremonial mace and placed it down on one of the chamber's empty green benches, angrily lamenting that a lack of a vote on a proposed runway by his own party in government was "a disgrace to the democracy of this country".

Watch the event as it unfurled, below.



His run-in with deputy speaker Alan Haselhurst did not go down well with fellow MPs.
Rumblings And Rebellion(06 of06)
Open Image Modal
Labour's new leader was well-known amongst his colleagues as a frequent defier of party staffer's whips - instructions for MPs to vote one way or another on Commons motions.

But his new shadow chancellor is reportedly the only other Labour MP to trump Corbyn's record - taking the parliamentary mantel of rebelling against his own party's official line more times in the 2010-15 parliament than any of his colleagues.
(credit:Peter Jordan/PA Wire)

Peers will vote on Monday on a Labour motion to refuse to approve the measure unless the Government sets out "full transitional protection for a minimum of three years" for existing claimants.

Ministers are urging critics instead to back a motion tabled by Church of England bishops that would express "regret" at the failure to consider the impact but let the cuts go ahead.