Gordon Brown 'Hurt Labour's Economic Credibility' By Refusing To Use This Word

Gordon Brown 'Hurt Labour's Economic Credibility' By Refusing To Use The Word...
|
Open Image Modal
DUNDEE, SCOTLAND - AUGUST 27: Former Prime Minister Gordon Brown attends a Better Together rally on August 27, 2014 in Dundee, Scotland. Both encouraged Scots with postal votes to vote no to independence, as postal ballots are being sent out this week to voters across Scotland. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)
Jeff J Mitchell via Getty Images

Former Labour prime minister Gordon Brown's refusal to use the word "cuts" during the 2010 election hurt the party's credibility as people thought it was not serious about clearing the deficit, a senior frontbencher has said.

Chuka Umunna, Labour's shadow business secretary, suggested that Brown's decision "gave the impression we didn't understand that debt and deficit would have to be dealt with."

Speaking to GQ magazine, he said that Labour was not further ahead in the opinion polls because it had allowed itself to be blamed for the economic "mess" the country was left in.

Labour leader Ed Miliband has faced mounting pressure from his own shadow cabinet to fight harder against Tory messaging. Jon Trickett, Labour's deputy chairman, told the Huffington Post UK that the party needed to use "strong, plain language" to cut through to voters.

Open Image Modal

Umunna also admitted that Labour would struggle to win back voters over the economy, unless it tells a "hopeful, optimistic [and] aspirational" message.

Asked by interviewer Alastair Campbell, who was Tony Blair's chief spin doctor, whether Labour can win, he said: "We can. I don't know if we will, but we can, if we make the right calls, if we focus on people and their ambitions and not on the bubble at Westminster. Bill Clinton said we have to own the future.

The Labour frontbencher called on his party to talk "more proudly" about its record in government in order to win the next election, which he warned would the "nastiest" to date, adding: "We do need to explain and rebut this notion that we crashed the car.

"My view is that the seeds were sown under the last government and Gordon [Brown] - for whom I have a lot of respect - his refusal to use the word 'cuts' [as applied to Labour] in trying to frame the economic debate as [Labour] investment versus [Tory] cuts gave the impression we didn't understand that debt and deficit would have to be dealt with."

George Osborne's Budget Broken Promises
Osborne won't eliminate the deficit by 2015 (01 of07)
Open Image Modal
George Osborne promised in the 2010 emergency budget to eliminate the budget deficit by 2015-2016, but had to awkwardly move the target in his Autumn Statement last December to 2018-2019. Meanwhile, the deficit will be £79 billion in 2015.
Osborne has failed to stop debt rising by 2015(02 of07)
Open Image Modal
Osborne pledged to ensure that debt was falling by 2015-2016 in his first budget, but now is set to see debt only start to fall by 2016-2017.
Unemployment remains higher than expected(03 of07)
Open Image Modal
Osborne said in 2010 that the unemployment rate, the percentage of the economically active population out of work, would be at 6.1% in 2015.Sadly, now he's predicting that it will be 7%, despite the proliferation of zero-hours contracts and the rise of self-employed workers.
Osborne failed to protect Britain's AAA credit rating(04 of07)
Open Image Modal
Despite Osborne making a big deal of how important it was to keep Britain's AAA credit rating, Fitch and Moody's agencies stripped the UK of its triple A credit rating in a withering assessment of its economic outlook.
Osborne's export-led economy hasn't arrived yet(05 of07)
Open Image Modal
"Our policy is to raise from the ruins of an economy built on debt a new, balanced economy where we save, invest and export," he told MPs in 2010. Last week, he told Andrew Marr: "We don’t export enough, we don’t invest enough, we don’t build enough, we don’t make enough."
Osborne failed to keep living standards risings(06 of07)
Open Image Modal
The Tories promised in their 2010 manifesto to forge an economy where everyone's standard of living "rises steadily and sustainably."Yet according to Labour, workers are £1,600 off since May 2010. as ONS figures showed that wages have been remorselessly eaten away by inflation.
Growth is half what Osborne promised(07 of07)
Open Image Modal
In November 2010, the OBR forecast that the UK economy would grow by 8.4% from the last quarter of 2010 to the last quarter of 2013.How far did it actually grow? Barely half that, at 3.8%.