RBS Report Author Lawrence Tomlinson Warns About Lack Of Change In Banking Sector

'We See Noise And Nothing Changing Among The Big Banks', Warns Govt Adviser
|
Open Image Modal
A pedestrian passes a sign outside the headquarters of the Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc (RBS) in London, U.K., on Wednesday, July 18, 2012. The U.K. financial regulator said it's investigating seven lenders over attempts to manipulate interbank offered rates as lawmakers criticized it for not opening the probe earlier. Photographer: Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Bloomberg via Getty Images

Big banks are still just as dominant as they were before the recession, with no one yet jailed or held responsible for the string of banking scandals that have emerged, government adviser Lawrence Tomlinson has warned.

The serial entrepreneur, who wrote a report for the government warning that state-owned banks RBS and Lloyds were "killing off" small businesses with "unscrupulous" business practices, told HuffPostUK that the banking sector still remained an "oligopoly".

"If you look at what banks we had then and you look at it now, we're in exactly the same place. The reality is that if you want to bank as a small business, it's going to be with RBS or Lloyds, but the market share is generally static.”

He warned that the change among the big banks from the 2008 era of being "too big to fail, too big to regulate and too big to look after their customers" was so small that there was little to stop another crash in 5 years time.

"What's going to stop 2018 being another 2008? Once RBS and Lloyds are back in the private sector, the only bet anyone has got is a one way bet as if all the bets go wrong, we'll be here to bail them out."

"When was a last time a British banker went to jail? Where is the personal liability? Who has lost their pension?

"The public see all this noise about criminal activity and fraud. They don't see anything changing and, personally, I don't see a lot of change."

The multimillionaire entrepreneur, whose interests range from Ginetta race cars to care homes, poured scorn on new banking reforms that are intended to clean up the sector by setting up a "ring-fence" between banks' investment and retail arms.

Open Image Modal

Tomlinson, chairman of the LNT Group that owns Ginetta sports cars, poses to mark sponsoring the Celebrity Allstar Football Team

"We've already had a ring fence, we already had an electrified ring fence, and now we're having an electrified ring fence with landmines? Great!"

Tomlinson spoke to HuffPostUK before he is set to be appear before the Treasury Select Committee to be grilled about his report, which accused RBS of operating like a "hit squad" by withdrawing lines of credit from healthy firms and burdening them with huge fees so they could seize the businesses assets, normally property, at discount prices.

Reasons Why The Banks Aren't Yet In Order
Barely Anyone Thinks Banks Are Well Run(01 of07)
Open Image Modal
They're Still Not Lending To Businesses (02 of07)
Open Image Modal
The big banks have been battling to get money out of the door to help British SMEs but are still struggling as business lending has fallen in most parts of Britain. An investigation by Lawrence Tomlinson, the business department's entrepreneurial adviser, found that government-owned banks were "crucifying" firms in the way they managed their financial support.
PPI Mis-selling Drags On(03 of07)
Open Image Modal
Banks are still paying out millions for mis-sold payment protection insurance.This has led to a peak in complaints too.
Credit Card Theft Insurance Mis-selling Surfaces(04 of07)
Open Image Modal
Over a dozen high street banks and credit card firms have agreed on a compensation fund of more than £1 billion for potentially for seven million people who had been mis-sold credit card and identity theft protection.It all stems from card insurance policies supplied by York-based CPP Group.
Was There Gilt-Rigging?(05 of07)
Open Image Modal
Did the Bank of England miss an attempt by traders to rig the gilt market too? Tory MP Andrea Leadsom thinks so.Financial regulators are investigating. Meanwhile one of the Bank officials said such an attempt at a dodgy trade would be "reprehensible" if proven.
Bank Bonuses Are On The Up (06 of07)
Open Image Modal
Banker bonuses effectively increased by 4% over last year to £38.6 billion, after banks deferred bonuses to take advantage of George Osborne's 50p income tax rate coming in.Osborne's introduction of the lower 45p income tax band, announced in his Budget last year means that the taxpayer lost out on an estimated £85 million as banks deferred £700 million of bonuses to April this year.Also, we have three times more millionaire bankers than the rest of the EU combined.
Oh Yes, And The Libor Rigging (07 of07)
Open Image Modal
Regulators are still looking into the Libor interbank fixing scandal, bringing charges against traders they have managed to single out.

The entrepreneur's allegations focus on the banks' "very concerning patterns of behaviour" with the use of business support programmes, like RBS' Global Restructuring Group (GRG) divison, which are meant to help firms struggling to pay off their loans.

The report, written by Tomlinson as the business department's "entrepreneur-in-residence", concluded: "Some of the banks, RBS and Lloyds in particular, are harming their customers through their decisions and causing their financial downfall".

The entrepreneur said he had been contacted by around 1,000 businesses who claimed they had been treated badly by the big banks.

Treasury select committee chairman Andrew Tyrie told HuffPostUK that it was "clear" that the state-backed bank's culture had been "inimicable to good quality servicing of SME lenders", admitting that "we cannot be confident" that such abusive practises will not happen again.

In response to Tomlinson's report, and a similar report by Sir Andrew Large, RBS chief executive Ross McEwan brought in the legal firm Clifford Chance to examine the allegations.

Sir Andrew, a former deputy governor of the Bank of England, told the Treasury select committee that he thought Tomlinson's allegations were "plausible".

But he added: "Equally they [the allegations] are so strong and the behaviours are so extreme that one wants to feel they can't be true. That is why this forensic work is so important."

Tomlinson told HuffPostUK that for as long as GRG is "perceived as doing what it's doing", it will take RBS "longer than a generation" to win back the public's trust.

He added: "I haven't heard them say sorry yet...!"

A spokesman for RBS said: "GRG successfully turns around most of the businesses it works with, but in all cases is working with customers at a time of significant stress in their lives.

"Not all businesses that encounter serious financial trouble can be saved."