MPs Ask Bankers To Prove They Are Regulated Too Much

'Dear Bankers, Why Must We Cut The Rules Stopping You Taking Risks?'
|
Open Image Modal
triloks via Getty Images

Bankers claiming that they are regulated too much should produce detailed figures to back up their complaints, senior Tory MP Andrew Tyrie has said.

This comes after Douglas Flint, chair of Britain's biggest bank HSBC, warned that the level of regulation was "hugely consumptive of resources" and risked encouraging "unwarranted risk aversion" as bankers seek to protect themselves.

Tyrie, chair of the influential Commons Treasury committee, told the Financial Times that Flint's complaint was "very important", but added: “It is for the industry to demonstrate that that is the case.”

Tyrie, who chaired the parliamentary commission on banking standards that put forward proposals to fix Britain's banking sector last year, warned politicians against "groaning on" about banks' failings.

“It’s crucial that politicians exercise judgment too and don’t drive regulators into a corner where they protect themselves from criticism by over-regulating,” he said.

Speaking earlier this week, HSBC boss Douglas Flint said: "Greater focus on conduct and financial crime risks at all levels of the firm globally is clearly the right response to past shortcomings.

"There is, however, an observable and growing danger of disproportionate risk aversion creeping into decision-making in our businesses as individuals, facing uncertainty as to what may be criticised with hindsight and perceiving a zero tolerance of error, seek to protect themselves and the firm from future censure.

"We can address this behaviour through training and leadership, but we also need clarity from public policy and regulatory bodies over their expectations in this regard."

Tyrie also weighed in to defend the Bank of England for unveiling a bank bonus clawback system that will not affect anyone who has already received their bonus.

The rules governing the clawback mechanism, which will come into effect from next January, will not apply retrospectively, the Bank's Prudential Regulation Authority confirmed. This was due to a concern that many banks would have to obtain their employees consent and "might be open to challenge for doing so".

Tyrie said that the Bank's stance showed the risk that regulators "“endlessly pile on regulation in an effort to demonstrate activity, which could all too easily act as a substitute for thinking through what is really needed”.

Reasons Why The Banks Aren't Yet In Order
Barely Anyone Thinks Banks Are Well Run(01 of07)
Open Image Modal
They're Still Not Lending To Businesses (02 of07)
Open Image Modal
The big banks have been battling to get money out of the door to help British SMEs but are still struggling as business lending has fallen in most parts of Britain. An investigation by Lawrence Tomlinson, the business department's entrepreneurial adviser, found that government-owned banks were "crucifying" firms in the way they managed their financial support.
PPI Mis-selling Drags On(03 of07)
Open Image Modal
Banks are still paying out millions for mis-sold payment protection insurance.This has led to a peak in complaints too.
Credit Card Theft Insurance Mis-selling Surfaces(04 of07)
Open Image Modal
Over a dozen high street banks and credit card firms have agreed on a compensation fund of more than £1 billion for potentially for seven million people who had been mis-sold credit card and identity theft protection.It all stems from card insurance policies supplied by York-based CPP Group.
Was There Gilt-Rigging?(05 of07)
Open Image Modal
Did the Bank of England miss an attempt by traders to rig the gilt market too? Tory MP Andrea Leadsom thinks so.Financial regulators are investigating. Meanwhile one of the Bank officials said such an attempt at a dodgy trade would be "reprehensible" if proven.
Bank Bonuses Are On The Up (06 of07)
Open Image Modal
Banker bonuses effectively increased by 4% over last year to £38.6 billion, after banks deferred bonuses to take advantage of George Osborne's 50p income tax rate coming in.Osborne's introduction of the lower 45p income tax band, announced in his Budget last year means that the taxpayer lost out on an estimated £85 million as banks deferred £700 million of bonuses to April this year.Also, we have three times more millionaire bankers than the rest of the EU combined.
Oh Yes, And The Libor Rigging (07 of07)
Open Image Modal
Regulators are still looking into the Libor interbank fixing scandal, bringing charges against traders they have managed to single out.