Ukip MEP William Dartmouth showed a "lack of candour" in his "vague" explanation of his connection to a Yorkshire onshore wind farm application, Lib Dem MEP Graham Watson has warned.
Any revelation that Dartmouth was financially benefitting from wind turbines would be politically fatal given Ukip's vehement opposition to wind farms. Professor Tim Congdon was forced to stand down as a Ukip parliamentary candidate after it emerged that he had signed wind-farm deals on his Scottish estates.
Dartmouth transferred the land on which the Valley Wind Co-operative hope to build turbines on to a company called Rosscroft Limited, according to a Land Registry document dated 10th February 2011. Rosscroft is currently run by offshore directors based in the Bahamas and Monaco.
Questions were raised about Dartmouth's links to the Valley Wind Co-operative project after the MEP was named as a relevant tenant in the wind farm's planning application to Kirklees Council, suggesting that the turbines would be directly built on his land.
Sir Graham Watson said: “I am not suggesting the Earl of Dartmouth has done anything illegal.
“However I believe his statement leaves a number of questions which remain unanswered. Does William Dartmouth have any financial interest in Rosscroft Limited who stand to gain financially from this application? Does he deny that he transferred land from his own estate to Rosscroft Limited back in 2011 knowing that the land was potentially subject to application to build windfarms on?
“UKIP and the Earl of Dartmouth have been consistently opposed to onshore wind farm development. In last week’s debate with Nick Clegg, Nigel Farage criticised land owners seeking to earn money by hosting wind turbines.
“There appears to be a lack of candour on his part. Dartmouth says that he “derives no benefit to the land as it stands”. Yet he has been vague in answering what his interest in Rosscroft Limited is. Particularly given that Land Registry documents show that the land transfer from Dartmouth was ‘not for money’.
“Some people may conclude it would be hypocritical for anyone to be a senior member of a political party vehemently opposed to wind farms on one hand, whilst being connected to a planning application to build 300 foot wind turbines on the other.”
Dartmouth claimed that he had been added in error to the planning document as a relevant tenant, despite the public document being available publicly and uncorrected for several months.
Kirklees Council told HuffPostUK that the Earl's incorrect inclusion did not jepoardise the application, but that he could still try and influence the project.
"The purpose of the certification requirement is to enable those who have an interest in the land which is subject to a planning application to be notified of the application so that they have knowledge of it and can therefore make representations. It does not imply consent to the application," a council spokesperson said.
"William Dartmouth has now indicated that he is not an owner/has another legal interest in the application site but we are advised that the application is not invalidated by wrongly including him."
In response, Dartmouth said: "It is completely over the top to be accused of hypocrisy by Sir Graham Watson, a man who accepted a knighthood from Her Majesty whilst an active Republican and who campaigns against the Monarchy.
"In his statement Sir Graham rightly points out that I receive no benefit from the land as it stands. Typically he omits the last part of that sentence which reads 'or if the application was granted'."
"He also says I am 'connected" to the application. I have made it perfectly clear that I have not made any application and that I do not own the land."
"Perhaps Sir Graham would be better served if he concentrated on trying to save his seat as a Lib Dem MEP in the forthcoming Euro elections."
Previously, the Earl of Dartmouth said in a statement: "I am not the applicant. I do not own the land in question.
"The land which is the subject of the planning application is owned by a relative. I derive no benefit, financial or otherwise, from the land as it stands, nor would I if the planning application were successful.
"An adjacent piece of land, which is owned by me, was erroneously included in the application.This strip of land would not be involved in the wind turbine application in any shape or form.
"As a UK Independence Party MEP I fully endorse the party policy to oppose onshore wind turbine development.
"The reason that the name Rosscroft Ltd appears on the above planning application, as well as in relation to land which I do own, is that they represent the entire extended Dartmouth family as well as many other clients.'
Ukip's Highs And Lows
COMING UP INTO THE WORLD: Ukip Are Born(01 of22)
Open Image ModalGOING DOWN: 1997 General Election(02 of22)
Open Image ModalUkip fielded 193 candidates but only got 0.3% of the vote, losing out to the just as Europhobic Referendum Party, led by billionaire publisher and politician, Sir James Goldsmith, (left), who got 2.6%.Sked resigned saying Ukip "they are racist and have been infected by the far-right", a reputation they have yet to shake.He was replaced with Michael Holmes (credit:PA)
GOING UP: James Goldsmith Dies(03 of22)
Open Image ModalThe unfortunate death of the rival party leader led to the dissolution of the Referendum Party with many members subsequently joining Ukip. (credit:Alamy)
GOING UP: 1999 Elections To European Parliament(04 of22)
Open Image ModalUkip got 7% of the vote and gained three MEPs.This jolly looking chap, Jeffrey Titford, was one of them. (credit:PA)
GOING DOWN: Holmes Resignation And 2001 General Election(05 of22)
Open Image ModalHolmes was forced to resign in 200 due to a conflict between himself and the Ukip's National Executive Committee.Titford became leader.In the following year's general election Ukip failed to gain any seats with a 1.5% of the vote.(The man pictured is not a member Ukip but a pictorial representation of the misery felt by the party during this difficult time) (credit:Alamy)
GOING STEADY: Knapman Takes Over(06 of22)
Open Image ModalTitford decided he didn't really like being leader and so was replaced with this fellow, Roger Knapman in 2002.Knapman attracted some attention in 2006 when he employed a team of Polish builders to renovate his home despite his anti-immigration stance. (credit:PA)
GOING WAY UP: 2004 European Elections (07 of22)
Open Image ModalBuilding on their previous European success, Ukip went on to gain a (in relative terms) massive 12 MEPs in 2004. Godfrey Bloom, seen here far-right, immediately triggered a storm of protest over women's rights within hours of starting work in the European Parliament. After being given a place on the Parliament's Women's Rights Committee he told journalists he wanted to deal with women's issues because "I just don't think they clean behind the fridge enough", adding: "I am here to represent Yorkshire women who always have dinner on the table when you get home. I am going to promote men's rights." What a charming gent... (credit:PA)
GOING DOWN TO THE PERMA-TANNED BOTTOM: Kilroy(08 of22)
Open Image ModalGOING UP PAST THE TORIES: Hartlepool By-Election(09 of22)
Open Image ModalGOING DOWN TO THE BEACH: 2005 General Election(10 of22)
Open Image ModalUkip were rubbish.They didn't gain a single seat and their best result was third place in Boston & Skegness. (credit:Alamy)
GOING UP. OR DOWN DEPENDING ON YOUR OPINION OF THIS MAN: Nigel Farage(11 of22)
Open Image ModalSeptember 2006 saw the introduction of Farage as leader. (credit:PA)
GOING UP WITH BAGS OF CASH(12 of22)
Open Image ModalIn 2009, Tory party donor extraordinaire, Stuart Wheeler, jumped ships and gave Ukip £100,000.He was, rather unsurprisingly, expelled from the Conservative party for his treachery. (credit:Alamy)
GOING DOWN WITH SOME DODGY FRIENDS: Geert Widlers(13 of22)
Open Image ModalIn 2009 Farage stood down as Ukip leader so he could contest the seat of Buckingham.Lord Pearson was chosen to replace him.Here is Pearson at a joint press conference with well-known Dutch extreme right-winger and general Islam hater, Geert Wilders.#justsayin (credit:PA)
GOING UP THROUGH THE POLITICAL GLASS CEILING: 2009 European Elections(14 of22)
Open Image ModalA climate where the electorate were slightly miffed at a banking crisis at the amount some MPs were claiming on expenses was a bonus for Ukip.They gained 16.5 per cent of the vote, or to put it another way, they beat the government. (credit:PA)
GOING DOWN AGAIN: 2010 General Election(15 of22)
Open Image ModalFarage lost to John Bercow.Once again, Ukip failed to win a single seat.This disaster however was slightly overshadowed by... (credit:PA)
GOIND DOWN RATHER QUICKLY AND WITH A SLIGHT BUMP: Plane Crash(16 of22)
Open Image ModalFarage was a passenger in this plane when it crashed on the morning of the elections. He broke his sternum, ribs and punctured a lung.The cause of the crash was put down to the Ukip banner the plane was towing getting caught in aircraft's tail. (credit:PA)
GOING UP A LITTLE BIT: Farage Re-Election(17 of22)
Open Image ModalFarage was re-elected in August 2010.Lord Pearson said: "The UKIP crown returns to its rightful owner".How nice of him... (credit:PA)
GOING UP HIGHER THAN THEY'D EVER BEEN BEFORE: Rotherham By-Election(18 of22)
Open Image ModalUKIP's Jane Collins came second in the 2012 vote with Ukip's highest ever share in a parliamentary election. (credit:PA)
GOING UP SO MUCH IT MADE FARAGE DO THIS FACE: Eastleigh By-Election(19 of22)
Open Image ModalCometh the hour, cometh the grin.This was a huge coup for Ukip as they took second place in front of Labour and the Conservatives in 2013. (credit:PA)
GOING DOWN WITH RACIAL PREJUDICE: Election Candidate Scandals(20 of22)
Open Image ModalFLYING HIGH: Local Elections 2013(21 of22)
Open Image ModalHe's right to look chuffed with himself.Ukip came second in the South Shields by-election and got 26 per cent of the vote in the local elections.The Conservatives and Liberal Democrats both lost seats.The biggest surge by a fourth placed party since WWII does not bode well for the coalition in 2015. (credit:PA)
(22 of22)
Open Image ModalThis slide has nothing to do with anything but this picture can NOT go to waste... (credit:Getty Images)