Scottish Independence Not Good For Businesses Says ITV Chairman Archie Norman

Scottish Independence 'Not Good For Businesses'
|

The chairman of ITV has claimed there is no economic strategy for an independent Scotland and said it is in the interests of businesses both there and in England for the UK to stay together.

Archie Norman, a former Conservative MP, dismissed plans for a breakaway as advocated by the Scottish National Party as "a few windmills and hydropower", in an article for the Sunday Telegraph.

Norman, who has a Scottish family background, urged business leaders to focus on making a positive case for the country's future within the Union despite "intimidatory" independence rhetoric backed by "vitriolic" social media outbursts.

Story continues after slideshow...

Business leaders who oppose Scottish independence
PricewaterhouseCoopers(01 of10)
Open Image Modal
PwC’s UK chairman Ian Powell said: “From a PwC perspective, we believe in a United Kingdom and we believe that the right thing is you do have as big an economic unit as you can.”
Lloyds Banking Group(02 of10)
Open Image Modal
In its annual report, Lloyds warned: "The impact of a 'yes' vote in favour of Scottish independence is uncertain."The outcome could have a material impact on compliance costs, the tax position, and cost of funding for the group."
Barclays(03 of10)
Open Image Modal
The bank said that Scottish independence would hurt business by "introducing potentially significant new uncertainties and instability in financial markets, both ahead of the respective dates for these referenda and, depending on the outcomes, after the event".
BP (04 of10)
Open Image Modal
Bob Dudley, chief executive of the oil giant, claimed there were ''quite big uncertainties'' over issues such as currency, European links and tax regimes if Scotland voted for independence.Maybe that's why David Cameron felt happy to pose on a BP oil rig.
Power generator giant Aggreko(07 of10)
Open Image Modal
Generator giant Aggreko, which employs around a tenth of its 5,749 worldwide employees in Scotland, warned that Scottish independence would create years of uncertainty and hiatus".
Duncan Bannatyne (08 of10)
Open Image Modal
Sainsbury's chief Justin King(09 of10)
Open Image Modal

The ex-Asda boss, who was writing in his capacity as chairman of investment bank Lazard UK, said: "Business in both England and Scotland has a huge vested interest in the UK staying together.

"Wherever business people stand personally on the issue, a separate Scotland would almost certainly result in more complexity, more regulation and greater uncertainty. So, business leaders need to express a view and so long before panic sets in."

Norman said the Better Together campaign against independence had been primarily negative, focusing on the risks of a split on currency and finances.

But a business campaign should focus on Scotland's "natural advantages" of cultural heritage, quality of life and higher literary and numeracy.

He said it could attract inward investment far better as part of the UK, while the country could also "harness the great traditions of Scottish entrepreneurship" and rebuild a technology and financial services base.

"Scottish business needs to find its voice and back the union. The independence movement should not have a monopoly on hope.

"They don't have a strategy: a few windmills and hydro power do not provide a base for economic recovery."

It was the latest warning about the implications of independence, though Norman said many business leaders "do not want to put their heads above the parapet".

He claimed there was a "strong intimidatory tone" to the independence rhetoric and that social media could be "vitriolic" about No campaigners.

Norman said Standard Life - which last month said it could move some operations out of Scotland in the event of a vote for independence - had taken a "remarkably bold stance".

Last week, defence giant BAE Systems said a No vote in the Scottish independence referendum offered "greater certainty and stability" for its business.