Bill Browder, The Brit Fighting Russia Death Threats And Libel Suits To Take On The Kremlin (INTERVIEW)

INTERVIEW: 'Driving A Truck Through British Law'
|
Open Image Modal
File/AP

A Russian policeman planning to sue a British hedge fund boss through British courts, for alleging he was part of a conspiracy to torture and murder lawyer Sergei Magnitsky, could end up "driving a truck through British law".

The case, if a judge allows it to be heard, will be a true test for the long battle for libel reform in the UK.

On Wednesday, a judge will consider whether an hitherto unknown Russian official, Lieutenant Colonel Pavel Karpov, can use the British justice system and British lawyers to fight his case.

Russian officials have called financier Bill Browder a fraudster and a fantasist, and he is the subject of death threats, legal battles and diplomatic crises.

But, he says, it will not deter him from fighting for justice for a friend who he believes died at the hands of Russian authorities.

Browder alleges Russian officials falsely imprisoned, tortured and killed his lawyer, Sergei Magnitsky after both he and Browder blew the whistle on a massive scandal, involving criminal gangs colluding with Russian authorities to steal millions from Russian taxpayers.

"They are so desperately trying to cover it up, that they are willing to kill the key whistleblower, prosecute him posthumously, and pursue me in every possible way, including threatening my life," Browder told The Huffington Post UK.

"We weren't the main victims of the fraud, the Russian people were the victims. But the other victim was Sergei, who exposed the fraud. When he died, it changed my life. I couldn't live comfortably knowing he died because of me."

A British judge will hear arguments this week from both sides as to whether the case is an "abuse" of the British legal system, because it concerns a Russian litigant.

It comes at a difficult time for Russia, currently embroiled in the diplomatic mess that is the NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden, and his bid for asylum in Russia to save him from prosecution in the US.

The world is watching how Russia treats its own whistleblowers.

"I was initially sympathetic to the sentiments behind Snowden's campaign of exposing government's invasion of privacy," Browder said.

"But his narrative has started to fall apart the moment he threw in his lot with the Russians who tortured and killed Sergei Magnitsky for exposing government corruption in Russia."

The Russians, he alleges, aren't concerned about damaging their reputation of the country in their pursuit of him. "The Russian government officials involved, the only thing they care about is their money.

"These people are trying to protect their money by trying to discredit the whistleblowers. This is about personal wealth of government officials in Russia. It's as simple as that.

"It's a criminal gang running a sovereign nation, using any tool inside and outside their country to pursue anyone trying to shut down their crimes."

Open Image Modal

Hedge fund boss Bill Browder

Browder, who is US-born but a naturalised UK citizen, will learn this week if the Russian man he accuses of being part of the fraud, and the killing of Magnitsky, has the right to sue him in the UK for libel

British libel law campaigners have called for measures against foreign defendants being dragged to London; and also foreign claimants bringing cases against UK defendants, when the reputation was mainly harmed elsewhere.

However, only the first of these issues was dealt with in the newly signed Defamation Act 2013. There is nothing in the new law that would limit the kind of action brought against Browder.

"If this case were to go forward, this would be like driving a truck through libel reform law, this is the test case if there ever was one, " Browder said.

The man in question who is suing Browder is Lieutenant Colonel Pavel Karpov, a former police officer who was the target of serious allegations of corruption on Browder's website.

Browder alleged that Karpov was involved in the shady death of his young colleague and fellow whistleblower Magnitsky.

Browder invested millions in Russian companies via his Hermitage Capital Management. But amid allegations of improper conduct, Russian authorities blacklisted him, revoked his visa in 2005 and raided his offices.

Browder fled the country, but his friend and lawyer Sergei Magnitsky stayed, and the decision cost him his life. Magnitsky, who was posthumously convicted of fraud just weeks ago, is believed to have been tortured and denied medical aid, dying in police custody three years ago.

Doctors who found him described his body as lying in a pool of his own urine, his arms covered in bruises.

Browder, who was convicted of tax evasion in absentia alongside the dead Magnitsky, has accused Karpov and other Moscow officials, and of orchestrating his friend's death.

Amnesty International called the trial of Browder and Magnitsky, the first where a dead defendant had been tried, “a whole new chapter in Russia’s worsening human rights record” and a “sinister attempt to deflect attention from those who committed the crimes he exposed”.

Interpol has refused to include UK-based Browder on its international criminal search list after deciding that Russia's case against him is "of a predominantly political nature".

Open Image Modal

A protester holds a poster which reads: Are orphans guilty of Magnitsky's death ?' after a bill banning Americans from adopting Russian children, as retaliation for a US law that allows the seizure of assets from Russian officials implicated in Magnitsky's death

Browder also implicates Karpov and 60 other officials in an alleged fraud scandal where more than £140m was taken from Russian taxpayers, a fraud that he and Magnitsky discovered and publicised. The money was given to a criminal gang posing as subsidiaries of Hermitage, who told the Russian authorities they were owed a tax rebate of millions.

Since being driven from Russia, Browder has run the website 'Russian Untouchables', where he publishes his exposes of corruption in the country. In a video published in English and Russian, he alleges Karpov has become wealthy since the scam, enjoying foreign holidays and owning luxury cars.

Karpov has vocally denied any allegations of impropriety, and is being represented by top libel lawyers Olswang and lawyers Andrew Caldecott QC and Geraldine Proudler. Karpov claims he owned all his luxury goods before the scam took place in 2007.

In the court documents published by the Independent in January, his lawyers say Browder has caused their client “serious hurt, embarrassment and distress," implicating him in fraud, torture and murder.

The case has become a major international embarrassment for the Kremlin, embroiling the police, tax officials, the judiciary and the Interior Ministry in the scandal.

The dispute has caused international ripples, with governments responding tit-for-tat.

The US has approved a new law, the Magnitsky Act, that bans anyone allegedly implicated in Magnitsky's death from entering their territory, and Browder is lobbying UK and European governments to follow suit.

The Russians responded with a shock ban on US overseas adoptions of Russian children.

"I have campaigned for justice, hoping for prosecutions for torture, murder and fraud in Russia," Browder said.

"But we have been rebuffed at every turn, there is no possibility for justice there at all. Then we had to take the campaign to the West, to fight for sanctions in the West against the people involved in this crime."

Human Rights After Putin
Alexei Navalny(01 of09)
Open Image Modal
Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny speaks during a major protest rally in Bolotnaya Square in Moscow, Russia, Monday, May 6, 2013. Up to 20,000 Russian opposition supporters gathered for a protest on Monday, venting anger against the Kremlin and demanding the release of political prisoners. The protest came exactly one year after a demonstration a day before President Vladimir Putins third presidential inauguration on the same square near the Kremlin ended in violent clashes between demonstrators and police. (AP Photo/Mikhail Metzel) (credit:AP)
Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, Maria Alekhina Yekaterina Samutsevich(02 of09)
Open Image Modal
In this Wednesday, Oct. 10, 2012 file photo, feminist punk group Pussy Riot members, from left, Yekaterina Samutsevich, Maria Alekhina and Nadezhda Tolokonnikova sit in a glass cage at a court room in Moscow, Russia. A Russian court is weighing Wednesday, Jan. 16, 2013 whether Maria Alekhina can serve the remainder of her two-year sentence when her 5-year-old son is 14. Alekhina is petitioning the court in Berezniki, a remote Ural mountains town near where she is serving her sentence. She was convicted last year along with two other band members of hooliganism motivated by religious hatred for an anti-President Vladimir Putin stunt in Russia's main cathedral. (AP Photo/Sergey Ponomarev, File) (credit:AP)
Lilya Shibanova(03 of09)
Open Image Modal
Leader of Russia's independent election monitoring group Golos, Lilya Shibanova, works in the Golos office in Moscow, Russia, Wednesday, Sept. 19, 2012. Russia on Wednesday explained its decision to put an end to the U.S. Agency for International Development's two decades of work in Russia by saying the U.S. government agency was using its money to influence elections. (AP Photo/Alexander Zemlianichenko) (credit:AP)
Maxim Luzyanin(04 of09)
Open Image Modal
In this file photo dated Friday, Nov. 9, 2012, Maxim Luzyanin attends his trial on charges that he attacked riot police during a massive rally against Russian President Vladimir Putin in a district court in Moscow, Russia. A gym owner and bodybuilder, Maxim Luzyanin, was subdued with a taser and later pleaded guilty and paid for a policeman's dental repair before being sentenced to four and a half years in prison, over his involvement in the May 6, 2012 opposition protest. (AP Photo/Yevgeny Feldman, Novaya Gazeta) (credit:AP)
Alexandra Dukhanina (05 of09)
Open Image Modal
In this Sunday, May 6, 2012 file photo, a Russian police officer detains protester Alexandra Dukhanina during an opposition rally in Moscow. Dukhanina was placed under house arrest on charges of assailing police by a court in Moscow. The youngest of the defendants, environmental activist Alexandra Dukhanina is one of the more than two dozen people who are facing criminal charges over the involvement in the May 6, 2012 opposition protest that ended in violent clashes between demonstrators and police. (AP Photo/Roustem Adagamov, File) (credit:AP)
Konstantin Lebedev(06 of09)
Open Image Modal
In this Monday, April 22, 2013 file photo, opposition activist Konstantin Lebedev charged with instigation of mass riots during last May's rally against Vladimir Putin's return to the Kremlin, listens to his lawyer in the Moscow City Court before a court session in Moscow, Russia. Lebedev pleaded guilty and testified against opposition leaders, including leftist leader Sergei Udaltsov. More than two dozen people are facing criminal charges over their alleged involvement in the May 6, 2012 opposition protest that ended in violent clashes between demonstrators and police. (AP Photo/Yevgeny Feldman, FILE) (credit:AP)
Denis Lutskevich(07 of09)
Open Image Modal
In this photo taken Sunday, May 6, 2012, Denis Lutskevich, left, is detained by police during an opposition rally in Bolotnaya Square in Moscow. The former naval cadet and first-year student, 21-year-old Lutskevich was attending his first protest when he was detained, and is still in prison Monday May 6, 2013, on the first year anniversary of the protest. Lutskevich is one of more than two dozen people who are still held, facing criminal charges over the involvement in the May 6, 2012 opposition protest that ended in violent clashes between demonstrators and police. (AP Photo/Pavel Golovkin) (credit:AP)
(08 of09)
Open Image Modal
In this May 6, 2012 file photo, a wounded opposition protester winces in pain during a rally in Moscow. Riot police in Moscow began arresting protesters who were trying to reach the Kremlin in a demonstration on the eve of Vladimir Putin's inauguration as president. (AP Photo/Mikhail Metzel, File) (credit:AP)
(09 of09)
Open Image Modal
This Oct. 31, 2012, file photo, shows police officers detaining an opposition activist during an unsanctioned protest rally in St. Petersburg, Russia. Tensions between the U.S. and Russia have been rising. The countries have been at odds over Syrias civil war, Irans nuclear program and Russias crackdown on domestic opposition. U.S. officials are uneasy about what they see as a more assertive foreign policy by Vladimir Putin, who returned to the Russian presidency in May. (AP Photo/Dmitry Lovetsky, File) (credit:AP)