Kentucky Senator Rand Paul Files Lawsuit Against Barack Obama Over NSA Surveillance Programmes

Senator Files Lawsuit Against Obama Over NSA Surveillance Programmes
|
Open Image Modal
Rand Paul (centre) is bring the law suit against Barack Obama (left) following the Edward Snowden (right) leaks

A Republican senator is to hit president Obama with a lawsuit on Wednesday that aims to halt surveillance by USA spy agencies which have been intercepting private communications both at home and abroad, as revealed by the Edward Snowden leaks.

Entitled 'Rand Paul v. Barack Obama', the Kentucky Senator is asking the Federal court in Washington DC to declare part of the Patriot Act, the legislation signed into law by George W Bush after the 9/11 attacks that enables agencies such as the NSA to monitor private phone calls, unconstitutional. Those named as defendants include the president, FBI director James Comey, director of the NSA General Keith Alexander and director of National Intelligence, James Clapper.

The legal action currently has around 350,000 plaintiffs, with Paul, a staunch libertarian and a candidate for the Republican presidential nomination in 2016, looking to corral many more. In a Fox News interview in December, Paul said that “everybody who has a cell phone would be eligible to become a plaintiff”.

The thrust of Paul’s complaint focuses on the metadata – the bulk phone records collected from American telecommunications companies – routinely collected by the NSA, which includes details such as phone numbers, dates and times of calls.

Several other lawsuits challenging the collection of this metadata are already pending in federal courts across the US. However Paul’s challenge is different in that it’s a class action suit, which means the plaintiff is not only seeking damages for themselves, but also for anyone who has been affected by the perceived wrongdoing.

Speaking to MSNBC, Stephen Vladeck, a law professor at American University, said of Paul’s suit: "Ostensibly, he could be suing on behalf of all Americans, or all Americans hypothetically affected by these court orders."

Addressing his supporters via a video message on Tuesday, Paul said: "When we learned that the NSA was collecting the phone data of every American last year it posed a serious Constitutional question: Do we no longer have a Fourth Amendment?"

The Fourth Amendment to the US Constitution, part of the Bill of Rights, prohibits unreasonable searches and seizures and requires any warrant to be judicially sanctioned and supported by probable cause.

In a statement released this week, Paul outlined his case against Obama, arguing that the president has "publicly refused to stop a clear and continuing violation of the Fourth Amendment," with the 51-year-old senator expecting the case to go all the way to the US Supreme Court.

The White House has yet to publicly comment on the lawsuit but, in a speech on security given earlier in January, Obama argued that members of the intelligence community "follow protocols designed to protect the privacy of ordinary people", adding: "They're not abusing authorities in order to listen to your private phone calls or read your emails."

Paul is expected to give a press conference in front of the federal courthouse in the capital after the suit has been filed, with the senator trumpeting his credentials as a defender of the constitution against encroachment of the intelligence services.

However, Paul’s critics, many of whom are from the Republican Party, have lambasted the move, with Peter King going as far as to question the Senator’s place in government.

"The NSA is doing exactly what it is supposed to be doing," said King in an interview earlier this month, adding: "To me, he’s either totally uninformed, or he’s part of that ‘hate America’ crowd that I thought left us in the 1960s.

"In any event, he doesn’t deserve to be in the United States Senate for spreading that type of misperception and absolute lies."

The scope of the NSA’s surveillance programme gained international notoriety last June after former NSA contractor Snowden, who is currently in asylum in Russia, released a tranche of classified documents about US and British spying activities.

Snowden's 21 Asylum Bids
AUSTRIA(01 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: NoInterior minister Johanna Mikl-Leitner, said no request could be filed from outside the country, but said if Snowden arrived in the country, he could not be deported because no international arrest warrant exists (credit:Alamy)
BOLIVIA(02 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: Maybe..President Evo Morales says his country is willing to consider US intelligence leaker Edward Snowden's political asylum request. (credit:Alamy)
BRAZIL(03 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: NOBrazil will not grant asylum, a Foreign Ministry spokesman said on Tuesday, adding that it will leave the request unanswered. (credit:Alamy)
CHINA(04 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: UnknownChina's Foreign Ministry spokeswoman said she had no information on Snowden's asylum bid. (credit:Alamy)
CUBA(05 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: UnknownNo response yet from Havana, but Snowden's inability to get on a plane to Havana last week might give some indication about how the Cuban government feels regarding his asylum claim. (credit:Alamy)
ECUADOR(06 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: NoPresident Rafael Correa told the Guardian in an interview that he was not considering Snowden's asylum request, because Snowden was not on Ecuadorian territory, and would not issue him travel documents. (credit:Alamy)
FINLAND(07 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: NoThe reply came from the country's foreign ministry spokeswoman Tytti Pylkkö - saying that Snowden had to be in Finland to apply. (credit:Alamy)
FRANCE(08 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: UnknownNo public response yet from the French government (credit:Alamy)
GERMANY(09 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: Unknown, but very unlikelyThere has been no official response, but like most countries, an application may be made only if the asylum-seeker is residing in Germany. Under the Residence Act: "A foreigner may be granted for the admission from abroad for urgent humanitarian reasons a residence. This is reportedly being considered by the federal government, but is unlikely to apply to Snowden. (credit:Alamy)
ICELAND(10 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: NoIceland said the request was legally invalid from outside its territory. (credit:Alamy)
INDIA(11 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: NoForeign ministry spokesman Syed Akbaruddin, tweeted: "Following careful examination we have concluded that we see no reason to accede to the Snowden request" (credit:Alamy)
ITALY(12 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: Stil considering.. Italy said it was "evaluating" the request which it dubbed "irregular" because it was not made in person. (credit:Alamy)
IRELAND(13 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: NoA Justice Ministry spokesman said an asylum application could only be accepted from a person who was on Irish soil. (credit:Alamy)
THE NETHERLANDS(14 of21)
Open Image Modal
The answer: NoNetherlands Justice Minister Fred Teeven says Snowden is not eligible for asylum. "Since 2003 it is no longer possible to serve from abroad" (credit:Alamy)
NICARAGUA(15 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: UnknownNothing yet from the country's government, (credit:Alamy)
NORWAY(16 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: NoAs with many European countries, it won't accept petitions filed from abroad. (credit:Alamy)
POLAND(17 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: NoUnequivocal. Poland's Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski tweeted that his country would reject the asylum bid from Snowden, saying: "We received a letter that does not meet the formal application [requirements] for asylum. "But even if it was fulfilled, I will not give a positive recommendation." (credit:Alamy)
RUSSIA(18 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: Snowden withdrew his requestVladimir Putin's statement said Snowden could only be considered for asylum if he stopped "his work aimed at bringing harm to our American partners" (credit:Alamy)
SPAIN(19 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: NoSpain's Foreign Minister José García-Margallo said his country will not grant Snowden asylum as he does not fulfil the requirements - he is not on Spanish territory. (credit:Alamy)
SWITZERLAND(20 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: UnknownSwitzerland does not normally allowed applications from outside its territory apart from in exceptional circumstances - and there have only been six in its history. (credit:Alamy)
VENUZEULA(21 of21)
Open Image Modal
The reply: Nothing firm, but probably the best chance.President Nicolás Maduro is currently in Moscow and said he would consider the request, saying: "We think this young person has done something very important for humanity, has done a favour to humanity." (credit:AP)