Sky News Reporter Colin Brazier's Emotional Explanation For MH17 Gaffe

Colin Brazier's Emotional Explanation For MH17 Gaffe
|

Sky News reporter Colin Brazier has spoken of his "error of judgment" after he was filmed rifling through the luggage of a flight MH17 victim live on air.

In an emotional explanation Brazier described the moment he caught himself in the middle of a grave mistake.

Brazier was accused of invading the privacy of the dead and faced a furious backlash after he appeared to nonchalantly pick up a set of keys and a toothbrush from an open suitcase during a broadcast on Sunday afternoon.

Suddenly realising his mistake, during the report he can be heard regretfully saying: "We shouldn't really be doing this, I suppose."

Open Image Modal

Colin Brazier reporting live from the crash site in Gravobo, Eastern Ukraine.

Now, the veteran journalist - who has covered war zones across the globe - has spoken from the heart in an attempt to explain his error at the scene of the disaster which took 298 lives.

Open Image Modal

Brazier picks up what appears to be a drinks container from a suit case.

"At the weekend I got things wrong," he said. "If there was someone to apologise to in person, I would."

"The crash site of flight MH17 is like the set of a horror story," he wrote in the Guardian. "Except that movies are never allowed to show what we saw over the weekend."

"As I type I can smell the nauseating scent of death that clings to me still."

Describing the emotional impact journalists suffer at the scenes of such atrocities, Brazier described the "shocking" scenes.

"I could not comprehend what we were seeing. Bodies and body parts everywhere. I phoned my wife. 'It's a butcher's yard, I said."

In the frank commentary piece, Brazier explains that during the live broadcast he spotted a victim's pink drinking flask, identical to one owned by his 6-year-old daughter.

He describes how he "lost it" when he saw the poignant item laying in a field scattered with charred body parts, and broke out in tears while on air as he bent down to touch the victims' possessions.

"It is a cardinal sin of broadcasting, in my book anyway, to start blubbing on-air," he said. "I fought for some self-control, not thinking all that clearly as I did so."

"Too late, I realised that I was crossing a line. I thought aloud: 'we shouldn't be doing this … this is a mistake', an instant apology that was only selectively quoted by those determined to see what I did as a powerful example of journalistic vulturism," he wrote.

The moment Brazier handled the luggage live on air prompted 110 complaints to broadcast watchdog Ofcom.

David Cameron called the incident "completely inappropriate," while the family members of British victims have spoken out in outrage.

Asked if media should behave itself while covering MH17, the Prime Minister said: "People are leafing through personal belongings in a way that is completely inappropriate," he said.

He said while it was "mostly separatists" doing this, there "have been occasions where mistakes have been made by members of the press".

Cameron added: "this is effectively a murder scene."

Leeds University student Richard Mayne was one of those who perished on board the Malaysia Airlines flight when it was hit by a surface-to-air missile last Thursday.

Speaking from the family home in Leicestershire, his brother Thomas told the Daily Mail: “I think it’s totally out of order. It’s not on.

Open Image Modal

Leeds University student Richard Mayne died in the crash

“It’s sick and the worst example of news journalism which is sensationalising an appalling human tragedy.

“On behalf of our family, I totally denounce the practice of Sky reporters looking through the victims’ possessions.

“I really hope Richard’s stuff isn’t part of that but it’s really not on. For all the families involved, they really should not be doing it.”

Sky News apologised for the gaffe on Sunday, with a spokesman saying: “Today whilst presenting from the site of the MH17 air crash, Colin Brazier reflected on the human tragedy of the event and showed audiences the content of one of the victims’ bags.

Open Image Modal

MH17 victim Richard Mayne (pictured right) with his brothers Thomas (left) and William (centre)

“Colin immediately recognised that this was inappropriate and said so on air. Both Colin and Sky News apologise profusely for any offence caused.”

Meanwhile, the ABC reporter who faced public outrage for touching debris at the devastating scene has defended his actions saying "it's not as though it's a crime scene".

Phil Williams was shown handling victims' belongings in a report that was later removed from the ABC website for re-editing.

Williams told the broadcaster's PM show on Monday: "I am guilty of picking up, touching a scarf on the ground".

"There are piles of people's belongings that have just been collected and dumped on the roadside, they've been picked through and so it's not as though it's a crime scene, an uncontaminated crime scene there," he explained.

He added: "It's a very difficult scene to report on. Literally the evidence is everywhere you walk."

An ABC spokesman said "the ABC has reminded journalists of responsibilities when reporting from an air crash scene such as MH17. A report has been re-edited to avoid any distress to our audience."

Forensics experts fear permanent interference to the crash site will hinder the investigation and the identification of bodies. There have been widespread reports of looters, military personnel and local workers traipsing all over the area.

In another example of evidence potentially being damaged at the scene, a BBC reporter was filmed handling victims documents live on air.

Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17 in Ukraine
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(01 of74)
Open Image Modal
Richard Mayne pictured in April 2014 in Nepal.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(02 of74)
Open Image Modal
Mo, Evie and Otis Maslin were on board MH17 along with their grandfather Nick Norris.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(03 of74)
Open Image Modal
Ben Pocock who has been confirmed as one of the passengers.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(04 of74)
Open Image Modal
Newcastle United fan John Alder, who was known as ‘The Undertaker’, is believed to have been making his way to New Zealand to watch the Magpies on their pre-season tour (credit:Paul Blacklock)
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(05 of74)
Open Image Modal
Newcastle United football fan Liam Sweeney who was believed to have been on his way to watch this beloved team's pre-season tour
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(06 of74)
Open Image Modal
Robert Ayley
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(07 of74)
Open Image Modal
Stephen Anderson
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(08 of74)
Open Image Modal
Mo, Evie and Otis Maslin were on board MH17 along with their grandfather Nick Norris.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(09 of74)
Open Image Modal
Elaine Teoh
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(10 of74)
Open Image Modal
German woman Fatima Dyczynski, 24, was one of four Germans on #MH17.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(11 of74)
Open Image Modal
Emiel Mahler
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(12 of74)
Open Image Modal
Roger Guard
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(13 of74)
Open Image Modal
Jill Guard
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(14 of74)
Open Image Modal
Sister Philomene Tiernan
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(15 of74)
Open Image Modal
Nick Norris
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(16 of74)
Open Image Modal
Joep Lange
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(17 of74)
Open Image Modal
Glenn Thomas from Blackpool who has been killed in Malaysian air disaster flight MH17 over the Ukraine.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(18 of74)
Open Image Modal
Elaine Teoh and her long-time boyfriend Emiel Mahler, who both died on flight MH17.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(19 of74)
Open Image Modal
Albert and Maree Rizk who are believed to be among the Australians killed in the crash.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(20 of74)
Open Image Modal
Gerry and Mary Menke were killed on the flight
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(21 of74)
Open Image Modal
Martine de Schutter
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(22 of74)
Open Image Modal
Pim de Kuijer
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(23 of74)
Open Image Modal
Helena Sidelik, who died aboard MH17
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(24 of74)
Open Image Modal
Azrina Binti Yakob was also on board the Boeing 777
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(25 of74)
Open Image Modal
Angeline Premila was reportedly on the Malaysian Airline flight MH17
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(26 of74)
Open Image Modal
Flight steward Sanjid Singh,
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(27 of74)
Open Image Modal
Liliane Derden
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(28 of74)
Open Image Modal
Pilot Eugene Choo Jin Leong was flying Air Malaysia MH17
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(29 of74)
Open Image Modal
Frankie and Liam Davison.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(30 of74)
Open Image Modal
Regis Crolla posted an image Instagram, with the comment "AMS --> Kuala Lumpur --> Bali."
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(31 of74)
Open Image Modal
Cor Pan (left) and his partner Neeltje Tol
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(32 of74)
Open Image Modal
Chief stewardess Dora Shahila Binti Kassim
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(33 of74)
Open Image Modal
Shazana Salleh who was also reportedly a flight attendant on board the flight
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(34 of74)
Open Image Modal
Yuli Hastini, John Paulissen and their two children Arjuna and Sri who were on board the Air Malaysia flight
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(35 of74)
Open Image Modal
Wayne Sujana is believed to be missing
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(36 of74)
Open Image Modal
Ninik Yuriani was reportedly on a trip back to Central Java
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(37 of74)
Open Image Modal
Dutch passengers Astrid Hornikx and Bart Lambregts
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(38 of74)
Open Image Modal
24-year-old Ontario medical student Andrei Anghel was among the 298 people killed when a Malaysia Airlines plane was downed over Ukraine
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(39 of74)
Open Image Modal
Karlijn Keijzer was a 25-year-old doctoral student in the chemistry department at the Indiana University College of Arts and Sciences.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(40 of74)
Open Image Modal
Hendry Se in this handout photograph released on July 18, 2014 by the family of Hendry Se, an Indonesian passenger on the crashed Malaysia Airlines flight MH17, shows Henrdy at her graduation.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(41 of74)
Open Image Modal
Howard and Susan Horder
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(42 of74)
Open Image Modal
Pim de Kuijer
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(43 of74)
Open Image Modal
Quinn Lucas Schansman was reportedly on his way to a family vacation in Malaysia.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(44 of74)
Open Image Modal
Emma Bell
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(45 of74)
Open Image Modal
Wan Amran Wan Husin
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(46 of74)
Open Image Modal
Gary Slok and his mother Petra posed for the photo aboard Flight MH17 hours before the plane was allegedly shot down and crashed.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(47 of74)
Open Image Modal
Sydney-based kindergarten teacher Gabriele Lauschet (right) has been identified as NSW's sixth victim on flight MH17
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(48 of74)
Open Image Modal
Dutch language teacher Dafne Nieveen was killed while flying home to Perth
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(49 of74)
Open Image Modal
Victor Oreshkin
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(50 of74)
Open Image Modal
Arjen Ryder and wife Yvonne from Albany, Queensland, were travelling together
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(51 of74)
Open Image Modal
Marie Rizk was travelling with her husband on board MH17
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(52 of74)
Open Image Modal
Recently retired couple Wayne and Theresa Baker
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(53 of74)
Open Image Modal
Edel Mahady was returning to Perth for the start of the school term at Good Shepherd Catholic Primary School, Kelmscott
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(54 of74)
Open Image Modal
Shaliza Dewal and her Dutch husband Hans Van Den Hende were travelling from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur with their three children, Piers, 15, Marnix, 12, and daughter Margaux, 8
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(55 of74)
Open Image Modal
Michael and Carol Clancy
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(56 of74)
Open Image Modal
Gary Lee ran a Chinese restaurant while his wife Mona who was a schoolteacher
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(57 of74)
Open Image Modal
A photograph of Indonesian man Wayan Sujana of Bali, believed to be missing on Air Malaysia flight MH17, is fixed to the ticketing desk of Air Malaysia at Schiphol Airport on July 18, 2014 in Amsterdam, Netherlands. (Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(58 of74)
Open Image Modal
Dutchman Itamar Avnon was on a trip to Israel for a wedding and stopped over in Amsterdam to visit friends
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(59 of74)
Open Image Modal
Melbourne-based IT security consultant Marco Grippeling
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(60 of74)
Open Image Modal
Jack O'Brien of Sydney, was 25.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(61 of74)
Open Image Modal
Elsemiek de Borst
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(62 of74)
Open Image Modal
Bryce Fredriksz and his girlfriend, Daisy Oehlers, were killed in the Malaysia Airlines 17 flight disaster.
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(63 of74)
Open Image Modal
Angeline Premila Rajandran
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(64 of74)
Open Image Modal
Jennifer van der Leij
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(65 of74)
Open Image Modal
Andrew Hoare with wife Estella and sons Jasper and Friso
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(66 of74)
Open Image Modal
This June 26, 2014 family photo released by Ross Campbell, shows Sue Campbell, left, Ross Campbell, Albert Rizk, second from right, and Maree Rizk, right, while they are on holiday in Florence, Italy. Albert and Maree Rizk died in the downed Malaysia Airlines Flight 17. (AP Photo/Ross Campbell) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(67 of74)
Open Image Modal
In this Monday, July 21, 2014 photo, candles are lit next to a portrait of Irene Gunawan, one of three Filipinos who died in the Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 downed over in eastern Ukraine, on an improvised altar prior to a novena prayer at her clan residence at Pagbilao township, Quezon province south of Manila, Philippines. Irene, her two children and her Indonesian husband Budy, were killed along with 294 others onboard the flight. (AP Photo/Jim Gomez) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(68 of74)
Open Image Modal
In this undated photo released by the Calehr family, Samira Calehr, left, poses with her son Shaka Panduwinata. Shaka Panduwinata and his brother Miguel Panduwinata, were killed aboard Malaysia Airlines Flight 17, which was shot down over eastern Ukraine. (AP Photo/The Calehr family) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(69 of74)
Open Image Modal
In this undated photo released by the Calehr family, Miguel Panduwinata, left, Mika Panduwinata, Samira Calehr, second from right, and Shaka Panduwinata, right, pose for a photo. Shaka Panduwinata and his brother Miguel Panduwinata were killed aboard Malaysia Airlines Flight 17, which was shot down over eastern Ukraine. (AP Photo/The Calehr family) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(70 of74)
Open Image Modal
In this July 2011 photo provided by Ron Peter Pabellon, Irene Gunawan poses with her son Darryl at a resort in her Philippine hometown of Pagbilao, Quezon province, while attending a family reunion with her husband Budy, who is of Indonesian descent, and daughter Sherryl. The Gunawan family, which was based in the Netherlands, was heading to the Philippines for another reunion when their Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 was believed to have been shot down over Ukraine. All 298 passengers and crew were killed. (AP Photo/Ron Peter Pabellon) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(71 of74)
Open Image Modal
This 2011 family reunion photo provided by the Pabellon family, shows Irene Gunawan, second from left in back row, her Indonesian husband Budy, right in front row, and their children Darryl, second from left in front row, and Sherryl, fifth from left, in back row, with their relatives in Pagbilao township, Quezon province, south of Manila, Philippines. Irene, her two children and her Indonesian husband Budy were killed along with 294 others onboard Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 which crashed over eastern Ukraine. (AP Photo/Pabellon family) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Victims of Air Malaysia Flight MH17(72 of74)
Open Image Modal
In this undated photo released by the Calehr family, Miguel Panduwinata poses for a photo. Miguel and his brother Shaka Panduwinata were killed aboard Malaysia Airlines Flight 17, which was shot down over eastern Ukraine. (AP Photo/The Calehr family) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
(73 of74)
Open Image Modal
Cameron Dalziel was one of the victims of MH17 pictured with wife Reine
(74 of74)
Open Image Modal
Shuba Jaya, and her Dutch filmmaker-husband Paul Goes with their daughter, Kaela, were among the 298 people onboard Malaysia Airlines flight MH17