Shaun Wright Resigns From Labour But Refuses To Quit Police After Rotherham Sex Abuse Scandal

It's Probably Time For Wright To Admit He's Got To Go
|

South Yorkshire police and crime commissioner Shaun Wright has resigned from the Labour Party, but insisted he would not leave his post.

Mr Wright's resignation came after Labour threatened to suspend him unless he stepped down in the wake of a damning report into child abuse in Rotherham.

He has faced repeated calls to quit because he was the Rotherham Council cabinet member for children's services between 2005 and 2010.

But in a statement he said: "I formally tender my resignation from the Labour Party. However, I remain committed to, and intend to remain in, my role as an Independent Police and Crime Commissioner for South Yorkshire."

Mr Wright defended a two-decade record in public service and insisted protecting vulnerable people was his number

one priority as commissioner, a post to which he was elected in 2012.

His statement, posted on the official website of the South Yorkshire police and crime commissioner, said: "I have had to make the difficult decision to stand down from the Labour Party and it's with deep regret that I've come to that decision.

"I've dedicated my career and life to serving the public of South Yorkshire. As a father, and a citizen of South Yorkshire, my thoughts are with the victims and their families and I reiterate my apology to them and take full responsibility for my part in the collective failures which took place at Rotherham Council during the time I was in office and indeed to that end I resigned in 2010.

"I stand by my earlier comments that I've taken that experience to deliver a major transformation in the way South Yorkshire Police deals with horrific crimes such as child sexual exploitation, and much progress has been made since I was elected as commissioner in terms of supporting victims, taking preventive action, increasing awareness of the issue and bringing criminals to justice.

"I was elected to deliver the people's policing and crime priorities in South Yorkshire and I intend to see that duty through by leading the force on that urgent, and fundamental, journey of improvement for the sake of past, present and potential victims, who are the most important people in all of this."

Open Image Modal

Shaun Wright, the South Yorkshire PCC (for now)

Shadow police minister Jack Dromey earlier confirmed Labour would have suspended Mr Wright from the party today had he failed to resign from his £85,000-a-year post.

Labour is powerless to stop Mr Wright from continuing as an independent for the rest of his term in office.

Mr Dromey told Newsnight last night: "(Mr Wright) should resign. He had the power to act and he did not use that power to defend the powerless.

"He needs therefore to accept responsibility. If he does not resign then he will be suspended tomorrow morning."

Mr Dromey said there needed to be an investigation by the Independent Police Complaints Commission to ensure South Yorkshire Police and its officers were properly held to account.

Mr Dromey's intervention came at the end of a day in which Home Secretary Theresa May appeared to back calls from Mr Wright's party that he had to quit.

She said: "Shaun Wright obviously has had involvement in this, both as his role as a councillor and obviously he's now the police and crime commissioner.

"It's not my job as Home Secretary to hire and fire police and crime commissioners. The whole point of them is that they are elected by the people, so ultimately it is a choice for the electorate.

"But I believe his own party have called for him to resign. I believe he has real questions to answer and I think in the circumstances he should heed those calls."

Mr Wright was the council cabinet member responsible for children's services in Rotherham from 2005 to 2010, in the middle of a 16-year period when, according to the report, 1,400 youngsters suffered widescale sexual exploitation

including gang rapes, grooming and trafficking.

So far he has resisted pressure for him to leave the post, insisting he had no knowledge of the "industrial scale" of child abuse when he was a Labour councillor in the town.

Mr Wright said he believed the report's author, Professor Alexis Jay, should have gone further in naming officials responsible for the failings identified in her report.

But Prof Jay has cast doubt on the assertion that Mr Wright did not know about what was happening in the town.

She said: "Part of my remit was to identify what information was available to key people in positions of influence throughout that time.

"And there was certainly a very great deal of information available from an early stage; indeed from at least 2001, both through a youth project which did outreach work with these young victims and children's social care.

"Names of potential perpetrators, car registration numbers, a very great deal of detail. Really by April 2005, it seemed to me that nobody could say 'I didn't know'."

Prof Jay's report revealed that although the majority of perpetrators were described as "Asian" by victims, councillors did not engage directly with the Pakistani-heritage community to discuss how to tackle the issue and some staff were nervous about identifying the abusers' ethnic origins "for fear of being thought racist".

Harry Harpham, chairman of South Yorkshire's police and crime panel, said he believed Mr Wright's position had become "untenable" and called on him to stand down.

The Labour councillor told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that he had been unable to speak to Mr Wright but insisted he would be seeking an urgent meeting to communicate his view.

He went on: "He should resign at the earliest opportunity.

"He can only be removed from office by resigning or unless he commits a criminal offence.

"We are not able to remove him, however, I will seek an urgent meeting with Shaun to let him know my position."

Asked whether he thought lessons had been learned, Mr Harpham said he would be meeting with the chief constable of South Yorkshire Police to discuss the findings of the report.


WHAT THE DAMNING REPORT ACTUALLY SAID


What the Rotherham abuse report actually says
The Issue Of Ethnicity(01 of06)
Open Image Modal
Those on the frontline in fighting child sexual abuse in Rotherham were "acutely aware" of "a general nervousness in the earlier years about discussing them, for fear of being though of racist". Senior people in the council and police conveyed the message that the "ethnic dimensions" of the abuse should be downplayed. But the report also says it was confident that "ethnic issue did not influence professional decision-making in individual cases". Staff had no personal experience of any attempt to influence their decision making over ethnic issues. The failure, by some councillors, to recognise that the 2010 convictions of abusers was part of a deep-rooted problem within the Pakistani-heritage community was "at best naive and at worst ignoring a politically inconvenient truth," the report says. (credit:Imgorthand via Getty Images)
A Lack Of 'Interest' In The Issue(02 of06)
Open Image Modal
The council leadership (former council leader Roger Stone pictured) showed "little obvious leadership or interest" in child sexual exploitation, beyond their financial support for Risky Business, an outreach service for children at risk of it. Potential reasons for the lack of interest were "denial it could occur in Rotherham, concern it could damage community cohesion, worry about the reputation risk to the borough". Although the council funded Risky Business, its own Children's Services department regarded the service as "something of a nuisance" and the relationship between the two was tense. (credit:Anna Gowthorpe/PA Wire)
Police 'Did Not Believe' Data About The Problem(03 of06)
Open Image Modal
There were three earlier reports on the issue from 2002, 2003 and 2006. They all gave stark evidence to police and the council and "could not have been cleared in their description of the situation". But they failed to convince some. The 2002 report was "effectively suppressed" because senior officers at South Yorkshire Police did not believe the data it presented. The other two reports sought to identify links between child abuse and other crimes such as drugs and guns. The police and the council took no action in response to them. (credit:Dave Thompson/PA Archive)
Senior Leaders Didn't Support Staff(04 of06)
Open Image Modal
In the early 2000s, a group of people from safeguarding agencies tried, on their own initiative, to meet to monitor large groups of the children deemed to be at risk of abuse. But senior managers with the police and the council's children's social care thought the scale of the problem, described by youth workers, was exaggerated and offered little help or support. (credit:Mykola Velychko via Getty Images)
Council Children's Services Were Understaffed(05 of06)
Open Image Modal
From 2009, Rotherham Council's (chief executive Martin Kimber pictured) children's social care service was "acutely understaffed and overstretched", leaving it struggling to cope with demand. (credit:Dave Higgens/PA Wire)
Policies To Improve The Issue Were Devised - But Not Implemented Well(06 of06)
Open Image Modal
New policies on procedures on child sexual exploitation were drawn up to help agencies work together, after Ofsted published a scathing report on the council's children's safeguarding services. But the follow-up in ensuring the policies were implemented was weak. Members of the Rotherham Safeguarding Children Board did not check whether the policies were implemented or working well. "Their challenge and scrutiny was lacking over several years at a time when it was most required," the report says. Roger Stone, who led the council from 2003 until his resignation yesterday, apologised for the safeguarding being so poor. The report is less than forgiving: "This apology should have been made years earlier and the issue given the political leadership it needed." (credit:monkeybusinessimages via Getty Images)