Magna Carta's Meaning Was A Mystery To Prime Minister David Cameron Three Years Ago

David Cameron Reminded Of Magna Carta Embarrassment On Letterman Three Years Ago
|

David Cameron has been criticised for using the anniversary of Magna Carta to push his political agenda to scrap the Human Rights Act.

Monday marks the 800th anniversary of Magna Carta and is regarded by many as laying the foundations for modern democracy, protecting freedoms and defending personal liberty.

On June 15, 1215, on the banks of the Thames, in Runnymede, King John met with a rebel group of English barons and placed his seal the document.

Today, the Prime Minister joined the Queen and the Archbishop of Canterbury to celebrate the 800th anniversary, but in 2012 he was unable to explain what Magna Carta actually was.

A fact not lost on many people today.

American chat show host David Letterman asked Cameron what the literal translation of Magna Carta was. Cameron said: “Again, you are testing me.”

Letterman replied: “Oh it would be good if you knew this.” Cameron said: “Yeah, well it would be.”

Cameron's lack of clarity on Magna Carta in 2012 didn't help the Prime Minister as he drew a parallel between the historic charter and the Human Rights Act - which he pledged to scrap in the face of huge opposition from legal experts.

In Cameron's speech at Runnymede today, he said: "For centuries, [Magna Carta] has been quoted to help promote human rights and alleviate suffering all around the world.

"But here in Britain, ironically, the place where those ideas were first set out, the good name of ‘human rights’ has sometimes become distorted and devalued.

"It falls to us in this generation to restore the reputation of those rights – and their critical underpinning of our legal system.

"It is our duty to safeguard the legacy, the idea, the momentous achievement of those barons and there couldn’t be a better time to reaffirm that commitment than on an anniversary like this."

Not everyone was entirely convinced the prime minister had got his timing or tone right. Labour's shadow justice secretary lambasted Cameron for using the anniversary to "attack fundamental rights".

Lord Charles Falconer said: "David Cameron claims he is safeguarding the legacy of Magna Carta but his own plans would scrap people’s basic rights and threaten the UK’s standing in the world.

"If the Prime Minister was serious about safeguarding the legacy of Magna Carta he wouldn’t be using its anniversary to attack fundamental rights.

"David Cameron should drop any plans to repeal the Human Rights Act and to withdraw from the European Convention on Human Rights immediately."

The article continues below slideshow:

The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(01 of21)
Open Image Modal
Soldiers stand on parade at a Magna Carta 800th Anniversary Commemoration Event on June 15, 2015 in Runnymede, United Kingdom. Members of the Royal Family are visiting Runnymede to attend an event commemorating the 800th anniversary of Magna Carta. Magna Carta is widely recognised as one of the most significant documents in history. Its influence, as a cornerstone of fundamental liberties, is felt around the world in the constitutions and political traditions of countless nations. (Photo by Chris Jackson - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(02 of21)
Open Image Modal
Speaker of the British House of Commons John Bercow (L) arrives ahead of a service to mark the 800th anniversary of Magna Carta (Photo by Ben Stansall - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:WPA Pool via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(03 of21)
Open Image Modal
British Prime Minister David Cameron takes the stage to make a speech during a service to mark the 800th anniversary of Magna Carta (Photo by Ben Stansall - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:WPA Pool via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(04 of21)
Open Image Modal
Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby delivers a speech during a service (Photo by Ben Stansall - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:WPA Pool via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(05 of21)
Open Image Modal
The Magna Carta memorial is seen during a service to mark the 800th anniversary (Photo by Ben Stansall - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:WPA Pool via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(06 of21)
Open Image Modal
British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond (2R) arrives ahead of a service to mark the 800th anniversary (Photo by Ben Stansall - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:WPA Pool via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(07 of21)
Open Image Modal
British Prime Minister David Cameron delivers a speech (Photo by Ben Stansall - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:WPA Pool via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(08 of21)
Open Image Modal
British Prime Minister David Cameron (Photo by Ben Stansall - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:WPA Pool via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(09 of21)
Open Image Modal
Seated near the Magna Carta memorial at Runnymede, England, are from left, The Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby, Prime Minister David Cameron, and Queen Elizabeth II, ahead of a commemoration ceremony (Steve Parsons / Pool photo via AP) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(10 of21)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II (Photo by Chris Jackson - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(11 of21)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(12 of21)
Open Image Modal
Princess Anne, Princess Royal attends a Magna Carta 800th Anniversary Commemoration Event - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(13 of21)
Open Image Modal
Princess Anne, Princess Royal attends a Magna Carta 800th Anniversary Commemoration Event on June 15, 2015 - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(14 of21)
Open Image Modal
(L-R) Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby, Prime Minister David Cameron, Queen Elizabeth II, Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh, Prince William, Duke of Cambridge, Princess Anne, Princess Royal and Timothy Lawrence - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(15 of21)
Open Image Modal
Prince William, Duke of Cambridge - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(16 of21)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II unveils a plaque at a Magna Carta 800th Anniversary Commemoration Event - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(17 of21)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II greets the Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby (Photo by Chris Jackson - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(18 of21)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II talks to Sarah Goad as the Magna Carta Commemoration Monument is seen in the background (Photo by Chris Jackson - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(19 of21)
Open Image Modal
Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh chats to Prince William, Duke of Cambridge (Photo by Chris Jackson - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(20 of21)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II chats to British Prime Minister David Cameron. (Photo by Chris Jackson - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)
The 800th Anniversary Of Magna Carta(21 of21)
Open Image Modal
Queen Elizabeth II arrives at a Magna Carta 800th Anniversary Commemoration Event (Photo by Chris Jackson - WPA Pool / Getty Images) (credit:Chris Jackson via Getty Images)

Director of civil liberties campaigners Liberty Shami Chakrabarti added: "The Prime Minister could give a masterclass in bare-faced cheek, using Magna Carta day to denigrate our Human Rights Act.

"But we will take no lessons in rights and freedoms from a leader who wants to dilute them to the detriment of everyone in the UK and wider watching world."

Guardian cartoonist Martin Rowson was also unimpressed with Cameron's tone.

The Cameron caricature is sat in front of some parchment which says that he will enshrine the "inalienable right of all free peoples everafter to neverending budget surpluses and no tax rises (unlike Labour tee hee)."

An American flag with arms has a sword poised behind Cameron's back. Secretary of State for Justice, Michael Gove, holds a torn-up 'legal aid' document and is standing on the Human Rights Act, which has been left on the muddy floor.

10 Worrying Things About The Tories' Human Rights Proposals
The proposals says that the ECHR banned whole-life tariffs for prisoners, but they didn't(01 of10)
Open Image Modal
Dominic Grieve, the former attorney general, called it a "howler" based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the Strasbourg ruling, and that UK sentencing laws had been found to be "totally compatible". Adam Wagner, human rights barrister from 1 Crown Office Row, called it a "major factual error". (credit:Fiona Hanson/PA Archive)
It's very unlikely the UK could be granted special status to have the Strasbourg court as a mere 'advisory' body(02 of10)
Open Image Modal
In practice, these proposals pretty much mean leaving the European Convention of Human Rights, lawyers say, leaving us in the company of Belarus and Kazakhstan. Russia, Azerbaijahn and Ukraine are just some of the countries that would have more watertight human rights protection than the UK. (credit:Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
If we want special treatment from the ECHR, then won't other countries want it too?(03 of10)
Open Image Modal
Legal commentator Joshua Rozenberg points out that "if Westminster has a veto on Strasbourg’s decisions, the parliaments of Russia, Ukraine and other countries will want one too, making compliance with court rulings voluntary would undermine the entire convention system." (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
The proposals "limit the use of human rights laws to the most serious cases...ensuring UK courts strike out trivial cases."(04 of10)
Open Image Modal
There doesn't seem to be any real clarification about what that will mean, leaving judges scratching their heads. (credit:peterspiro via Getty Images)
One of the proposals actually means we are more tightly legally bound to the Strasbourg court than we are already(05 of10)
Open Image Modal
The document says "every judgement that UK law is incompatible with the Convention will be treated as advisory and we will introduce a new Parliamentary procedure to formally consider the judgement. It will only be binding in UK law if Parliament agrees that it should be enacted as such." Carl Gardner points out in his Head of Legal blog that "this proposal puts more human rights obligations on Parliament than it has under the Human Rights Act. There is currently no legal duty on Parliament to consider any Strasbourg judgment. The Conservatives plan would oblige it to for the very first time." (credit:Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
Grayling has forgotten to mention how this would work under the Good Friday agreement with Northern Ireland or with Scottish devolution(06 of10)
Open Image Modal
It is a requirement under the Good Friday agreement that ultimately people in NI can take cases to the ECHR. Chris Grayling has just written a paper which makes no reference to this issue or how it can be solved, except saying 'We will work with the devolved administrations and legislatures as necessary to make sure there is an effective new settlement across the UK'. Westminster could change the law for both countries, but there's been no consultation and no reference to it in this paper, and it's likely Scotland would seek to devolve it. If Scotland or NI want to stay linked to the ECHR, then we could end up with a "patchwork" of different human rights laws across the United Kingdom. (credit:Dorling Kindersley via Getty Images)
British judges are now likely to find more UK legislation is incompatible with human rights, not fewer(07 of10)
Open Image Modal
The new proposals say the Tories will "prevent our laws from being effectively re-written through ‘interpretation’ of Strasborg case law."
"I don’t think this has been thought through," Gardner writes on Head of Legal. "If judges think old housing legislation discriminates against a gay tenant, they can rule that it is no longer to be read as permitting the discrimination.
"But if that option is barred, they will in case like that have no option but to declare the legislation incompatible with human rights in principle.
The result, surely, will be more headlines about judges condemning Parliament for breaching human rights, not fewer."
(credit:Lewis Whyld/PA Archive)
The proposals mean we don't have to worry as much about sending people off to be tortured(08 of10)
Open Image Modal
The “real risk” test used to determine whether someone is at risk of torture on deportation will be "revised..in line with our commitment to prevent torture and in keeping with the approach taken by other developed nations”. "If there is evidence that an individual faces a real risk of torture on return, should the UK seriously be seeking shortcuts?" asks Angela Patrick is the Director of Human Rights Policy at JUSTICE. (credit:Cristian Baitg via Getty Images)
It would take an enormous amount of time, effort and consultation to end up with basically the same thing we have already(09 of10)
Open Image Modal
No one thinks we should scrap laws against, say, slavery, or free speech, or the right to protest. So the new "Bill of Rights" would be 99% a carbon copy of what we already have, only enforced by British judges, several legal commentators have pointed out. Unless we scrap human rights altogether. (credit:Peter Macdiarmid via Getty Images)
The proposal doesn't even spell "judgment" in the correct legal way(10 of10)
Open Image Modal
Gardner points out that this means the proposal probably wasn't drafted by lawyers, at least in parts. (credit:JGI/Jamie Grill via Getty Images)