Jack The Ripper Mystery Continues As 'Scientific Error Means Aaron Kosminski Was Wrongly Identified'

Back To The Drawing Board: Jack The Ripper Was NOT A Polish Barber
|

Jack the Ripper, who murdered at least five women in London’s East End in 1888, was finally unmasked as a Polish immigrant barber named Aaron Kominski.

Businessman and amateur sleuth Russell Edwards announced the findings after hiring Dr Jari Louhelainen, an expert in the forensic investigation of historic crime scenes.

Open Image Modal

A contemporary illustration of the discovery of Catherine Eddowes' body

Dr Louhelainen’s analysis of a shawl owned by one of the Ripper’s victims, Catherine Eddowes, reportedly revealed Kominski’s DNA to be present – after comparisons with swabs taken from one of his British descendants.

It reports Dr Louhelainen “appears to have made a basic error” in his calculations by placing a decimal point in the wrong place, when using a DNA database to calculate the chances of a genetic match.

Story continues beneath slideshow

9 Things You Didn't Know About Jack The Ripper
The letters supposedly from the murderer, which gave us the name "Jack the Ripper," were almost certainly written by journalists.(01 of08)
Open Image Modal
Some were sent to Scotland Yard, but many were sent to the Central News Agency. A few newspapers of the time said outright that they were fraudulent, and one magazine even produced a parody of Macbeth to indicate who they thought was responsible for them, and why: "Enter three Editors…" they wrote: "Round about the cauldron go, In it slips of ‘copy’ throw. / Headlines of the largest size -- / Murderer’s letters – all faked lies…Bubble, Bubble! Crime and Trouble / Make our circulation double." (credit:AP)
The Ripper learns from Sherlock Holmes (02 of08)
Open Image Modal
Sherlock Holmes’s first outing was in 1887, the year before the Ripper appeared, in A Study in Scarlet. When Catherine Eddowes was found dead, there was an inscription on a nearby wall which may have said "The Juwes are the men that will not be blamed for nothing." The police had it erased immediately, fearing it would lead to anti-Semitic riots. In A Study in Scarlet, Holmes had found the mysterious world "Rache" written in blood on the wall of the room in which a dead man lay.The foolish police thought the dying man had tried to write "Rachel," but Holmes (ta-da!) recognized it as German for "revenge." It is hard to see this inscription near Mrs. Eddowes as anything other than another journalistic confection, by a reporter who had read his Conan Doyle.
…and Holmes learns from the Ripper(03 of08)
Open Image Modal
In October 1888, the Times newspaper agitated for bloodhounds to be brought in to attempt to track the scent of the murderer, and the police acquiesced, running trials in Regent’s Park – literally running for Sir Charles Warren, the police commissioner, who agreed to be the "fox" for the hounds to chase. (It is, apparently, not true that one of the dogs bit him.) But a mere 10 days later, the hounds had been returned to their owners – the smells of London were discovered to be too complex for them to follow a single trail. Conan Doyle must have read these reports, for when Holmes wants to use a dog to track a suspect in London, Watson has doubts "when I reflected upon the great traffic which had passed along the London road." Holmes’s dog only succeeds because the suspect steps in creosote before fleeing, something the Ripper was not considerate enough to do. (credit:Getty)
Robert Louis Stevenson gets caught up too(04 of08)
Open Image Modal
Stevenson’s novella Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde was published two years before the murders, and by 1887 had already been turned into a popular stage play. Once the murders began, the idea of a respectable man who turned into a murdering beast seemed too close to home, and the play closed. Even so, its star, Richard Mansfield, could not escape the taint of a connection. An anonymous letter to Scotland Yard pointed out that, while "I should be the Last to think because A man take A dretfull Part he is therefore Bad," the actor was nevertheless "the Man Wanted:" no one else was "So well able to disguise Himself in A moment…So well able to Baffel the Police," making himself "Short…or Tall in A five Seconds if he carried a fine Faulse Wiskers in A Bag." (credit:Getty)
Entertainment for all(05 of08)
Open Image Modal
While the murders were still occurring, entertainment venues joined the newspapers in exploiting the crimes. Jack the Ripper waxwork shows were popular. Mme Tussaud’s, the most respectable of the waxworks, didn’t show the murderer, since it had made a point of always modeling from life, but others were not so troubled. One ad, selling heads to waxwork-proprietors, promised that its head of the Ripper was "carefully Modelled from Sketches published in the 'Daily Telegraph,' Furnished by witnesses who had actually seen him." (It was followed by an advertisement which offered for sale "Eighty Serpents, for Charming.") Another waxworks opened in the Whitechapel Road, only yards from the location of the murders. The illustration displayed outside as advertising was "too strong," declared the local magistrates, and had to be removed, but the exhibition itself continued.
Foreign fiction(06 of08)
Open Image Modal
The Ripper is known across the world – Jacques l’eventreur, Jack o Estripador, and Jack el Destripador, not to mention Johann der Ausschlitzer and Giovanni il Squattatore. Novels and plays about him abound, but the (unintentionally) funniest may be an American dime-store novel, Lord Jacquelin Burkney by "Rodissi," the pseudonym of Jacob Ringgold. Burkney is an aristocrat, disinherited by his father for his love of a poor but honest shopgirl. When his father dies, he leaves his work as "the most adroit dissector in all Paris" to return home, where his servants address him with remarkable impartiality as "Your highness" and "Your lordship." To the reader’s astonishment, the poor but honest girl has become a streetwalker, and the crazed aristo murders her amid "peals of demoniacal laughter."
Literature (07 of08)
Open Image Modal
Sixteen months after the final murder, the actor Henry Irving’s business-manager made his first note for a novel on the "ghouls." The manager’s name was Bram Stoker, and the novel was Dracula. The Whitechapel crimes weave throughout his novel: the vampire’s five female victims match the Ripper’s five, one character is a doctor, as the Ripper was said to have been, the characters in the novel create a "vigilante committee," as Whitechapel’s residents did. And a person who is both respectable and evil is paramount, as it also was in the second great work that owed itself, in part, to these crimes: Oscar Wilde’s The Picture of Dorian Gray. The Ripper also makes an appearance in Frank Wedekind’s Lulu plays, one of which was the basis for Pabst’s silent film, Pandora’s Box, and Alban Berg’s opera.
Merchandising (08 of08)
Open Image Modal
Art was only for some. Others were happy to make the most of the situation more prosaically. A suburban jeweler advertised "The Great SURPRISE WATCH:" show your friends your new watch and, as they bend over to look, press a "secret spring" and up jumps a tiny Jack, presumably waving a knife, "to the horror and great astonishment of all beholders." Or families could buy a board game centering around Jack the Ripper, where the winner is the player who can help him escape a dozen policemen and another dozen journalists. Even as the murders were continuing, helping the murderer escape was fun for all the family.

This error is alleged to have led him to mistakenly assume the DNA sequence he identified was more rare than it really was.

The newspaper cites experts in the field, adding: “If true, it would mean his calculations were wrong and that virtually anyone could have left the DNA that he insisted came from the Ripper’s victim.”

Edwards, whose book on his findings which was serialised in the Mail on Sunday last month, wrote: “I was overwhelmed. Seven years after I bought the shawl, we had nailed Aaron Kosminski.

"Kosminski was not a member of the Royal Family, or an eminent surgeon or politician. Serial killers rarely are."

Open Image Modal

A fanciful engraving showing 'Jack The Ripper' being caught red-handed

"Instead, he was a pathetic creature, a lunatic who achieved sexual satisfaction from slashing women to death in the most brutal manner. He died in Leavesden Asylum from gangrene at the age of 53, weighing just 7 stone.”

A spokesman for publishers Sidgwick & Jackson said they were investigating the reports but that “the author stands by his conclusions.”

The mystery surrounding the identity of the killer has seen suspects range from the painter Walter Sickert, to Alice in Wonderland author Lewis Carroll, to the wife of an eminent Victorian surgeon.

WARNING: The gallery below contains some graphic content

(01 of13)
Open Image Modal
The murder of Catherine Eddowes by Jack the Ripper. A sketch by Dr F Gordon Brown made on the spot to show the postition of the body and significant details. (credit:PA)
(02 of13)
Open Image Modal
The hand written note in the back of the book by Donald Swanson naming Life to the Crime Museum at New Scotland Yard.Picture Date: Thursday 13 July 2006. After Jack the Ripper's suspected true identity has revealed, more than 100 years after his gruesome series of murders. Chief Inspector Donald Swanson never caught the killer, who stalked Whitechapel, east London, in 1888. The Ripper claimed the lives of at least five women, all prostitutes, during his reign of terror. (credit:PA)
(03 of13)
Open Image Modal
Jack the Ripper An 1880 map of the East End of London where the murders occured. (credit:PA)
(04 of13)
Open Image Modal
Dutfield's Yard, off Berner Street (since renamed Henriques Street) in Whitechapel, the scene of the rippers third murder, that of Swedish-born prostitute Elizabeth "Long Liz" Stride. (credit:PA)
(05 of13)
Open Image Modal
Jack the Ripper A knife found at the scene of one of the murders. (credit:PA)
(06 of13)
Open Image Modal
13 Miller's Court, off Dorset Street, London Spitalfields, the site of the last and most terrible of Jack theRipper's murders, that of Mary Jane Kelly (credit:PA)
(07 of13)
Open Image Modal
The unrecognisable remains of the Ripper's last victim, Mary Jane Kelly. (credit:PA)
(08 of13)
Open Image Modal
Jack the Ripper Victim (Elizabeth Stride) From a sketch taken at the mortuary by Mr F W Foster 3:45 AM Sunday 30th September 1888 (credit:PA)
(09 of13)
Open Image Modal
ack the Ripper A Metropoliotan Police sign in an attempt for information including a letter and postcard supposedly written by the murderer. 3rd October 1888 (credit:PA)
(10 of13)
Open Image Modal
Mary Ann Nicholls, murdered in Bucks Row on 31st August 1888, seen in this mortuary photograph. (credit:PA)
(11 of13)
Open Image Modal
The back yard of the house at 29 Hanbury Street where the mutilated body of Annie Chapman was found on the morning of 8th September 1888. (credit:PA)
(12 of13)
Open Image Modal
A letter with the signature of an individual calling themselves 'Jack the Ripper' is seen during a press preview for the exhibition "Jack the Ripper and the East End" at the Museum in Docklands, London, Wednesday, May 14, 2008. (credit:AP)
(13 of13)
Open Image Modal
A person holds a knife allegedly used by Jack the Ripper during his East End London murders, which forms part of the Jack the Ripper exhibition in the Museum in Docklands opening tomorrow.Picture date: Wednesday May 14, 2008. (credit:PA)