Mission Accomplished? Iraq And US Security, 10 Years After George Bush Infamous Military Banner In 2003

Mission Accomplished?
|

Emblazoned in bold letters across red, white and blue, high a-top the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln, a now infamous banner declared 'Mission Accomplished' as President George W Bush proudly asserted that American operations had ended in Iraq, on May 1, 2003.

Ten years after the highly controversial banner flew off the San Diego coast, bombs are still exploding in cafes, bus stops, mosques and residential neighbourhoods across Iraq. This week alone, 200 people have died in the sectarian strife engulfing the nation since the fall of Sadaam Hussein.

In a report published by War Child, called "Mission Unaccomplished", Iraq has gone from being among the most ‘hospitable places’ for children in the Middle East and North Africa, to being one of the most hostile: with 100 infants dying every day, equivalent to 35,000 infants dying before they reach their 5th birthday.

Open Image Modal

President George W Bush speaks aboard the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln

US Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld later said he had taken care to remove any use of the phrase "Mission Accomplished" in Bush's speech itself. He told journalist Bob Woodward in 2006: "I was in Baghdad, and I was given a draft of that thing to look at. And I just died, and I said my God, it's too conclusive. And I fixed it and sent it back... they fixed the speech, but not the sign."

Professor Anatol Lieven, from Kings College London, said he now feels "nausea" looking at images of the decade-old banner, which hung as Bush announced the end to major combat operations in Iraq.

"Iraq remains a deeply troubled and divided society, at continuous risk of falling into civil war, which has appalling consequences for the whole region," he told HuffPost UK.

David Reeths, director of consulting at IHS Jane's, said that the banner had actually been an attempt to convey a specific military term, "major combat operations", had finished in Iraq. "The failure was giving the impression that the entire mission had ended, that the US could walk away from extensive involvement in Iraq, which was absolutely untrue. It was far from over.

"What was to come would cost a lot more in blood and treasure than the Bush administration had ever conceived at that point."

Open Image Modal

The speech was given at the end of 'major combat operations' in Iraq, 10 years ago

As well as ongoing violence and political struggles in post-war Iraq, the US even damaged its own military reputation, according to Professor Lieven. "Iran no longer has any reason to fear a US invasion. No-one believes now that the US and Nato can invade and occupy anything, or at least, nothing bigger than a tiny country like Kosovo. That has done appalling damage."

Professor Lieven, the author of Pakistan: A Hard Country, said the Iraq war had had a deep psychological impact on Muslims all over the world. "It is impossible to quantify, but in the 18 months or so since 9/11, I found most Muslims in Pakistan, which I know best, generally accepted Al Qaeda had carried out the attack and had been based in Afghanistan, and that the invasion had some justification.

"Since the invasion of Iraq, I would say with no exaggeration, among Muslim Pakistanis, even in Britain, even among the most educated, around 99% of the population is now convinced that 9/11 is a CIA-Israeli plot. And when you try point out that is poisonous idiocy, they point out Bush lied about weapons in Iraq. And after that, you've already lost the 10 second rule of argument, as you try and explain the different logics."

Open Image Modal

Donald Rumsfeld said he had taken care to remove the phrase 'Mission Accomplished' in Bush's speech

Lisa Aronsson, a research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute, said she believes there was certainly "progress made on counter terrorism" since Iraq. "But the security landscape has been completely transformed, after Iraq and post-Arab Spring, since 2003."

"America is facing a much more difficult security environment now, exacerbated by the failure to understand the resources it needed to get any semblance of success in Iraq," Reeths said.

"The world is a much more complex place, threats in Syria, instability in North Africa, reduced but significant threats from jihadists, but also territorial disputes in East Asia, the growth of China in terms of soft and military power, the nuclear growth of Iran, the potential for a nuclear arms race in the Middle East, and a potential nuclear North Korea."

One legacy of the infamous banner has been a shift in the bombastic rhetoric which rang forth from the Bush administration.

"The US has made a direct shift in tone, one of the reasons Obama won the Nobel Peace Prize," Reeths said. "The US has to now strike a balance to not be too militaristic but also pose an effective deterrent. Obama has shifted away from the Bush's administration's 'stick' to giving out carrots, as well as carrying a stick."

Sectarian Violence Grows In Iraq
(01 of14)
Open Image Modal
An Iraqi Arab member of the Kirkuk provincial council shoots in the air upon the delivery of the bodies of victims killed in yesterday's bombings in Hawijah north of Baghdad before their burial on April 24, 2013 in the multi-ethnic Iraqi city, bordering the autonomous Kurdistan region. (MARWAN IBRAHIM/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
(02 of14)
Open Image Modal
The body of Maad Hammad is taken for burial in Kirkuk, 180 miles (290 kilometers) north of Baghdad, Iraq, Wednesday, April 24, 2013. Hammad was killed when Iraqi security forces backed by helicopters raided a Sunni protest camp before dawn Tuesday, April 23, 2013, prompting clashes that killed scores of people in the area and significantly intensified Sunni anger against the Shiite-led government. (AP Photo/ Emad Matti) (credit:AP)
(03 of14)
Open Image Modal
The body of one of the victims killed in yesterday's bombings in Hawijah north of Baghdad is transported in the back of a truck to be handed over to his family for burial in the northern Iraqi city of Kirkuk on April 24, 2013. (MARWAN IBRAHIM/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
(04 of14)
Open Image Modal
Angry family members react as they receive the bodies of victims killed in yesterday's bombings in Hawijah north of Baghdad in the northern Iraqi city of Kirkuk before their burial on April 24, 2013. (MARWAN IBRAHIM/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
(05 of14)
Open Image Modal
Relatives identify the bodies of victims killed in yesterday's bombings in Hawijah north of Baghdad upon their arrival in the northern Iraqi city of Kirkuk for burial on April 24, 2013. (MARWAN IBRAHIM/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
(06 of14)
Open Image Modal
An Iraqi Army helicopter hovers over Hawija, 150 miles (240 kilometers) north of Baghdad, Iraq, Tuesday, April 23, 2013. (AP Photo/Hadi Mizban) (credit:AP)
(07 of14)
Open Image Modal
The body of a gunman killed during clashes with Iraqi security forces lies on the ground in Hawija, 150 miles (240 kilometers) north of Baghdad, Iraq, Tuesday, April 23, 2013. (AP Photo) (credit:AP)
(08 of14)
Open Image Modal
AK-47s seized by Iraqi security forces are seen in Hawija, 150 miles (240 kilometers) north of Baghdad, Iraq, Tuesday, April 23, 2013. (AP Photo) (credit:AP)
(09 of14)
Open Image Modal
Iraqi army soldiers drive out of Hawija, 150 miles (240 kilometers) north of Baghdad, Iraq, Tuesday, April 23, 2013. (AP Photo/Hadi Mizban) (credit:AP)
(10 of14)
Open Image Modal
Iraqi army vehicles drive out of Hawija, 150 miles (240 kilometers) north of Baghdad, Iraq, Tuesday, April 23, 2013. (AP Photo/Hadi Mizban) (credit:AP)
(11 of14)
Open Image Modal
An Iraqi army military vehicle burns near a demonstration site in Ramadi, Iraq, 70 miles (115 kilometers) west of Baghdad, Iraq, Tuesday, April 23, 2013. Protesters threw stones on a military convoy that was passing near the protest site in Ramadi, one army Humvee was flipped over and the soldiers opened fire on the fire, then they left, the protesters set fire on the abandoned army vehicle. (AP Photo) (credit:AP)
(12 of14)
Open Image Modal
A burning Iraqi army military vehicle near the demonstration site in Ramadi, Iraq, 70 miles (115 kilometers) west of Baghdad, Iraq, Tuesday, April 23, 2013. (AP Photo) (credit:AP)
(13 of14)
Open Image Modal
This citizen journalist image provided by the Rebels Gathering of Hawija on the group's Facebook page shows people inspecting protesters' dead bodies at a hospital in Hawija, 150 miles (240 kilometers) north of Baghdad, Iraq. (AP Photo/Rebels Gathering of Hawija) (credit:AP)
(14 of14)
Open Image Modal
Iraqi soldiers surround an ambulance as it arrives at a hospital following clashes between security forces and anti-government protesters, allegedly infiltrated by militants, on April 23, 2013 in the northern city of Kirkuk. (MARWAN IBRAHIM/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)