NHS 'Deterring' Pregnant Immigrants From Seeking Care

NHS 'Deterring Pregnant Immigrants From Seeking Care'
|

Pregnant immigrants are missing out on pre-birth care because pressure is growing on the NHS to enforce immigration rules rather than provide care, a charity has claimed.

Doctors of the World UK said undocumented migrants and asylum seekers were being turned away from GP practices or received "huge bills", even after losing their babies, as the NHS was "asked to play the role of the UK Border Agency".

The charity said a crackdown on so-called "health tourists" - foreign nationals travelling into the UK to use the NHS - led to confusion, even though the pre-natal treatment was necessary and could avoid complications with a birth.

Dr Clare Shortall, report author, doctor and volunteer family clinic lead for Doctors of the World, said many of the women had been in the UK for four years and "do not fit the dubious categorisation of 'health tourist".

She said: "In no compassionate society would a health system bill a grieving woman for the loss of their child. Health trusts are increasingly being asked to play the role of the UK Border Agency and focus on checking documents rather than delivering care. This has to stop.

"Pregnant migrant women are also regularly sent letters from NHS trusts that have a very strong deterrent effect. Rather than mentioning their right to care, they ask for proof of entitlement, often directly mentioning the UK Border Agency. These sort of scare tactics need to stop.

"Both because the bills they face and the deterrent letters they receive, extremely vulnerable pregnant women are not getting the care they need, sometimes with tragic results."

The report, which surveyed the views of 35 women at a London drop-in clinic run by the charity, found two-thirds had not received antenatal care until at least three months into pregnancy, while more than half went without care for more than 20 weeks.

And two had received bills for four-figure sums even though they had lost their babies.

The women surveyed included victims of human trafficking, according to Phil Murwill, who runs Doctors of the World's clinic where the study was conducted.

He said: "By law antenatal care should always be provided, but we regularly see women who've been denied access to primary care, putting both mother and child at risk.

"We've seen extremely vulnerable women who've been trafficked into the country who've accessed antenatal care, but who've then received threatening letters from hospitals demanding repayment for thousands of pounds that they simply don't have."

Story continues beneath slideshow

Immigration In Britain Exhibition
George(01 of10)
Open Image Modal
I’m from Romania, Bucharest and have been in this country for four years. I like this country. There’s no racism.

My country, too much racism: ‘You gipsy!’ Racism bad in Bucharest, lots of fighting, people killed. Here I work, it’s very good. No work, no good. It’s nice, you pay your house, you pay the electric, the cars, the water; it’s very nice.

The Romanian government is racist - is big mafia. All the money put in the pocket, no pay the children, no pay the house, no pay nothing; it’s big mafia.

England is nice. I no like another country. No Germany, no Francais. Here not any problem; it’s very good people. And the government is very good government here, very clever. The government help every people; Pakistani, Indian, Romanian, Polish, English, very good.

This is my country. This is my children’s country, they speak very nice English, speak very good. I no speak very good English; I speak little bit.

I work scrap metal. I have own van. I have license for van. I clean rubbish from streets and pay tax. Well for me, it’s good - for my family it’s very good. Not too much money, but I can pay all.

I have four children. I hope maybe they work in hospital, another one for government. I have big plans. Every day I working for my children. I’m going for school. I pay food, I pay all they are doing; university - everything.

I explain to them, this no good, no going for street, no drink. You understand?
Dan Dan (02 of10)
Open Image Modal
Communities don’t mix; they just stick together. It’s like they walk to one side. It’s all the Asians together, then it’s all Polish. It is just how people are.

There’s not one big society. People don’t mix how they should. When they’re young, they mix, but the elders, they don’t really mix, they like to keep themselves to themselves and their own kind. I like to mix. But it won’t change like that.

Us younger people, I think we’ll stick to how we are now and it will change like that. Everyone will start mixing a lot more.
Ali Zayed(03 of10)
Open Image Modal
Imagine yourself. You live in a camp in your own country for eight years and get fed by international organisations like Save the Children or Oxfam.

Ten years ago you had your own house; you had your own farm. You had a couple of cows, camels or goats, living a normal African villager’s life.

Today, there are no villages. They’ve been burned, bombed, people have been displaced, fleeing to neighbouring countries, fleeing to massive internal camps, relying on aid from outside, this is the kind of life they live in now in Darfur.

At the end of the day, if all this settled down, I would prefer to live in Sudan rather than be in England, because life here, I know it’s peaceful, I know it’s safe and I know everything is available - modern life, modern technology - but it’s not enough for me this, is not what I’m seeking.

I’m not seeking technology and this kind of life; I’m seeking to be in my big family and to be myself.

The children who were born here, in this country or any other European country, will never go back to stay or to live in their original countries where they come from, because that is just hell to them.

When they go back there, they don’t like it. I wouldn’t take my children to Sudan in this kind of situation now, never, ever, because within two weeks, they will hear and they will see atrocities and I don’t want them to see that; I don’t want my children to see what’s going on in Sudan.
Kafilat Mohammed(04 of10)
Open Image Modal
I am from Abidjan [Ivory Coast], West Africa. I came over here to England for salvation. There is a lot of problem back in Abidjan as there was a war, named the Second Ivorian Civil War, which started in 2002.

They would kill anyone. I didn’t really want to leave, but because of the problems I had no choice.

I lost my parents from this war. I lost my dad, then my brother and my sister.

It was Christian against Muslims. If they find out that you are a Muslim, they will kill you, or someone find out you are a Christian, they’ll kill you; that is why I came here. It was all to do with the president in power and his reluctance to step down - his people began killing civilians.

The Christians killed my family. A lot of people died, including my friends; they all died in that war and I was 21 when this happened.

That was 10 years ago.
Marco Kashemish (back right)(05 of10)
Open Image Modal
I came for work as in my country it is hard to get a job. I’m from Poland.

There’s a lot of Polish people don’t like gypsies, because I’m half dark skinned and they don’t like that.

The old Polish and gypsy Polish kids go to school together and have problem because of the dark skin. All the Polish children shout ‘Oh, you gypsy, you’re dirty.’

And this was the reason why I left. Because I’m gipsy, a lot of people don’t give me the work... It is why I didn’t finish school as well, because I’m gypsy, people fighting with me, saying I’m black, I’m dirty, it was hard. And this problem has been going on for such a long time.

I remember my grandfather telling me, saying the same thing, he had the same problem: black skin, you are dirty; just all the time and this problem is coming stronger, I think it has something to do with hard times, the recession and no opportunities.

Now I have a wife and three children and the future for my kids is better than Poland. We want them to have an education and when they get older its their choice what they want to do for work. I want them to do what they want, they are living in UK; so they will be like English people.

I only just want them to know they are gypsy, because his family is, all family is gipsy. I just will tell to them, ‘Yes, continue with this: but you are gypsy. Your father is gypsy, your grandfather gypsy,’ all like that.

They can’t just live it like UK people.
Emmanuel Changamaire(06 of10)
Open Image Modal
I’m from Malawi and got here when I was 18 years. It’s the good life here; you have everything at your disposal without suffering, without having to seek more to have the very basics. It’s just hard back home, you need to have good monies, you need to be well educated, you need to come from a good family, to lead a good life and that’s not for everyone.

You always see it on TV as the best country in the world, England, so we had to come. And it has really has lived up to my expectations. This is the best place anyone could be. When they say sky is the limit, they talk about this place, for real and you are your own limit; you can go as far as you want, but not back home.

I work in a mail shop: mail sorting and bagging. I do not have any further ambitions in my life, I’m done; I just want to make money.

If someone was to ask where my home is, it is still more back home; that’s my home, man. That’s where I was raised, that’s where I stayed for 18 years of my life. I’ve only been here for like what, eight or nine years.

When I stay here for 18 years ago, it’s balanced; 19 years, then I’ll call this home, you know? Yeah, you know, I’ll call this place home.
Diane(07 of10)
Open Image Modal
I came back five years ago after being away for 40 years. I never thought such a change would ever happen. It was a big shock to walk actually on Radford Road and not hear anybody who spoke English – even walking through to ASDA, nobody was talking English and I wondered what was happening.

Because before, it was mainly Caribbean on Radford Road, you know, and now you’ve got Polish, Turks and a lot of Romanians now.

Some people have moaned that they’ve brought the area down, but they do try and make their own living, because they’ve got a lot of scrap vans. But the change doesn’t bother me. I’ll stay here now because my son bought the house where I live. I still love the area, for all the shops and all the different cultures.

But my experience, every shopkeeper knows you, everybody’s so friendly in all the shops. Sometimes, you get a better service than actually from British shopkeepers. It’s a one-to-one service and you’re made to feel welcome and you’re treated with respect.
Kelo (Kelmyne)(08 of10)
Open Image Modal
I was born in [South Africa] a place where white people did not mix with black people. You go to the park, you had two chairs written ‘black people’ or ‘white people’. It wasn’t racist, that was the life.

I’ve seen children getting killed, white and black people getting burned alive in the streets and police doing nothing. I was in my 20s when I decided to move to United Kingdom. I came here looking for a job but it was difficult.

Don’t ever think that migrating to another country can change your life. It can’t. If you have the chance to change your life wherever you are, just change it.
Muklis Azis(09 of10)
Open Image Modal
I came from Kurdistan, north Iraq. Saddam didn’t like Kurdish people; he just want to like destroy us.

He killed a lot of people and did not allow us to speak in our own language, Kurdish; you have to speak Arabic.

And he liked to say you don’t have army, you don’t have flag, you have nothing; you’re just existing here.

My dad and my granddad, they stayed in the mountains called Pashmerga. Fighting since 1991 they finally kicked out Saddam, back to the Arabic side, but in 2003 when America and the UK came in, he’s gone. Now we have all our rights, we’re happy and everyone is happy.

My business is going well. I’ve got a partner to help and when I came here my family sent me money to help start this shop, so I had their support and I worked very hard to get to where I am today.

I have married here to my Pakistani wife. I have a baby. I’m happy. We do go back sometimes, and my wife has been with me. If I had no choice but to go home I’d go but I don’t what to, I have both passports, Kurdish and British and I could not make that choice.

I enjoy both sides of my life, I’m happy for both sides. I can go back when I want but my life is here, my family is here.
Mahamud, Hassan and Norman(10 of10)
Open Image Modal
We are proud of our diverse up-bringing. We have all come from Somalia, two of us are from Mogadishu and one from Djibouti.

Living in Hyson Green and Forest Field is good, it’s a diverse area, we have friends who are Polish, Romanian, Pakistani and Caribbean.

Commenting on the report, Cathy Warwick, chief executive of the Royal College of Midwives, said: "We have real concerns that the aggressive pursuit of charging migrant women for medical care may deter them from accessing maternity care.

"I fear that these women could fall through the cracks and only find their way into the health system when it is too late - if at all.

"Women from these groups are often already in poorer health, have poor pregnancy outcomes and these steps could have negative consequences for their health.

"Our view is very clear: Midwives should not act as gatekeepers to the maternity services. They owe a duty of care to all pregnant women who seek care from them and, they should provide care to all pregnant women irrespective of the woman's ability to pay.

"We urge service providers to exercise compassion and sensitivity when dealing with migrant women, especially when they have suffered the tragic loss of their baby."

A Department of Health spokesperson said: "International visitors are welcome to use the NHS, provided they pay for it - just as UK families do through taxes.

"With the NHS busier than ever, our plans to recoup these costs better will help keep services sustainable.

"As a key part of our existing plans, GPs must give appointments to vulnerable patients and women will never be refused hospital maternity care if they haven't paid in advance."