South Africa's Untold Success Story: A Christian Nation's Peaceful History With A Muslim Minority

Religion, the one thing that has divided the rest of the world so starkly, has not done so here. This has perhaps been one of the most remarkable stories of post-apartheid South Africa.
|
Open Image Modal
People sing as political activists and religious leaders attend an interfaith memorial gathering for anti-Apartheid stalwart Ahmed Kathrada on March 28, 2017 at the City Hall in Durban.
RAJESH JANTILAL via Getty Images

Growing up in early 90s South Africa I was not exposed to many different races, in that stifling, artificially divided environment apartheid left us with. But I was immersed in a rich religious melange that formed my understanding of community. My neighbours on my right were Hindu, on my left were Christians and opposite me were Muslims. I heard stories about Ram's love for Sita from Mrs Moodley, about Christmas from the Davids next door and about the Prophet (PBUH) at madressah. There were at least five temples, mosques and churches in my area alone (often right next to each other) and our parks were littered with white rocks that mark Shembe outdoor prayer sites. In town, outside the bustling African traditional healer's market was the Catholic Emmanuel Cathedral and right next door was the largest mosque in Durban, the Juma Musjid Mosque dating back to 1880.

While we may have been segregated by race, there were no clear rules about religion and it is perhaps one of the reasons that faith bound us to one another so strongly. Religion was not only a source of strength and comfort during apartheid, it was also a means of resistance against a system designed to divide. And yet religion, the one thing that has divided the rest of the world so starkly, has not done so here. This has perhaps been one of the most remarkable stories of post-apartheid South Africa, but the least told.

Despite being a secular state, South Africa is a deeply religious country – it has more than 60 religious affiliations and in 2016, the General Household Survey by StatsSA revealed that more than 90% of South Africans associate themselves with a religion while 36.6 % of Hindus, 52.5% of Christians and 75.6% of Muslims attend religious ceremonies at least once a week. While the number of South Africans who consider themselves religious may be lowering we still have a uniquely united approach to religion in a world that is steadily growing divided over it.

This community of Muslims have lived in harmony with the Christian majority in South Africa for years.

Thuli Madonsela, the former public protector who helped draw up the the South African Constitution, explained in an interview last year that respect for the right to choose one's faith and the state's respect for all faiths is how a secular democracy and a religious population work together so well in South Africa.

This is especially pertinent today in a world where Islam and its communities have come under scrutiny with non-Muslim majority countries calling for stricter control measures like the surveillance of Muslims, preventing mosque construction and supporting the introduction of Muslim identification documents. South Africa's Muslim population represent only one and a half percent of the population but it has a strong presence in the country due to an active and involved community. This community of Muslims have lived in harmony with the Christian majority in South Africa for years. It is perhaps one of only a handful of countries where this has succeeded.

One of the reasons for this is the way Islam was introduced to South Africa. Islam first arrived on our shores though slavery, which began in mid 1600s to the mid 1800s when the Dutch sent slaves and political prisoners to the Cape Colony from Indonesia and other Asian countries. The second wave of Muslims arrived from India as indentured labourers to work in sugar cane farms for the British in the late 1800s. This history of slavery is part of the reason why Muslims are so organically a part of South Africa, says Gabeba Baderoon, an academic and author of Regarding Muslims, a book that traces the role of Muslims in South Africa. "South Africa was built not only on colonial occupation and land theft but on slavery and indentured labour. Islam is intricately connected to these deep beginnings because many enslaved and indentured people were Muslims and the long history of struggle during colonialism is part of the reason that Islam is an ordinary, organic and indigenised part of our present," Baderoon tells the Huffington Post South Africa.

Khadija Patel, a Muslim journalist and editor of the Mail & Guardian, echoes similar sentiments. "Islam in not homogenous, it is many things and it has grown through an organic process that speaks to the long and difficult history of this country."

Some within the Muslim community have been labelled racist, sexist, apathetic and unwilling to integrate into a South African community.

Despite their small numbers, Muslim South Africans are visible in many fields, including our politics. In 1998 former South African president Nelson Mandela reflected that: "Our country can proudly claim Muslims as brothers and sisters, compatriots, freedom fighters and leaders, revered by our nation. They have written their names on the roll of honour with blood, sweat and tears." Some Muslims, most notably Yusuf Dadoo, Ahmed Timol, Ismail Cachalia and Fathima Meer, fought in the struggle against apartheid.

But the Muslim community in South Africa has not been without its criticisms. Safiyyah Surtee, a Postgraduate researcher as the University of Johannesburg's Religion Studies, says that Muslims do have a unique situation here but she believes that a lot more can be done on an interfaith level. "Muslims need to contribute more to interfaith, respect and harmony. I often find myself the only Muslim at interfaith events."

Some within the Muslim community have been labelled racist, sexist, apathetic and unwilling to integrate into a South African community. There is a danger that they consider themselves separate from the people and government.

And mostly alarmingly, there is one aspect of the issues facing global Islam that has crept into an otherwise largely peaceful Muslim existence in South Africa: an undeniable strand of extremism. This may pose the biggest danger to the social cohesion South Africa enjoys with its Muslim population. While most were largely moderate Muslims, and a significant number well-integrated into society, some South African Muslims have actually joined terror groups. In 2015 a fifteen-year-old Cape Town girl was taken off a flight en route to join ISIS.

Kathrada's memorial in Cape Town was proudly hosted by the historically important St George's Cathedral.

But then there are moments like anti-apartheid activist Ahmed Kathrada's state funeral which demonstrate the power of South Africa's real religious tolerance. His memorial in Cape Town was proudly hosted by the historically important St George's Cathedral, and religious leaders in attendance at the Muslim funeral included the Anglican Archbishop. This prompted former University of the Free State vice chancellor, Jonathan Jansen, to write a viral post about religious cohesion in South Africa "where Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu and other faiths come together in a broad swathe of South African humanity to remember a man who fought for all of us. Where on and off the stage no one racial or ethnic or religious group dominated the event".

An active and committed community with a history in the country may be the reason why Islamophobia has had little impact in the country. Whilst there has been some protests to construction of mosques in Valhalla and most recently Atholl, these incidents are often related to the history of the area as previously white-only areas, and objections mainly came from white residents. This year the Western Cape experienced vandalism of two mosques in January; the mosques were desecrated after a public call on Facebook to burn Islamic places of worship. However there was an immediate outcry and the Christian community showed support with the local Bishop attending interfaith meetings at the mosque and publicly denouncing the acts.

Despite these incidents South African Muslims have experienced little of the current levels of fear and intimidation of global Muslim minorities and this may have something to do with the fact that Muslims have been allowed to develop their communities and thus feel settled enough to become active and contributing members of society. In 2014 The Pew Research Centre conducted a study on the perceptions of Americans towards members of different religious groups. The study revealed that whereas Jews, Catholics and Evangelical Christians were all viewed warmly, Muslims were viewed coldly. However several trends emerge from this research, an important one being that the more likely a person is to know a Muslim, the more likely he or she is to express positive feelings towards Muslims as a group.

Religious tolerance is still one of South Africa's strongest traits – and a story we don't tell often enough.

South Africans rely on their immediate community and not on the media to formulate an understanding of Muslims and this has led to a far nuanced understanding of a currently misunderstood religion.

South African Muslims have a long and peaceful history in the country and while Islamophobia and extremism has been on the rise globally, and cannot help but affect us here, religious tolerance is still one of South Africa's strongest traits – and a story we don't tell often enough. It is a shared history of struggle, a Constitution that protects religious diversity and a remarkable tolerance for difference from many South Africans.

The Huffington Post South Africa is delving into what faith and spirituality means to South Africans here and now. Against the backdrop of a renewed wave of thought around decolonisation, a new generation is rediscovering its traditional beliefs, while some are reconciling with Christianity. On another note, we tell South Africa's real good news story: our remarkable and peaceful religious diversity. In a world fractured along religious extremism, we have a large Christian population with significant Muslim and Jewish communities, who often come together peacefully and with purpose, as has been evinced at the memorials for departed struggle stalwart, Ahmed Kathrada. Read the rest of the special report here, or choose from our selection below:

27 Quotes By Desmond Tutu On Faith, Justice And Love
(01 of27)
Open Image Modal

"God has such a deep reverence for our freedom that he'd rather let us freely go to Hell than be compelled to go to Heaven."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu ponders a point during an interview at his office in Cape Town, South Africa, April 25, 2006.

(credit:Mike Hutchings / Reuters)
(02 of27)
Open Image Modal

"I don't preach a social gospel; I preach the Gospel, period. The gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ is concerned for the whole person. When people were hungry, Jesus didn't say, "Now is that political or social?" He said, "I feed you." Because the good news to a hungry person is bread."

The former Anglican archbishop of Cape Town Desmond Tutu waits to receive the 2013 Templeton Prize at the Guildhall in central London on May 21, 2013.

(credit:Paul Hackett / Reuters)
(03 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Forgiveness is an absolute necessity for continued human existence."

Chairman of the TRC Archbishop Desmond Tutu wipes his face during a special public hearing of South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission in Johannesburg November 24. Winnie Mandela was accused of the murder of Stompie Seipei, a 14 year-old activist who died in 1989.

(credit:Peter Andrews / Reuters)
(04 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Some of my friends are skeptical when they hear me say this, but I am by nature a person who dislikes confrontation. I have consciously sought during my lifetime to emulate my mother, whom our family knew as a gentle “comforter of the afflicted.” However, when I see innocent people suffering, pushed around by the rich and the powerful, then, as the prophet Jeremiah, says, if I try to keep quiet is is as if the word of God burned like a fire in my breast. I feel compelled to speak out, sometimes to even argue with God over how a loving creator can allow this to happen."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu speaks to Winnie Madikizela-Mandela during a special public hearing of South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission in Johannesburg November 25. Winnie Mandela was accused of the murder of Stompie Seipei, a 14 year old activist who died in 1989.

(credit:Peter Andrews / Reuters)
(05 of27)
Open Image Modal

"I've never doubted that apartheid - because it was of itself fundamentally, intrinsically evil - was going to bite the dust eventually."

Chairman of the TRC (Truth and Reconciliation Commission) Archbishop Desmond Tutu (R) hands over the TRC report to South Africa's President Nelson Mandela at the State theater Building in Pretoria October 29. South Africa's Truth Commission has found that the ruling African National Congress (ANC) is politically and morally accountable for gross human rights violations committed during its 30-year struggle against apartheid.

(credit:Peter Andrews / Reuters)
(06 of27)
Open Image Modal

"You and I are created for transcendence, laughter, caring. God deliberately did not make the world perfect, for God is looking for you and me to be fellow workers with God."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu and former President Nelson Mandela respond to questions at a meeting to commemorate World Aids Day in KTC township near Cape Town, December 1, 2001. Tutu told the gathering of youths that the best way to tackle the disease was to abstain from sex, but if that were not possible to practise safe sex. REUTERS/Mike Hutchings MH

(credit:Reuters Photographer / Reuters)
(07 of27)
Open Image Modal

"It is for real that injustice and oppression will not have the last word. There was a time when Hitler looked like he was going to vanquish all of Europe, and where is he now?"

Archbishop Desmond Tutu shares a laugh with Zulu Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi (L) and Zuil King Goodwill Zwelithini (R) at the Inaugural ceremony of the South African President May 10

(credit:Philippe Wojazer / Reuters)
(08 of27)
Open Image Modal

"You don’t choose your family. They are God’s gift to you, as you are to them."

The former Anglican archbishop of Cape Town Desmond Tutu dances with his grandson Khalil Morrison, 6, grand daughter Onalina Burris, 7, and daughter Reverend Mpho Tutu (R) after he received the 2013 Templeton Prize at the Guildhall in central London on May 21, 2013. South African anti-apartheid campaigner Desmond Tutu won the 2013 Templeton Prize worth $1.7 million for helping inspire people around the world by promoting forgiveness and justice, organisers said. REUTERS/Paul Hackett (BRITAIN - Tags: RELIGION POLITICS)

(credit:Paul Hackett / Reuters)
(09 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Sometimes you want to whisper in God's ear, "God, we know you are in charge, but why don't you make it slightly more obvious?"

U.S. President Barack Obama (L) listens to Desmond Tutu as he visits his HIV Foundation Youth Centre and takes part in a health event with youth in Cape Town, June 30, 2013.

(credit:Jason Reed / Reuters)
(10 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Injustice and oppression will never prevail. Those who are powerful have to remember the litmus test that God gives to the powerful: what is your treatment of the poor, the hungry, the voiceless? And on the basis of that, God passes judgment."

U.S. President Barack Obama (L) hugs Archbishop Desmond Tutu as he visits his HIV Foundation Youth Centre and takes part in a health event with youth in Cape Town, June 30, 2013.

(credit:Jason Reed / Reuters)
(11 of27)
Open Image Modal

"What has happened to us? It seems as if we have perverted our freedom, our rights into license, into being irresponsible. Perhaps we did not realise just how apartheid has damaged us so that we seem to have lost our sense of right and wrong."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu and his wife Leah share a moment shortly before renewing their vows as they celebrate their 60th wedding anniversary in Cape Town, South Africa, July 2, 2015. REUTERS/Mark Wessels

(credit:Mark Wessells / Reuters)
(12 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Resentment and anger are bad for your blood pressure and your digestion."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu addresses media during his meeting with Britain's Prince Harry in Cape Town, South Africa November 30, 2015. Prince Harry is in South Africa on behalf of Sentebale, the charity he founded with Lesotho's Prince Seeiso in memory of their mothers. REUTERS/Schalk van Zuydam/Pool

(credit:POOL New / Reuters)
(13 of27)
Open Image Modal

"We used to say to the apartheid government: you may have the guns, you may have all this power, but you have already lost. Come: join the winning side."

Britain's Prince Harry talks to Archbishop Desmond Tutu during their meeting in Cape Town, South Africa November 30, 2015. Prince Harry is in South Africa on behalf of Sentebale, the charity he founded with Lesotho's Prince Seeiso in memory of their mothers. REUTERS/Schalk van Zuydam/Pool

(credit:POOL New / Reuters)
(14 of27)
Open Image Modal

"He has a childlike, boyish, impish, mischievousness. And I have to try and make him behave properly, like a holy man!"

Exiled Tibetan spiritual leader The Dalai Lama (L) shares a laugh with Archbishop Desmond Tutu as they both take part in a dialogue on youth and spiritual connection as part of a five-day event to teach compassion to children in Seattle, Washington, April 15, 2008.

(credit:Robert Sorbo / Reuters)
(15 of27)
Open Image Modal

"I give great thanks to God that he has created a Dalai Lama. Do you really think, as some have argued, that God will be saying: "You know, that guy, the Dalai Lama, is not bad. What a pity he's not a Christian"? I don't think that is the case — because, you see, God is not a Christian."

Exiled Tibetan spiritual leader The Dalai Lama (L) listens to Archbishop Desmond Tutu speaks as they both take part in a dialogue on youth and spiritual connection as part of a five-day event to teach compassion to children in Seattle, Washington, April 15, 2008.

(credit:Robert Sorbo / Reuters)
(16 of27)
Open Image Modal

"If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor. If an elephant has its foot on the tail of a mouse and you say that you are neutral, the mouse will not appreciate your neutrality."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu (L) and Bono, the lead singer of the Irish rock band U2, share a light hearted moment during Tutu's 80th birthday celebrations in Cape Town October 7, 2011. South African peace icon Archbishop Tutu celebrated his 80th birthday on Friday in the church where he preached against apartheid, just a few days after saying the former liberation movement now in government was in some ways even worse. R

(credit:POOL New / Reuters)
(17 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Injustice and oppression will never prevail. Those who are powerful have to remember the litmus test that God gives to the powerful: what is your treatment of the poor, the hungry, the voiceless? And on the basis of that, God passes judgment."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu gestures during a news conference in Cape Town after the Dalai Lama cancelled a trip to South Africa October 11 2011. The Dalai Lama, the Tibetan spiritual leader, cancelled a trip to South Africa that had put Pretoria in a bind between its biggest trading partner China and one of its modern heroes, Nobel Peace Prize laureate Desmond Tutu. The Dalai Lama's office said on Tuesday he cancelled the trip intended for him to attend Archbishop Tutu's 80th birthday celebration because South Africa, which has had his application paperwork for weeks, had not issued him a visa on time.

(credit:Sumaya Hisham / Reuters)
(18 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Without us, God has no eyes, without us, God has no ears; without us, God has no arms or hands. God relies on us. Won't you join other people of faith in becoming God's partners in the world?"

South African Archbishop and Nobel Laureate Desmond Tutu speaks during an interview with Reuters in New Delhi February 8, 2012. Picture taken February 8, 2012.

(credit:B Mathur / Reuters)
(19 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Isn’t it noteworthy in the parable of the Good Samaritan that Jesus does not give a straightforward answer to the question "Who is my neighbor?" (Luke 10:29). Surely he could have provided a catalog of those whom the scribe could love as himself as the law required. He does not. Instead, he tells a story. It is as if Jesus wanted among other things to point out that life is a bit more complex; it has too many ambivalences and ambiguities to allow always for a straightforward and simplistic answer."

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Archbishop Desmond Tutu arrive to deliver remarks to a group of visiting Girl Scouts in honor of the first-ever International Day of the Girl at the State Department in Washington October 10, 2012.

(credit:Yuri Gripas / Reuters)
(20 of27)
Open Image Modal

(Continued)

"This is a great mercy, because in times such as our own — times of change when many familiar landmarks have shifted or disappeared — people are bewildered; they hanker after unambiguous, straightforward answers. We appear to be scared of diversity in ethnicities, in religious faiths, in political and ideological points of view. We have an impatience with anything and anyone that suggests there might just be another perspective, another way of looking at the same thing, another answer worth exploring."

Nobel peace prize laureates, Myanmar's pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi (R) and South African social rights activist and retired Anglican bishop Desmond Tutu (L) speak at Suu Kyi's house in Yangon, February 26, 2013.

(credit:Handout . / Reuters)
(21 of27)
Open Image Modal

(Continued)

"There is a nostalgia for the security in the womb of a safe sameness, and so we shut out the stranger and the alien; we look for security in those who can provide answers that must be unassailable because no one is permitted to dissent, to question. There is a longing for the homogeneous and an allergy against the different, the other."

Nobel peace prize laureates, Myanmar's pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi (R) and South African social rights activist and retired Anglican bishop Desmond Tutu (L) embrace at Suu Kyi's house in Yangon, February 26, 2013.

(credit:Handout . / Reuters)
(22 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Now Jesus seems to say to the scribe, 'Hey, life is more exhilarating as you try to work out the implications of your faith rather than living by rote, with ready-made second-hand answers, fitting an unchanging paradigm to a shifting, changing, perplexing, and yet fascinating world.'"

Archbishop Desmond Tutu jokes with Princess Charlene of Monaco during a visit to the Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation youth centre in Masiphelele township near Cape Town July 8, 2011.

(credit:Mike Hutchings / Reuters)
(23 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Our faith, our knowledge that God is in charge, must make us ready to take risks, to be venturesome and innovative; yes, to dare to walk where angels might fear to tread."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu greets United States first lady Michelle Obama during a visit to Cape Town stadium, June 23, 2011.

(credit:Mike Hutchings / Reuters)
(24 of27)
Open Image Modal

"Do your little bit of good where you are; it's those little bits of good put together that overwhelm the world."

Archbishop Desmond Tutu (L) hugs poet Maya Angelou during a ceremony to honor Tutu with the J. William Fulbright Prize for the International Understanding Award in Washington, November 21, 2008.

(credit:Jim Young / Reuters)
(25 of27)
Open Image Modal

"I am a leader by default, only because nature does not allow a vacuum."

South African Nobel Peace Laureates Nelson Mandela (L) and Archbishop Desmond Tutu (2nd L) arrive for the 70th birthday celebrations of fellow laureate former President FW de Klerk (R) in Cape Town, March 17, 2006. De Klerk turns 70 on March 18.

(credit:Mike Hutchings / Reuters)
(26 of27)
Open Image Modal

“Good is stronger than evil; love is stronger than hate; light is stronger than darkness; life is stronger than death. Victory is ours, through him who loves us.”

Oprah Winfrey and Archbishop Desmond Tutu laugh during The Sesame Workshop's Second Annual Benefit Gala, in New York, on June 2, 2004.

(credit:Reuters Photographer / Reuters)
(27 of27)
Open Image Modal

“I will never tell anyone to pick up a gun. But I will pray for the man who picks up a gun, pray that he will be less cruel than he might otherwise have been….”

Archbishop Desmond Tutu (L), the keynote speaker at Ebenezer Baptist Church at the annual Martin Luther King, Jr. Commemorative Service, chats with Coretta Scott King, wife of slain civil rights leader Martin Luther King, Jr. in Atlanta January 18 during the anniversary of Kings' 70th birthday celebration.

(credit:Reuters Photographer / Reuters)