David Cameron's Starter Homes Policy Has Been Blasted By Just About Everyone

Here's Why Cameron's 'Starter Homes' Policy Has Been Completely Torn Apart
|

David Cameron’s pledge to turn "Generation Rent" into "Generation Buy" has prompted outrage from housing campaigners who say his plan will do nothing to help struggling renters.

The move means developers are no longer required to include low-cost rented housing in construction plans, but can instead fulfill their 'affordable homes' requirement with 'starter homes' which must be sold at 20% below market rate.

In his leader’s speech to the Tory conference, the Prime Minister is set to unveil proposals to help him hit his manifesto pledge to build 200,000 more low-cost homes for first-time buyers by 2020.

But housing charities and groups have blasted the plans, saying that so-called starter homes are often only affordable for high-earners, meaning the policy does nothing for people on low incomes.

Open Image Modal

The new housing policy has not gone down well with housing charities and organisations

Homes for sale homes under Cameron's new scheme could be priced at up to £450,000 in London and £250,000 outside London.

The plans will also "undermine" requirements on developers to build cheap homes for rent, which they argue are desperately needed, critics say.

Developers building new housing are required by law to include some 'affordable' housing in new developments.

The term “affordable housing” is currently used to describe homes for rent at 80% of the market rate.

Under the new policy, the definition will be changed to include 'starter homes' – offered for sale to people under 40 at a discount of up to 20% off the normal price.

Campbell Robb, chief executive of housing charity Shelter, said: “You don't solve an affordability crisis by getting rid of the few affordable homes we're building, yet that's exactly what this policy will do.”

Robb continued: “Today's announcement confirms our fears that starter homes costing up to £450,000 will be built at the expense of the genuinely affordable homes this country desperately needs.

“Our research has shown that these starter homes will too often only be 'affordable' for higher earners, not the millions of people working hard for an average wage who will be left stuck in expensive private renting.

“There's nothing wrong with helping people onto the property ladder, but the government has to invest in genuinely affordable homes to buy and rent for all of those on ordinary incomes who are bearing the brunt of this crisis."

Open Image Modal

David Cameron claims the policy will turn 'Generation Rent' into 'Generation Buy'

Many people on social media also seemed less than impressed with the prime minister’s new policy…

Campaign group Generation Rent was conerned that the plans did nothing to address the problems faced by millions of renters around the country.

Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Betsy Dillner, Generation Rent’s director, said: “[David Cameron] is once again nibbling away at the edges of the housing crisis. We need to build 200,000 a year and he's been saying that 83% of people would rather buy than rent. But what is he going to do for the rest of the 9 million who are stuck renting?"

"No doubt we need to increase the supply of affordable homes but this policy is undermining the of developers' obligation to provide affordable homes for rent.

"We would like to see more security measures for the private rented sector. Private rents are unaffordable.

"We're talking about making sure we actually have the supply of low cost homes for everyone's income bracket.

“He's undermining the obligation to provide social housing from the private sector. So where are people on low incomes going to live? We haven't seen an answer to that question yet."

The problem could also be compounded by the loss of council houses when those purchased under the Right To Buy scheme are not replaced. It was revealed in September that only one in 10 homes sold off under the flagship Tory scheme had been replaced with a new council house as promised.

20 shocking facts about private renting
House prices are officially a complete joke(01 of20)
Open Image Modal
A staggering 80% of properties in England are unaffordable to a family of renters on average wages looking to buy their first home, Shelter has found. There are just 43 homes in London that the charity classes as genuinely affordable - and that includes house boats and one mobile home. (credit:fazon1 via Getty Images)
Rents are rocketing(02 of20)
Open Image Modal
Rental costs in England and Wales have risen 15.2 per cent since the last general election, faster than the rate of inflation, an index from Your Move and Reeds Rains estate agents shows. But - in another blow to those hoping to buy - house prices have risen even faster, at 28% to an average price of £268,000, according to the Office for National Statistics. (credit:Niki van Velden via Getty Images)
And it's not just renters who are suffering...(03 of20)
Open Image Modal
It's their friends and family too. An exclusive poll for HuffPost UK found that 19% of people need help from their friends or relatives to pay their rent. (credit:MARIA TOUTOUDAKI via Getty Images)
Renting for life will cost you dearly(04 of20)
Open Image Modal
Renting ‘lifers’ will be over half a million pounds worse off than those who buy a home in their twenties, according to Shelter. This reveals the huge financial cost of being priced out of homeownership for a lifetime - a likely fate for many people if the situation we're in continues. In London, the amount you could lose is an even more eye-watering £1.36 million. (credit:Gareth Fuller/PA Wire)
Rent is forcing people cut back on essentials(05 of20)
Open Image Modal
Rent is so expensive that two in five private renters (39%) say they have had to cut back on heating because of the cost of rent, while a third (33%) say that they have had to cut back on food, the Generation Rent campaign claimed in 2014. (credit:Jupiterimages via Getty Images)
And it's not just about the money(06 of20)
Open Image Modal
Being priced out of homeownership damages more than just your wallet: your wellbeing can suffer too. Shelter research found damaging social and emotional impacts of being unable to buy a home, including feeling unstable or alienated in your career or relationships, or jealous of friends who had help from family to buy a home.

Some people are even put off parenthood because of uncertain housing situations - or risk their children’s wellbeing by not having enough space in a rented home.
(credit:Tara Moore via Getty Images)
Bad landlords are far too common(07 of20)
Open Image Modal
The National Landlords Association finds that around 12 or 13 per cent of tenants it surveys say they think they have dealt with a rogue landlord - someone acting in a criminal manner. While it's not a majority, that's over a million, and "far too many" - as the head of the association Richard Lambert admitted to HuffPost UK. (credit:Chris Mellor via Getty Images)
Government policies may be making things worse(08 of20)
Open Image Modal
According to housing campaigners, many policies like the Help To Buy ISA, and the Tories's plan to extend the Right To Buy scheme to housing association properties, will simply make things worse, by pushing up house prices while not adding desperately needed homes to the market. (credit:Jupiterimages via Getty Images)
Renters are valuable voters - yet they're being forgotten(09 of20)
Open Image Modal
Generation Rent conducted a poll of 1,004 private renters and found that 35% say that they tend to change which party they vote for between different General Elections, making them potential swing voters.

With 11 million people in the private rented sector in England, and most of them saying that renting is the thing they spend the most money on, you'd think that politicians would listen up - but historically little has been done to address private renters' concerns, despite a flurry of promises in the last days of the election campaign.
(credit:Bloomberg via Getty Images)
Only 6 in 10 renters can actually vote(10 of20)
Open Image Modal
Private renters are far less able to make their voices heard by politicians because only 63% are registered to vote, compared to 94% of people who own their home, according to the electoral commission. And, as the electoral register is used for credit checks, not being on it could also stop a renter getting a mortgage, if they are ever able to afford buying. (credit:Floresco Images via Getty Images)
The sector is growing too big, too fast(11 of20)
Open Image Modal
Private renting is booming – but not in a good way, as there isn't enough good housing for rent. When Shelter started a campaign last year to make 'revenge evictions' illegal (which it succeeded on) the movement was called '9 Million Renters' after the number of renters in the UK. Now, it would have to be renamed '11 million Renters.' (credit:inxti via Getty Images)
They are renting their way into poverty(12 of20)
Open Image Modal
The Joseph Rowntree Foundation has predicted that, without action, rents will rise twice as fast as inflation, meaning that by 2040 half of all private renters (currently 6 million people ) would be living in poverty because of the cost of rent.

Private renters’ rights campaigner Heather Kennedy claims she volunteered at a soup kitchen, and found that "about a third of the people there were in private rented [accommodation]."

"It really struck me that the imbalance of power is much worse the lower down you get in the market," she told The Guardian, "so if you are living really at the bottom end of the market, that’s where you’ve got the most exploitative conditions, you’ve got landlords that really have absolutely no respect for the wellbeing of their tenants and it’s all happening completely under the radar.”
(credit:BEN STANSALL via Getty Images)
Renting is the biggest route to homelessness(13 of20)
Open Image Modal
Being evicted from private renting is now the number one path to homelessness, according to Shelter - mainly because landlords won't renew contracts, or people can't afford their rent. (credit:Christopher Furlong via Getty Images)
Most renters simply don't want to be there(14 of20)
Open Image Modal
Most renters don’t want to be renting. Two-thirds of private renters (67%) would rather own their home, while another 10% would prefer to be in social housing, the Generation Rent campaign says. (credit:Gary Burchell via Getty Images)
Things shouldn't be like this(15 of20)
Open Image Modal
The private rented sector is housing more and more people that it wasn't designed to cater for - individuals and families who might ordinarily have been in social housing or supported housing. They can be vulnerable and landlords can discriminate against people who are claiming housing benefit. (credit:Cultura/Nick Daly via Getty Images)
Even if it doesn't affect you, it will affect someone you know(16 of20)
Open Image Modal
Even if you own a swanky pad, the crisis may be touching you - most of us (57%) say they, or someone they know, is struggling to buy or rent a suitable home, according to the Generation Rent. (credit:Bloomberg via Getty Images)
We could be so happy(17 of20)
Open Image Modal
The sad thing is that people could be perfectly happy with renting. A poll for flatshare site Weroom found that 55% of people (and 66% of over 35s) would rather rent than buy a home - if renting offered secure tenancies and affordable rents.

That's a big if, but it makes clear that owning is not something people crave simply for investment purposes, it's also to escape the instability of renting.
(credit:Bloomberg via Getty Images)
Private renting is used as a plaster for council housing(18 of20)
Open Image Modal
Councils are offering landlords cash payments of up to £4,000 to house homeless families, according to The Guardian, as a shortage of council housing forces them to look to the private sector.

The “golden hellos” were seized on by critics of the Tory plans to extend Right To Buy - meaning that there would even fewer council homes for rent when local authorities are clearly already having difficulties housing people.
(credit:LatitudeStock - David Williams via Getty Images)
Activism has a slow payoff(19 of20)
Open Image Modal
We had the biggest ever housing rally in Britain, from the Homes For Britain campaign in March - and while politicians may have noticed the message (build more homes) they didn't really show it.

The next major political announcement was the Conservatives's plant o extend Right To Buy to housing associations, which will increase competition for houses rather than providing more, campaigners say, and united the housing sector in condemnation.
Uncertainty in old age(20 of20)
Open Image Modal
With the collapse of pensions, people who own a home may rely on their investment to support them when the retire. But what of the millions priced out of buying?

"We haven't even begun to get into the thought process around if more and more people stay renting privately until they are in their 40s and 50s, what impact that has on their pensions," says Richard Lambert, the CEO of the National Landlords Association.
(credit:Peter Chadwick LRPS via Getty Images)