The Sun Forced To U-turn On Jeremy Corbyn Privy Council 'Short Money' Claims

The Sun Has Been Forced Into A Front Page Corbyn Correction
|

The Sun newspaper has been forced to correct a "significantly misleading" front page article that attacked Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn.

It was censured by press regulator Ipso, which rubbished the original September 15 piece and ruled that tabloid bosses wrongly accused Corbyn of being a "hypocrite".

The Murdoch-owned paper was forced to publish an adjudication which clarified it had offered "significantly misleading coverage" of the issue, which it then later failed to correct.

Open Image Modal

'Court Jezter' - the original Sun front page

The Sun had reported that Corbyn "will kiss the Queen’s hand on bended knee in a humiliating personal climbdown". It added he was intending to become a privy counsellor so he could “grab £6.2m” of state cash.

But following a complaint from one ex-Labour staff member, Ipso said that there was no formal connection between Corbyn’s membership of the Monarch's council and the allocation of funding for opposition parties – referred to as 'short money'.

Press regulator executives said in a statement published in Tuesday's edition of the Sun: "Ipso's Complaints Committee found that it was significantly misleading to claim that Labour's access to the £6.2m depended on whether Mr Corbyn was a member of the Privy Council.

"The two were not formally connected and the article did not make clear how a majority of the funding was in fact allocated.

"The Committee upheld the complaint as a breach of Clause 1 [Accuracy].

"The newspaper failed to correct the significantly misleading coverage promptly and Ipso required The Sun to publish this adjudication."

To comply with the order to print a reference to this week's adjudication on its front page, the Sun included 11 words on page one, in a space roughly 15mm by 35mm. The rest of the adjudication appeared on page two.

Rose Brocklehurst, a former Labour press officer in the 1980s, was behind the complaint which led to Tuesday's tabloid climbdown.

Speaking to the Independent, she admonished Sun editors for printing a "completely spurious, nasty and wrong" front page.

"Ipso is an improvement on the PCC [its predecessor, the Press Complaints Commission] if only because they have courteous complaints officers whose aim is to try to mediate a satisfactory conclusion for both parties," she said.

"In this case, the mediation failed because I became even more determined when the Sun were rude to me while I extended all courtesy to them in correspondence.

Open Image Modal

Corbyn meets the media scrum outside his house

"The front page story was in my view completely spurious, nasty and wrong. My whole Ipso experience showed that an individual needs determination and courage to enter the complaints process.”

Corbyn's office has not yet offered comment on the ruling, but the leader of the opposition told The Huffington Post UK in an interview published yesterday that some national newspapers could be "routinely abusive".

“I’m a member of the NUJ [National Union of Journalists], I fully understand the importance of an independent media, an investigative media, I get all that," Corbyn said.

"What I don’t get is the way in which the media, particularly the print media, can be routinely abusive and feel that that is perfectly OK.

“I think there does need to be multiplicity of ownership. There does need to be a wide variety of it, and no crossover between broadcast and print media. That’s what I’d want to see. So I am looking at those issues and we will put forward something on it."

“But I also recognise that media has changed a great deal. Social media and internet have completely changed the whole game.

Story continues below

Why The Sun And Corbyn Don't Get Along
Revealing His 'Draining' Hobby(01 of07)
Open Image Modal
Jeremy Corbyn's penchant for pipes raised eyebrows, not least at the Sun who reveled in the details of his draining ambitions.

He is reported to have said: “My mother always said there’s history in drain covers. I take pictures of them. People think it’s a little odd, but there we are.”

And to ram home the point to its readers, the paper placed Corbyn at the bottom of a list of "Britains Dullest Men".

The Labour leader stands alongside Pensioner David Grisenthwaite who keeps a lawn-mowing diary, Peter Willis who photographs postboxes, Paul Rabbitts who travels to bandstands across the UK and traffic cone "fanatic" David Morgan.
(credit:fotog via Getty Images)
Criticising His Choice Of TV News(02 of07)
Open Image Modal
In a less-than-subtle attempt to suggest Corbyn is out of touch, the Sun managed to turn his choice of television news into a headline-leading criticism.

Under the headline "Al Jezeera", it claimed that his estranged niece observed the Labour leader's TV viewing while she lived in his home.

Jasmin Alvarez told the paper: “Jeremy loved watching TV — he always had the news on, BBC, ITV and his favourite was Channel 4 news. He watched foreign news including Al Jazeera."

The Arab-owned channel is primarily focussed on high-quality foreign news, despatching reports from across the Middle East, Asia and Africa.

But rather than bolstering Corbyn's foreign policy credentials, his total snub of fellow Rupert Murdoch stablemate Sky News left the Sun fuming.

Fancy that!
(credit:STAN HONDA/AFP/Getty Images)
Making Unflattering Comparisons(03 of07)
Open Image Modal
The Sun reacted with fervour to Jeremy Corbyn's first speech as leader to the Labour Party conference, pulling out all the stops to ridicule him in the process.

In an sensational double-page spread the paper devoted countless column inches for everything from what Corbyn said, what it thought he meant, how he dressed, and how he looked:

Click here for a zoomable version


And everyone was in on it. Corbyn's "Alternative Marxist Universe" was lamented by the Sun's leader writer, his fashion sense was taken down by the style editor, while the diarists and political team focused on the meat of his speech.

Nothing like a common foe to bring a team together...
(credit:Karwai Tang via Getty Images)
Calling Him A Hypocrite(04 of07)
Open Image Modal
A classic Sun front page depicted Corbyn as a "Court Jezter" allegedly motivated to "kiss the Queen's hand" to "grab £6.2m" in public funds.

Detailing events which have yet to come to pass, the paper noted that the Labour leader would rescind his Republican credentials in order to "trouser" public cash.

As leader of the opposition, Corbyn is entitled to money to keep his official office afloat and to pay for increased expenses.

But this basic function of democracy was swept aside by the paper as it deemed Corbyn's anti-Monarchy stance sacrosanct to all else.

Jeremy Corbyn has yet to meet the Queen as a member of her Privy Council.
(credit:The Sun)
Criticising His Breakfast(05 of07)
Open Image Modal
In a bizarre column carried in the Sun on Sunday, Conservative Mayor of London Boris Johnson denounced Corbyn as a "muesli-munching throwback."

Despite having a very lucrative contract to write for The Daily Telegraph, the Sun drafted in Boris to bring his signature waffle to its pages - providing it with quips and puns it has used ever since.

Corbyn's presumed choice of breakfast clearly gave Johnson food for thought. Though we've no confirmation exactly what kind of morning food the leader enjoys...
(credit:Thomas Trutschel via Getty Images)
Publishing Details Of His Marriages(06 of07)
Open Image Modal
Lurid details of Corbyn's marriages have made canon fodder for the Sun.

Despite running the risk of presenting the Labour leader as even the least bit interesting, the paper has narrowed its focus on his personal relationships under the headline: "Very Red, Much Wed, Union Led".

The paper wrote: "His personal life has been just as unpredictable and turbulent... we can reveal how Corbyn, now an unlikely second favourite to lead the party, has secretly married for a third time — to a woman 20 years his junior."

Similar media coverage elicited a direct response from Corbyn who lamented the "personal" nature of reporting during his leadership contest as he accepted the nomination in London.

He told the assembled audience: “I say to journalists: attack public political figures, that’s ok, that’s what politics is about. But please don’t attack people who didn’t ask to be put in the limelight, leave them alone, leave them alone in all circumstances.”
(credit:Dan Kitwood via Getty Images)
But... He Might Have An Unlikely Ally(07 of07)
Open Image Modal
The Sun's former political editor and current columnist and leader writer has admitted it would be a mistake for top Tories to ignore Corbyn's rise to prominence.

Writing in the paper, Trevor Kavanagh said:

"They have far too hastily written off the Opposition leader off as a political third-rater, a shabbily dressed 1980s throwback, easily provoked and reluctant to engage with the media.

"They scoffed when he ducked an earlier summons to appear before Marr the previous week.

"Commentators dismissed his public utterances as rambling and incoherent.But there is clearly more to Jezza than meets the eye."


But Corbyn should probably put hopes of a complete change of heart at the Sun to one side.... for now.
(credit:Peter Macdiarmid via Getty Images)

"We have a 24-hour media age which has it’s ups and downs. The upside is that you can find things out very quickly, the downside is it can be completely inaccurate and gets a life of its own very quickly.

Some critics have pointed out that just three families own more than 60% of Britain’s national newspapers, leaving Corbyn to lay out his plans for a major shift in the print media industry.

“I would want a divestment of some of that, so share that out a bit more. Also local papers do play an important part in communities.

"There’s a monopoly. If you look at every region, the local papers have often all but disappeared and become some regional editorial function that lives off press releases.

"I’m an obsessive buyer of local papers. Wherever I go I buy a local paper, I read them on the train. Sometimes they’re great.

Speaking of 'Leveson 2' being put on the back-burner, Corbyn adds: “I’m concerned that they are delaying on it. It’s got to be done. We cannot have this degree of practice going on. What was exposed was utterly appalling practices, intrusion on individuals and it’s got to stop.”

Open Image Modal

Corbyn, complete with mug: 'HuffPost: It's just my cup of tea,' he joked

A spokesperson for the Sun claimed that it had not published a correction or apology.

"Contrary to what other publications not signed up to the press regulator are reporting, The Sun has not printed an apology or a correction," they told HuffPost UK.

"However, as a member of Ipso, we accept that we are obliged to publish critical adjudications with due prominence. We have done so today."