'My Big Gay Jewish Conversion': Simon Atkins Explores The Dilemma Of Sexuality And Religion In New BBC Three Documentary

Could converting to Judaism validate marriage in the eyes of God?
|

For many LGBT+ people of faith, their religion can often feel at odds with their sexuality, but a new BBC Three documentary is set to explore whether it is possible to for the two to be in harmony with one another. 

In ‘My Big Gay Jewish Conversion’, TV presenter Simon Atkins goes on a personal journey, as he explores whether converting to Judaism would validate any union with his boyfriend in the eyes of God. 

Having been brought up as a Roman Catholic, Simon didn’t realise the impact his religion had had on his lifestyle until he met Jewish boyfriend Matthew.

After becoming disillusioned with the Catholic church, Simon sets out to discover if Judaism is more tolerant of his sexuality than his own religion, and whether he can sacrifice his own beliefs. 

Open Image Modal
Simon Atkins fronts BBC Three's 'My Big Gay Jewish Conversion'
BBC

In the one-off documentary, which is available to stream on BBC iPlayer now, Simon begins by talking to a variety of people, including other gay Jewish men and the Rabbi at his boyfriend’s synagogue, who allows same-sex marriage.

While the people he meets seem very accepting of his lifestyle, Simon’s plans are thrown into doubt when he travels to the birthplace of Judaism, Israel. 

In Jerusalem, he is faced with more conservative and hostile views, and is also faced with the prospect of giving up on the Catholic core belief that Jesus Christ is the son of God. Will he be able to do that?

Speaking about his decision to explore the option of converting to Judaism in an exclusive vlog for HuffPost UK, Simon explained: “I wanted to make this documentary to create awareness, but from a personal point of view, I was unhappy with my faith. 

“When I met my boyfriend, I thought Jewish people had it all - the religion, the culture, the community, and they could get married in a synagogue and be preached to by a gay Rabbi. I felt robbed by the Catholic church. I wanted answers and I wanted to explore what my options were.”

He added: “I hope viewers will come away with a feeling of what it means to be gay and to be religious. There is no neat solution, it is a constant push and pull with extreme highs and lows. If you’re looking for answers from religion alone, you’re never going to find them.”

My Big Gay Jewish Conversion, available now on BBC Three bbc.co.uk/bbcthree

10 LGBT Rising Stars
Samira Wiley ('Orange Is The New Black' actress)(01 of10)
Open Image Modal
"I was just taught that love is the most powerful thing." (credit:Megan Mack via Getty Images)
Adore Delano (Drag performer/singer)(02 of10)
Open Image Modal
"My voice is not only for singing, I speak about body image issues, HIV rights, and many other topics that should be addressed when you have a platform like mine." (credit:Gabe Ginsberg via Getty Images)
Mary Lambert (singer/songwriter)(03 of10)
Open Image Modal
"Hearing women of all ages sing 'She Keeps Me Warm' at the top of their lungs - they don’t give a shit about what pronoun it is.

"They get that it’s about love, so I think that’s really given me perspective. I think people can deal with it, and they get it."
(credit:Paul Morigi via Getty Images)
Todrick Hall (YouTube star/singer)(04 of10)
Open Image Modal
"When you’re a person that’s trying to be a public figure and you’re black and you’re gay and for some people it’s a little too much for them to handle...

"I think there are a lot of people who are afraid to be who they are and if I have to sacrifice a little bit of fame and a little bit of success because I’m being 100 percent truthful with who I am, hopefully that will create a paved way for someone else."
(credit:Robin Marchant via Getty Images)
Ines Rau (model)(05 of10)
Open Image Modal
"It's all about what's in your heart. Gender and sexuality do not make you who you are. Your heart and actions do!" (credit:Instagram/Ines Rau)
Riley Carter Millington ('EastEnders' actor)(06 of10)
Open Image Modal
"I want to help make a difference. [Being trans] is a part of me and I want hopefully to make other people feel like they can come out, like they can feel that they’ve got support." (credit:Peter MacDiarmid/REX/Shutterstock)
Angel Haze (rapper)(07 of10)
Open Image Modal
"Sexuality is like having a favorite colour. It doesn’t rule you, you know? And I should be able to do whatever and whoever I want at any given time." (credit:Brian Killian via Getty Images)
Joe Lycett (stand-up comedian)(08 of10)
Open Image Modal
"Gender is fluid and I think it’s absolutely fascinating, so I talk about that a little bit in my show. I think it’s important some people do publicly go, 'Hey, I’m not straight and I’m not gay. I’m somewhere in the middle and that’s OK.'" (credit:David Fisher/REX/Shutterstock)
Ruby Tandoh (foodie/'Bake Off' finalist)(09 of10)
Open Image Modal
"To all the bros who hate social media, who pit it against 'real life' - I never would've had the courage to be me without Twitter's queer queens." (credit:Richard Saker/Rex/Shutterstock)
Troye Sivan (YouTube star/pop sensation)(10 of10)
Open Image Modal
'[Being gay] been a non-issue for me. But the same thing that’s been a blessing in my life can lead someone to suicide. Every time I hear about an LGBTQ kid committing suicide, it’s just so much frustration. I just think about lost potential because a parent wasn’t accepting or a friend wasn’t, and it ended an LGBTQ kid’s life.

"I really want the parents of my audience to see these videos actually. And realise that their reaction influences their kid’s entire experience. Showing them two sides of the coin: this is how it could go or this is how it could go. It’s up to you."
(credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)