Oscars 2019: News That 4 Categories Will Be Announced During Ad Breaks Does Not Go Down Well

A number of nominees and former winners have criticised the Academy's decision.

Several key figures from the world of cinema have criticised the Film Academy, following their announcement that a number of non-acting categories will not be aired live during the Oscars this year.

Earlier this week, it was confirmed that the Academy Awards for Best Cinematography, Best Editing, Best Live-Action Short and Best Make-Up/Hairstyling will be awarded during the ad breaks of this year’s ceremony.

Open Image Modal
The Oscars will take place later this month
Christopher Polk via Getty Images

This decision has irked a number of actors and directors, including Alfonso Cuarón, the Best Director nominee behind Roma, which is up for Best Picture at this year’s Oscars.

He pointed out: “In the history of CINEMA, masterpieces have existed without sound, without color, without a story, without actors and without music. No one single film has ever existed without CINEMAtography and without editing.”

Meanwhile, fellow Best Director nominee Spike Lee told the LA Times: “Without cinematographers and film editors, I would be lost, wandering in the cinema wilderness.”

Meanwhile, the president of the American Society Of Cinematographers said on the subject (via Deadline): “After receiving many comments on this matter from ASC members, I think I speak for many of them in declaring this a most unfortunate decision.”

But they aren’t the only ones annoyed at this decision, with several other stars venting their feelings on Twitter, including several Oscar nominees past and present…

Three-time Oscar-winning cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki noted in a since-deleted Instagram post that the Academy’s decision was an “unfortunate” one, branding cinematography and editing “the primordial compositions of cinema”.

Variety has claimed that the “emotionally resonant” moments from the four speeches not aired live will be shown later in the broadcast.

Of course, this isn’t the only case of messiness associated with this year’s Oscars, which is going ahead without a host for the first time in 30 years, following a debacle involving comedian Kevin Hart, who was not replaced after quitting the job when historic homophobic tweets of his resurfaced.

There’s also the reports that only two of the five Best Original Song nominees were originally going to be performed during the ceremony, which the Academy backtracked on, allegedly after pressure was put on them by Lady Gaga herself.

The 91st Academy Awards will go ahead on Sunday 24 February in Los Angeles.

Vintage Oscars Moments
Vintage Oscars Moments(01 of33)
Open Image Modal
Judy Garland and Mickey Rooney (1940) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments (1940)(02 of33)
Open Image Modal
Bette Davis and Johnny Favour (credit:Bettmann via Getty Images)
Vintage Oscars Moments(03 of33)
Open Image Modal
Audrey Hepburn (1954) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(04 of33)
Open Image Modal
Grace Kelly and Marlon Brando (1955) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(05 of33)
Open Image Modal
Charlton and Lydia Clarke Heston (1960) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(06 of33)
Open Image Modal
Elizabeth Taylor (1961) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(07 of33)
Open Image Modal
Elizabeth Taylor and Burt Lancaster (1961) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(08 of33)
Open Image Modal
Sidney Poitier (1964) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(09 of33)
Open Image Modal
Julie Andrews (1965) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(10 of33)
Open Image Modal
Julie Christie (1966) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(11 of33)
Open Image Modal
Elliot Gould and Barbra Streisand (1969) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(12 of33)
Open Image Modal
Frank Sinatra (1971) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(13 of33)
Open Image Modal
Liza Minnelli and her father Vicente Minnelli (1973) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(14 of33)
Open Image Modal
David Niven (1974) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(15 of33)
Open Image Modal
Shirley MacLaine, Jack Nicholson, and James L. Brooks (1974) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(16 of33)
Open Image Modal
John Travolta and Vanessa Redgrave (1978) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(17 of33)
Open Image Modal
Kirk Douglas and Raquel Welch (1978) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(18 of33)
Open Image Modal
Jane Fonda (1979) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(19 of33)
Open Image Modal
Meryl Streep and Dustin Hoffman (1980) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(20 of33)
Open Image Modal
Sally Field (1980) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(21 of33)
Open Image Modal
Jack Nicholson (1984) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(22 of33)
Open Image Modal
Bette Davis (1987) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(23 of33)
Open Image Modal
Cher and Michael Douglas (1988) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(24 of33)
Open Image Modal
Geena Davis (1989) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(25 of33)
Open Image Modal
Jodie Foster (1992) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(26 of33)
Open Image Modal
Brad Pitt and Juliette Lewis (1992) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(27 of33)
Open Image Modal
Sophia Loren (1993) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(28 of33)
Open Image Modal
Elton John and Tim Rice (1995) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(29 of33)
Open Image Modal
Claudia Schiffer, Pierce Brosnan and Naomi Campbell (1996) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(30 of33)
Open Image Modal
Cuba Gooding Jr (1997) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(31 of33)
Open Image Modal
Gwyneth Paltrow (1999) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars Moments(32 of33)
Open Image Modal
Angelina Jolie (2000) (credit:PA)
Vintage Oscars moments(33 of33)
Open Image Modal
Halle Berry and Denzel Washington (2002) (credit:Frank Micelotta Archive via Getty Images)