Amy Winehouse Documentary, 'Amy', Debuts At Cannes Film Festival: Reviews Praise Asif Kapadia's Film, But Mitch Winehouse Still Isn't Happy

'Amy' Lauded By Critics After Cannes Debut

‘Amy’, the documentary film about the life and career of the late Amy Winehouse, made its official debut at the Cannes Film Festival on Saturday night.

The film, which includes never-before-seen footage of the ‘Back To Black’ singer and interviews with those who knew her best, was shown in a midnight screening, and has already been lauded by the majority of critics.

Open Image Modal

The poster for 'Amy'

Here’s a selection of what some of the early reviews have had to say about ‘Amy’...

The Guardian 5/5:

“A star is born — all over again. Asif Kapadia’s documentary study of the great British soul queen Amy Winehouse is stunningly moving and powerful: intimate, passionate, often shocking, and almost mesmerically absorbing... It is an overwhelming story, and despite everyone knowing the ending, it is as gripping as a thriller: Kapadia has fashioned and shaped it with masterly flair.”

“As a whole, Amy is an emotionally stirring and technically polished tribute, its sprawling mass of diverse source material elegantly cleaned up, color-corrected and shaped into a satisfying narrative. If Kapadia’s film feels like an incomplete story, that is mainly because Winehouse’s life was itself incomplete.”

The Independent 5/5:

“There is an unutterable sadness at the heart of Asif Kapadia’s brilliant new film about Amy Winehouse, the singer who died from alcohol poisoning in 2011 aged only 27…. Kapadia's film is steeped in regret and grief over what became of its subject and yet it never loses its sense of awe about what she achieved.”

“Hardly innovative in form, but boasting the same depth of feeling and breadth of archival material that made Kapadia’s “Senna” so rewarding, this lengthy but immersive portrait will hit hard with viewers who regard Winehouse among the great lost voices not just of a generation, but of an entire musical genre.”

The Wrap:

“‘Amy’ the movie never comes close to showing us why Amy the singer was so great; instead, it settles for showing up, in uncomfortable detail, why Amy the woman could not handle the success her talent brought her. The film is disturbing and tawdry, hard to watch but tough to shake.”

“Winehouse’s most famous song, ‘Rehab’, is all about not seeking treatment for addiction. As such, while it’s easy to empathise with her story, her struggles have been largely simplified by their reflection in popular culture. Two hours in the company of Kapadia’s heartbreaking documentary change all that.”

However, while the film has received largely positive reviews from critics, not everyone is happy about ‘Amy’, including her father, Mitch Winehouse, who has spoken out against the documentary on several occasions.

Branding the film a “wasted opportunity” in his review for The Sun, Mitch has now said: “Rather than getting to the heart of who Amy was as a person, as a musician, friend and daughter, this is a film with an agenda.

“Instead of taking seriously the responsibility of finding different perspectives and balance as her biographers, they have chosen to use parts of quotes, lay blame and base the story on the testimony of a very narrow pool of speakers.”

“Those who didn’t know Amy might enjoy the film, but anyone who really knew her will see it for what it is: nothing more than a piece of orchestrated spin.”

Following its debut in Cannes, ‘Amy’ will arrive in UK cinemas on 3 July.

Amy Winehouse
BRIT Awards 2008 - Show - London(01 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse and Mark Ronson on stage, during the BRIT Awards 2008, at Earls Court in central London. (credit:PA)
BRIT Awards 2007 - Show(02 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs on stage during the Brit Awards 2007 at Earls Court Exhibition Centre in central London. (credit:PA)
MTV Movie Awards 2007(03 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse arrives for the 2007 MTV Movie awards at the Gibson Amphitheatre, Universal City, Los Angeles. (credit:PA)
Winehouse in court(04 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse arrives with her father Mitch (right) at City of Westminster Magistrates Court in London for her court appearance. (credit:PA)
46664 Concert - London(05 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse leads the celebrations on stage at the 46664 concert honouring Nelson Mandela's ninetieth birthday in Hyde Park, London. (credit:PA)
The Mojo Honours List Award Ceremony - London(06 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse and her boyfriend Blake Fielder-Civil arrive for the Mojo Honours List award ceremony at The Brewery, east London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse at court - London(07 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse leaving Westminster Magistrates Court in central London, as she stands trial on a charge of assault. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse Sighting - London(08 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse spotted out and about in Soho, central London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse at court - London(09 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse arrives at Westminster Magistrates Court on the second of a trial for alleged assault. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse sighting - London(10 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse hand in hand with Tyler James in Covent Garden, London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse Sighting - London(11 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse seen in Covent Garden, London. (credit:PA)
The Libertines gig - London(12 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse watches the Libertines perform on stage at the Forum in Highgate, London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse & Pete Doherty Sighting - London(13 of48)
Open Image Modal
Singers Pete Doherty and Amy Winehouse spotted out in central London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse Leaving For Court - London(14 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse, and her father Mitch, leave her north London home for her court appearance. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse Sighting - London(15 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse spotted out and about at 4am. The singer has been keeping some erratic hours of late and last night was no different. After leaving her new Bow home at 4am, Amy hot footed it back to the homeland Camden where she went shopping for ice pops and hooked up with pal Sadie Frost and her pal Tommy. (credit:PA)
Blake Fielder-Civil in court(16 of48)
Open Image Modal
Singer Amy Winehouse arrives at Thames Magistrates Court, east London, to see her husband, Blake Fielder-Civil, appear on charges of perverting the course of justice. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse Sighting - London(17 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse spotted on a night out in Camden, north London. (credit:PA)
BRIT Awards 2008 - Show - London(18 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse on stage at the Brit Awards 2008, Earls Court, London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse Sighting - Camden(19 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse spotted out in Camden, north London. (credit:PA)
46664 Concert - London(20 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs during the 46664 concert honouring Nelson Mandela's ninetieth birthday in Hyde Park, London. (credit:PA)
Glastonbury Festival 2008 - Day Two(21 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs on the Pyramid Stage during day two of the Glastonbury Festival, Somerset. (credit:PA)
SHOWBIZ Winehouse Launch(22 of48)
Open Image Modal
Singer Amy Winehouse during her performance at HMV Oxford Street, central London, where she celebrated the release of her new single Take The Box and signed autographs. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse - Q Awards(23 of48)
Open Image Modal
Singer Amy Winehouse backstage during the 15th annual Q Awards at Grosvenor House in London's Park Lane. Jonathan Ross hosts the music magazine awards honouring the best in the industry. (credit:PA)
Ivor Novello Awards - London(24 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse wins the Best Contemporary song award for her song 'Rehab' at the Ivor Novello Awards held at the Grosvenor House Hotel in cental London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse Sighting - London(25 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse and Dionne Bromfield seen out and about in Camden, north London. (credit:PA)
The 2008 Ivor Novello Awards - London(26 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse and her dad Mitch during the 2008 Ivor Novello Awards, at Grosvenor House, central London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse (27 of48)
Open Image Modal
FILE - In this July 24, 2009 file photo, British singer Amy Winehouse leaves Westminster magistrates court in London after a judge acquitted her of assaulting a fan who asked to take her picture. Winehouse had no illegal drugs in her system when she died, and it is still unclear what killed the singer, her family said Tuesday, Aug. 23, 2011. The family said in a statement that toxicology tests showed "alcohol was present" in the singer's body but it hasn't yet been determined if it contributed to her death. (AP Photo/Kirsty Wigglesworth) (credit:AP)
Amy Winehouse(28 of48)
Open Image Modal
FILE -- In this Feb. 20, 2008, file photo, Amy Winehouse performs at the Brit Awards 2008 in London. A new album of recordings by the late soul singer Amy Winehouse will be released in December, Island Records said Monday Oct. 31, 2011. It said "Lioness: Hidden Treasures" will contain 12 songs previously unreleased tracks, alternative versions of existing hits and brand new songs recorded by the beehive-wearing singer who died at her London home on July 23. .(AP Photo/Matt Dunham, file) (credit:AP)
Amy Winehouse (29 of48)
Open Image Modal
FILE - In this June 27, 2008 file photo, British singer-songwriter Amy Winehouse performs at the 46664 charity concert in honor of Nelson Mandela's 90th birthday in London. Winehouse had written all the songs that were to appear on her third album. She even picked out song titles. But music producer Salaam Remi said the singer was not rushing to release that new material. Only two of the tracks Winehouse wrote were recorded and appear on her compilation album, Lioness: Hidden Treasures. It will be out on Dec. 5. (AP Photo/Lefteris Pitarakis, File) (credit:AP)
T in the Park festival 2008 - Scotland(30 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs on the main stage at T in the Park music festival near Kinross in Scotland. (credit:PA)
Isle of Wight Festival 2007(31 of48)
Open Image Modal
EDITORIAL USE ONLY: Amy Winehouse performing at the Isle of Wight Festival in Seaclose Park on the Isle of Wight. Picture date: Saturday June 9, 2007. (credit:PA)
Mercury Music Prize - London(32 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs during the Nationwide Mercury Music Prize at the Grosvenor House Hotel in central London. (credit:PA)
Music - Amy Winehouse - Vodafone TBA - Bristol(33 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs during an exclusive Vodafone TBA concert at Circomedia in Bristol. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse in concert(34 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs at the Union Chapel in Islington, north London during a MENCAP benefit concert. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse(35 of48)
Open Image Modal
FILE - In this Friday Feb. 16, 2007 file photo British singer Amy Winehouse poses for photographs after being interviewed by the Associated Press at a studio in north London. British officials say the coroner who oversaw the inquest into the death of singer Amy Winehouse has resigned after her qualifications were questioned. Winehouse's relatives said they were still absorbing the implications of the news. In October, coroner Suzanne Greenaway ruled that the soul singer had died from accidental alcohol poisoning. (AP Photo/Matt Dunham, File) (credit:AP)
The Brit Awards 2007 - Arrivals(36 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse arrives for the Brit Awards 2007 at Earls Court Exhibition Centre in central London. (credit:PA)
V Festival 2008 - Essex(37 of48)
Open Image Modal
EDITORIAL USE ONLY : Amy Winehouse performs on the second day of the V Festival at Hylands Park, Chelmsford, Essex. (credit:PA)
MTV Movie Awards 2007(38 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse and her husband Blake Fielder-Civil arrive for the 2007 MTV Movie awards at the Gibson Amphitheatre, Universal City, Los Angeles. (credit:PA)
Oxegen Festival 2008 - Ireland(39 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs at the Oxegen music festival which runs all weekend at Punchestown Racecourse in Co. Kildare. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse sighting - London(40 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse hand in hand with Tyler James in Covent Garden, London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse(41 of48)
Open Image Modal
En esta fotografía de archivo del 3 de junio de 2007, se ve a la cantante británica Amy Winehouse a su llegada a los MTV Movie Awards en Los Angeles. La familia de Amy Winehouse puso a la venta la casa en Londres que era propiedad de la desaparecida cantante por 2,7 millones de libras (4,2 millones de dólares). (Foto AP/Kevork Djansezian, Archivo) (credit:AP)
BRIT Awards 2007 - Show(42 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse performs on stage during the Brit Awards 2007 at Earls Court Exhibition Centre in central London. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse(43 of48)
Open Image Modal
En esta foto de archivo del 16 de febrero del 2007, Amy Winehouse posa en un estudio en el norte de Londres. Mitch Winehouse, el padre de la cantante británica, dice que le sido muy difícil disfrutar del exitoso álbum de su hija "Back to Black" porque las canciones hablan de su ex esposo, Blake Fielder-Civil, a quien culpa de llevarla al alcoholismo y la drogadicción, detallando su larga caída en el libro, "Amy, My Daughter". (AP Foto/Matt Dunham, Archivo) (credit:AP)
Reg Traviss rape charge(44 of48)
Open Image Modal
File photo dated 13/07/2010 of Amy Winehouse with Reg Traviss, who has been charged with two counts of rape, sources said today. (credit:PA)
'I never knew how talented Amy was'(45 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse and her dad Mitch who has admitted that he realised how talented his daughter was only after she died. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse sales(46 of48)
Open Image Modal
File photo dated 22/06/07 of singer Amy Winehouse, who is still proving to be one of the most popular British recording artists of modern time, with fans buying more than 1.7 million copies of her recordings in the year since her death. (credit:PA)
Amy Winehouse(47 of48)
Open Image Modal
En esta foto de archivo del 8 de enero del 201, Amy Winehouse canta durante un concierto en Florianopolis, Brasil. Winehouse murió hace un año, el 23 de julio del 2011, a causa de un envenenamiento etílico accidental. Tenía 27 años. (AP Foto/Nabor Goulart, Archivo) (credit:AP)
Amy with Blake(48 of48)
Open Image Modal
Amy Winehouse with Blake Fielder-Civil, (credit:PA)